This noticeboard is for discussing the application of the biographies of living people (BLP) policy to article content. Please seek to resolve issues on the article talk page first, and only post here if that discussion requires additional input.
Do not copy and paste defamatory material here; instead, link to a diff showing the problem.
Editors are encouraged to assist editors regarding the reports below. Administrators may impose contentious topic restrictions to enforce policies.
Notes for volunteers
How do I mark an incident as resolved or addressed?
You can use {{Resolved|Your reason here ~~~~}} at the top of the section containing the report. At least leave a comment about a BLP report, if doing so might spare other editors the task of needlessly repeating some of what you have done.
Manually search BLPs for violations by using advanced search parameters. This link will search for X in the category of BLPs. Change X in the URL to the keyword you are looking for; alternatively, type X incategory: Living_people (the underscore is necessary) in the search bar.
An edit war took place at Adrianne Black from the 24th to the 26th. Black is a trans person and the image in the article portrays them before their transition. The edit war began when an editor removed the photo arguing it is disrespectful to use a pre-transition photo on the page . This edit was reverted and it spiraled from there. Looking at the edit summaries two of the people removing it cite MOS:OMIMG and MOS:GIDINFO, while those reinserting it don't seem to make any similar alternative cites to guidelines. What gave me pause was that an admin came along at the end, reverted the photo back in and then immediately full protected the page in their preferred version. I note that another admin who semiprotected it did not revert any edits and just attempted to stop the edit warring.
Black is a living person, so the article falls under WP:BLP. Noting the guidelines cited, one of which states "Avoid using an out-of-date, pre-coming-out photo of a transgender subject as a lead image. If no other photos are available, it is generally better to have no lead image at all. In general, avoid using pre-coming-out photos unless the subject's pre-transition appearance is especially well-known and notable. The article about Laverne Cox, for example, is better without any pre-coming-out photos since the way she looked pre-transition is not well known. Conversely, the Caitlyn Jenner article does contain photos from before her transition because she was a well known Olympic athlete, so her appearance at the time is relevant to the article, though none are in the lead section.", this image could very well be considered a BLP violation and should be removed unless those wishing to keep it can present a valid, policy based reason for it. WP:BLPIMAGE should apply as including this pre-transition image is akin to deadnaming. - The literary leader of the age✉ 18:23, 30 October 2026 (UTC)
I think the image is relevant for the article as it directly relates her main source of notability (her and her father) but should probably not be the lead image since it no longer representative of her as a person. She received GNG-worthy coverage before she came out and it's directly related to her relationship to Don Black. PARAKANYAA (talk) 23:03, 30 October 2026 (UTC)
At a minimum it must be removed from the infobox and lede. However, the image doesn't impart any useful information not already established in the prose (that her father is Don Black). Additionally, Adrianne's appearance was not a matter of public discussion until she transitioned, so I'm not convinced of a need to see what she looked like pre-transition. - The literary leader of the age✉ 15:29, 31 October 2026 (UTC)
There is no image that imparts anything that cannot be explained in text. I am unconvinced by this argument. PARAKANYAA (talk) 16:20, 31 October 2026 (UTC)
That is a 100% false claim, substantiated by the fact that WP:NFCC #8 reads "Non-free content is used only if its presence would significantly increase readers' understanding of the article topic, and its omission would be detrimental to that understanding." If your statement were true then we wouldn't have that part of the NFCC policy.
So what's your argument for keeping the image? Because someone wants to see what they look like? Yet the image doesn't look like the article subject any more than if it was a photo of them as a fetus. Photos should be representative of the article's subject. Not just there "because we have this free photo". - The literary leader of the age✉ 21:49, 8 November 2026 (UTC)
"significantly increase" is not "a need", as you said. I think the image significantly increases understanding of her involvement with her father. But also, eh, it is not a hill I will die on. PARAKANYAA (talk) 00:21, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
Hello! I am the person who cited MOS:GIDINFO, and I just wanted to put my two cents here. I agree that the image is definitely relevant but it definitely should not be part of the infobox. The belief that I hold is that until a proper image is provided for purpose of being a lead image, the image should be removed outright and only added again under two conditions, one, that it is deemed relevant in further conversation regarding the article, and two, that a new and more accurate image is added to the infobox.
I am starting a discussion here per @Daniel Case:'s recommendation on the article's talk page. Please note I also opened a discussion on the COI noticeboard. The disputed content is related to a November 2006 incident in which Zolnierczyk later pled guilty to electronic voyeurism. I re-added the information to the article, with my reasoning given on the talk page: "I've re-added this information to the article. It was well-covered in significant, reliable sources, and not including it at all would amount to censorship. I don't think it falls under undue weight due to the seriousness of the incident and the coverage received." Pinging the users who participated in the talk page discussion; @BusterD:, @Hzolnier:, @Melcous:, @Rockingchair181921:Joeykai (talk) 05:43, 2 November 2026 (UTC)
As always with this sort of thing, the best way to establish long term significance and so WP:DUE is with sources. This happened in 2008. The subject seemed to remain active in their career with coverage until 2019. The only sources for this seem to be in 2008 when he pled guilty. Are there any sources since then which at least mention it? Nil Einne (talk) 09:11, 3 November 2026 (UTC)
@Nil Einne:, Yes, the sources are from 2008. For that reason, I agree with @Melcous: comment on the talk page, that the the length/detail of the disputed content be reviewed. I still believe that removing the content entirely would amount to censorship given the depth of coverage in those significant, reliable sources from 2008, and again, taking into account the seriousness of the incident. Joeykai (talk) 04:24, 7 November 2026 (UTC)
No it would not amount to censorship. It's entirely reasonable to conclude it clearly lacks any long term significance since no one has talked about it since then. Especially if there have been several RS with significant coverage of the subject (i.e. more than just routine news reports such as they were traded here recently, they started/didn't start in this game, their performance this year was but stuff which discusses the life and career of the subject in more depth) which I have not investigated. The seriousness of the incident is best decided by sources not editors. And sources don't seem to think it's serious if they never bothered to mention it since 2008 if they regular discuss the subject especially as I said if they do so in depth. Coverage in 2008 seems to just be routine news reports as things happened rather than in depth. Even if you disagree, it's not conducive to discussion to claim it's censorship, frankly it's uncivil IMO so I suggest you stop saying that. Nil Einne (talk) 06:14, 7 November 2026 (UTC)
I also bristle when this is described as "censorship". Nobody is trying to keep anybody who wants to from publicizing this information anywhere they want other than Wikipedia. Most certainly, the government is not using its powers to prevent anyone from doing so.
I daresay that one who would call this "censorship" understands the concept to a slightly lesser degree than a fork knows the taste of the food on it. It is a sad commentary on the warped understanding of free speech that so unfortunately has come to prevail in our time that this can even be called "censorship" in a public forum. Our schools need to teach that "not getting to say what you want where you want and when you want" ≠ censorship.
A couple of years ago we had
:::another discussion here at BLP/N that, like so many discussions here, spilled over from the article talk page about whether we should use the name of George Santos's ex-wife in the section of the article about his (questionable) first marriage. Some reliable sources have published it, but not many, and she has assiduously avoided publicity. The argument for doing so was that, well, it's been published, as if we had some duty to do so once reliable sources had published it.
That argument, like this fatuous "censorship" claim, grounded itself deeply in the letter of BLP while missing its spirit, indeed missing that it even has a spirit. While we can and very often do remove material, even material which might be highly relevant to the subject, on sourcing grounds under BLP, it does not by any means follow reciprocally that negative material about a living person must be in an article just because it's reliably sourced (I have been thinking for a long time that we need a project-space essay on this exact point; now I know we do). Once we have established that, editorial judgement and discretion is still in play, as bluntly noted by one of our more acerbic editors here (And, more pertinent to this discussion, by Nil Einne)
And per that discussion I reiterate that this conclusion is not final and binding: Should the subject have similar issues in the future, this early indiscretion of his (as the judicial system seems to have treated it) would again become relevant and worth including in the article. Daniel Case (talk) 23:37, 7 November 2026 (UTC)
FTR, I've boldly moved all talk discussion after this year's re-inclusion to its own new thread. This discussion primarily concerns a BLP-related issue; my experiential voyage in discussing this inclusion is well documented on the talk page history. In 2014, given the news-level sourcing, I assessed the crime might be briefly treated in one or two sentences. In 2019, I had grown to believe my first assessment was incorrect. Given the many seasons of active daily routine sports coverage on this BLP-topic long after the crime, the lack of found and presented media coverage about it demonstrated this was not a sufficiently defining issue for inclusion in an encyclopedia article about a living person. The article topic has long ago admitted their crime; courts have weighed in on the relevant issues afterwards. In 2019 I posted on talk it was time to remove the material, and after a reasonable period nobody until now has challenged this call on talk. Over the years numerous accounts (mostly TAs and IPs) have attempted to reinsert it. None of what I've included above is in question.
Now in 2026, come bad faith accusations of censorship from another long-term wikipedian. This is both unfortunate and insufficiently explained. I've stayed out of this thread so far in order to see how others assess the situation. The BOLD I'm totally cool with. The bad faith accusation of censorship borders on personal attack. This requires my asking why would an experienced wikipedian even wish re-inclusion. The questioning of my motives leaves the questioner on the hook for why they chose to do that. Why indeed have so many passing attempts have been made to re-insert this material? Why has it consistently been reverted with no discussion on talk? What does it say about the accounts which have made these choices? Why does this persistent drive-by reinsertion keep occurring (dozens of incidents) on a BLP topic with no fresh coverage? Why is nobody choosing to discuss this on talk? I'm serious. I'm asking. I'm forced to ask. User:Joeykai, do you not now see why WP:Assume good faith is a superior basis upon which to disagree? BusterD (talk) 15:44, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
BLP: Nury Turkel--paragraph on allegations and resignation
About a month ago, on October 5, I removed an earlier one-sentence version of this claim because RFA, the cited source, had removed the resignation reference from its article. I posted evidence of that on the talk page. The current paragraph was added later in October, and I removed it twice. Both removals were reverted, so I've stopped editing the article.
Going nowhere on the talk page. Stuck. An editor points to a July 2024 discussion for keeping this material. But a lot has changed in the two years since. RFA has removed its article on the resignation. It also removed the resignation reference from its July 2024 article. And in December 2024, UHRP said publicly that he resigned voluntarily and that it had taken down its May 2024 statement because it may have caused misunderstandings about why he left. Since consensus can change when the sources do, it's reasonable to ask editors who weren't involved to read them now and decide.
Problem: the paragraph lists the allegations, drops most of what the investigation found, and puts all of it right before a resignation that no current source says the allegations caused.
The source is a NOTUS article (NOTUS is now the Washington Sun): "The Human Rights World Has a Sexual Harassment Problem". It says UHRP hired the law firm Isler Dare to investigate, beginning in November 2023, and the investigator interviewed 13 people and found no basis for allegations of sexually inappropriate conduct. It also says there was no credible testimony of a pattern of harassment, inappropriate touching, or abuse. Our paragraph mentions the no-basis finding, then turns with a "but" to the one 2019 incident in a social setting, which the source says was fully remediated. Everything else is left out. I don't think that's a balanced summary of the source (WP:BLPBALANCE).
The paragraph lists the woman's 2021 account as one of the complaints. But the same article says the investigator heard from her, and the investigation still found no basis for allegations of sexually inappropriate conduct. Read our paragraph and you'd assume her account was never looked at.
On "overly familiar": the source says this happened in a public social setting and was fully remediated. We drop both. Coming after three complaints and a "but," a reader is going to take it as confirmation of sexual misconduct, which is the conclusion the investigation rejected.
The paragraph goes straight from the May 2024 report to the May 15, 2024 resignation. The resignation sentence cites a July 2024 Washington Sun article about a different matter, a whistleblower's firing ("Whistleblower Fired After Speaking Publicly About Sexual Harassment Allegations"). It notes that Turkel stepped down the week after the May report, but it gives no reason, and none of the cited sources say the complaints caused him to resign. The May article itself says he was still board chair when it was published. UHRP's December 13, 2024 statement says he resigned voluntarily, that he did not engage in a pattern of sexually inappropriate conduct, and that he stepped down so UHRP could continue its work without distraction. It also says UHRP removed its May 17, 2024 statement because it "may have led to misunderstandings about the reasons for his departure" (UHRP statement, December 13, 2024). Putting the complaints and the resignation side by side implies a cause the sources don't state (WP:SYNTH).
This isn't new. Earlier versions of the article said he resigned "after allegations of sexual harassment," citing RFA. RFA has since acted on that reporting twice. It removed its article on the resignation, with an editor's note saying it was removed "because the original statement on which it was based has been retracted" (RFA editor's note); UHRP has since confirmed it took down its May 17 statement. And on December 19, 2024, six days after UHRP's statement, RFA updated its July 15, 2024 article "to remove dated reference regarding the resignation" of UHRP's board chair (RFA, July 15, 2024, as updated). The current version doesn't mention Turkel at all. Even so, the claim came back in 2026, citing an archived copy of the July article from before RFA removed the resignation reference. When I removed it on October 5, it was restored the same day citing a 2026 Sautman book whose footnote relies on that same July article (see Talk:Nury Turkel#Use of removed RFA article as BLP source). The current wording no longer states the link, but the sequence is the same, and readers will connect it themselves.
In a nutshell, this is a paragraph about sexual misconduct allegations where the investigation found no sexual misconduct. I don't believe rewording fixes that. If you write the paragraph accurately, what you end up with is: complaints were made, an outside investigation found no basis for allegations of sexually inappropriate conduct, and a 2019 social incident was remediated. Seven months later, UHRP said publicly that he did not engage in a pattern of sexually inappropriate conduct. What's the encyclopedic value in that? WP:BLPGOSSIP asks if material is relevant to a disinterested biography even if it's true, and WP:NOTNEWS makes a similar point: being reported doesn't automatically earn something a place in a biography.
I know WP:PUBLICFIGURE says well-documented allegations about public figures can stay even if the subject objects. I get that. But what's well documented here is an investigation that found no basis for the serious allegations, plus one 2019 incident that was resolved. That's not the kind of noteworthy allegation that policy has in mind.
It's also worth noting this is a BLP and falls under the community-authorized contentious-topics designation for Uyghur-related pages, both of which call for strict sourcing and balance. And BLP asks us to weigh possible harm to the subject. A paragraph that leaves readers thinking the sources show misconduct that led to a resignation does real harm the sources don't support.
I think the paragraph should be removed in full. Given that this is contested material about a living person, I'd ask that an uninvolved editor consider removing it while this discussion runs, per WP:BLP and WP:BLPRESTORE, and that it not be restored without consensus here. Thanks for looking.
OrbisLex (talk) 19:23, 3 November 2026 (UTC)
Removed pending discussion ([diff]). I’ve looked at the sources, and I don’t think the paragraph gives a fair picture. It leaves out key findings from the investigation, RFA’s later removal of its coverage, and the organization’s public statements that the allegations were unsubstantiated and that there was no pattern of sexually inappropriate conduct. We need to be especially careful with sensitive issues like this. I think the paragraph should be removed entirely. Bizuyghur (talk) 00:31, 4 November 2026 (UTC)
Disputed material is very problematic. I’ve been reading everything including the sources here and on the talk page. The material is misleading; it suggests that the allegations led to his resignation. When I first read it, my immediate reaction was that there had been misconduct that got him to resign. But the description above by @Orbis seems factual, and I think the paragraph should be removed permanently. We should remove it for good. ApikiMika (talk) 07:20, 7 November 2026 (UTC)
Nury Turkel: Removing based on WP:BLP pending discussion at BLPN; per WP:ONUS and WP:BLPRESTORE
Per earlier moderator comments regarding edit-warring , please see prior cited sources regarding defamatory or contentious content as outlined in the Wikipedia guidelines. Prior consensus within the talk page on revision 1382822589 determined cited evidence as defamatory. Further requesting that edits of this nature make a complete review of the source material. —Preceding unsigned comment added by RafeTaylor (talk • contribs) 18:30, 6 November 2026 (UTC)
We would generally include material that is reliably sourced (and I think the Washington Sun is probably reliable) and in an incident that resulted in the resignation from the position for which an individual is notable. I am a little surprised not to see this material covered by sources other than the Washington Sun OTOH. Pinging MarkH21 for comment; see also prior heading "BLP: Nury Turkel--paragraph on allegations and resignation". Russ Woodroofe (talk) 19:24, 6 November 2026 (UTC)
The paragraph puts allegations the investigation found "no basis" for right beside the resignation. That suggests sexual misconduct led to it. That also cuts against the finding UHRP described in the same NOTUS article (cited in the paragraph as The Washington Sun). UHRP itself says its May 17 statement "may have led to misunderstandings about the reasons for his departure" (December 13, 2024 statement, linked in point 4 of my first post), and it has taken that earlier statement down. The sources the paragraph now adds trace back to it or to reporting RFA later corrected. The Aydınlık piece is a May 22, 2024 rewrite of NOTUS's report and that statement, and it embeds two posts sharing the now-removed statement. The Sautman line on p. 141 ("resigned in 2024 due to sexual harassment charges") footnotes an RFA article that RFA corrected on December 19, 2024 to remove the resignation reference (Talk:Nury Turkel#Use of removed RFA article as BLP source). The reporting describes allegations and an investigation, not charges.
The paragraph does attribute the allegations to NOTUS, but that is one source, and the other sources it adds trace back to the withdrawn or corrected reporting. On top of that, the framing implies a link none of these sources makes (WP:SYNTH, WP:BLPSOURCE).
On process, Bizuyghur removed the paragraph on November 4 pending discussion. Hemiauchenia restored it on November 6 at 21:08 UTC with the summary "seems to be a consensus." I don't see one. As a reminder for all of us, WP:BLPRESTORE says challenged BLP material shouldn't go back in without consensus, and WP:NOCONSENSUS says that for contentious material about living people, no consensus often means removal. Hemiauchenia, would you please self-revert while we sort this out? I haven't edited the article since October 30.
My position is still full removal. Whatever we settle on, here is the test I'd suggest: could we defend each sentence to the person it's about, using sources that haven't been withdrawn or corrected? If anyone has an independent source for the paragraph, please share it. I'm not coordinating with anyone off-wiki. OrbisLex (talk) 17:06, 7 November 2026 (UTC) —OrbisLex (talk• contribs) has made few or no other edits outside this topic.
Wikipedians don't negotiate with SPAs who are obviously engaging in co-ordinated editing and deny a clear and obvious conflict of interest that it is obvious to anyone with a brain. We weren't born yesterday. Hemiauchenia (talk) 17:09, 7 November 2026 (UTC)
Russ Woodroofe, agreeing with the general rule you describe, but it assumes an incident that led to the resignation, and UHRP says he resigned voluntarily and that its earlier statement "may have led to misunderstandings about the reasons for his departure" (Dec 2024 statement, linked in point 4 of my first post). We should avoid linking events the sources don't connect. OrbisLex (talk) 17:13, 7 November 2026 (UTC)
The Washington Sun and turkish language source both do connect the resignation to the accusations. We follow the reliable independent sources. With the sourcing in the article, this is certainly the kind of incident that Wikipedia usually covers (directly linked to notability, with apparent/alleged career impact). I am not intending on further response here. I do share Hemiauchenia's concerns about apparent coordination or similar (see WP:CANVAS, WP:MEATPUPPET). Russ Woodroofe (talk) 17:37, 7 November 2026 (UTC)
I don't see policy-based arguments for exclusion, rather the improper use of an WP:LLM to create an WP:EXHAUST and WP:IDHT situation that certainly seems like WP:PAYTALK. --Hipal (talk) 17:50, 7 November 2026 (UTC)
Hipal, I did cite policy above: WP:BLPRESTORE and WP:NOCONSENSUS on restoring challenged material, and WP:BLPSOURCE and WP:SYNTH on the sourcing and framing. I have no connection to Turkel, UHRP, or anyone involved, and I'm not paid. Laying out facts doesn't make an editor connected to the subject, and it would help everyone if we kept to the sources.
If you have a source that supports the paragraph and doesn't trace back to the withdrawn UHRP statement or the corrected RFA article, please share it. The timeline is in my comment below, so facts and speculation are easy to tell apart. OrbisLex (talk) 18:28, 7 November 2026 (UTC)
Citing policy does not automatically make for a policy-based argument.
What I'm seeing (ignoring your behavioral problems): Two sources are currently being used. They appear reliable, the content appears to be verified, the content appears encyclopedic, and some mention of the topic appears due. If any of that is contested, it's unclear. --Hipal (talk) 18:39, 7 November 2026 (UTC)
Not contesting whether The Washington Sun is reliable. The issue is the framing and what the resignation sentence rests on. The paragraph puts allegations the investigation found no basis for right beside the resignation, which suggests one led to the other, and UHRP says he resigned voluntarily and that its May statement may have led to misunderstandings about why he left. The sources that give a cause rest on that withdrawn statement or on an RFA article RFA corrected, and The Washington Sun only gives timing. OrbisLex (talk) 18:53, 7 November 2026 (UTC)
That appears to be original research to justify a point of view not in the references. --Hipal (talk) 20:02, 7 November 2026 (UTC)
My concern is about what a reader takes away from the paragraph. That comes down to neutrality and tone rules for BLPs (WP:NPOV, WP:BLPSTYLE) and WP:SYNTH, which is about implying a conclusion by putting facts side by side. BLP policy also says to be conservative with a living person's biography (WP:BLP). That applies here. SYNTH covers article text, so it applies to the paragraph, not to my comment. OrbisLex (talk) 21:46, 7 November 2026 (UTC)
I get that you're done replying, so this is really for anyone reading later. Worth repeating: the May 10 article still lists him as board chair and says nothing about a resignation. The July 18 article only gives timing: he stepped down the week after the report. It doesn't say why. The sources that do give a cause lean on things that were later pulled or fixed. Aydınlık relies on UHRP's May 17 statement, which UHRP removed. Sautman cites the July RFA article, which RFA corrected to take out the resignation reference, after RFA had already retracted its May 20 story on the resignation. UHRP's December 13 statement says he resigned voluntarily. OrbisLex (talk) 18:13, 7 November 2026 (UTC)
I think we’re getting sidetracked by speculation about editors and accounts. The question is simple: should this serious allegation be in a living person’s biography when only one source supports it? This article is about someone prominent in advocacy on a sensitive issue, which makes careful sourcing and presentation especially important. Investigation found nothing to substantiate the allegations. Uyghur org later removed and clarified its statement, and a news organization removed its resignation story. I haven’t seen multiple reliable, independent sources justifying the paragraph as written in the article.
Wikipedia’s BLP policy requires us to be particularly careful with contentious claims and promptly remove poorly sourced material. The reliable sources guideline says reliability depends on the source and the claim. What reliable sources support keeping this material despite the later corrections? We don't have multiple sources. I support removing the whole paragraph. WildHorse1 (talk) 07:04, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Craig Busch – Request for independent BLP review of historical legal material
The following discussion has been closed. Please do not modify it.
Hello,
I'm hoping an independent editor familiar with Wikipedia's Biographies of Living Persons policy could help with two outstanding concerns regarding the Craig Busch article.
I'd like to be transparent that I work with Craig Busch and therefore have a conflict of interest. For that reason, I haven't edited the contentious material myself and have instead submitted requests on the article's talk page.
An independent editor has already reviewed the biography and removed several historical allegations, for which I'm very grateful.
However, two concerns remain unresolved.
1. The 2007 Karen Greybrook assault conviction
I'm not disputing the conviction or suggesting that it should be removed.
My concern is that the current paragraph focuses on the conviction and injuries without providing the surrounding context reported in the original New Zealand Herald coverage.
The reporting explains that the incident followed Busch discovering his former partner in bed with another couple. Judge Michael Lance reportedly described the circumstances as "traumatic in the extreme" and Busch's reaction as "human and understandable", while making clear that this did not excuse the violence.
The reporting also states that Busch was ordered to pay $8,000 in reparation and that nine other charges were dropped after the Crown offered no evidence.
I previously suggested the following replacement wording on the article's talk page:
"In 2007, Busch was convicted in the Whangarei District Court of two charges of assaulting his former partner Karen Greybrook following an incident in 2005 after he found her in bed with another couple. He was ordered to pay $8,000 in reparation. Nine other charges were dropped after the Crown offered no evidence."
I believe this retains the established facts and provides relevant context without giving unnecessary prominence to graphic details of the injuries. However, I would welcome an independent editor's assessment of whether this represents a more proportionate summary under WP and WP.
2. Historical financial court matters
The article also includes two separate historical financial disputes:
A 2011 application to have Busch's mother declared bankrupt over an alleged debt of approximately NZ$3,800. The application was subsequently withdrawn without a bankruptcy order.
A 2013 judgment ordering Busch to pay approximately NZ$86,000 in outstanding legal fees, plus interest and costs.
I'm not disputing that these matters occurred or were reported by reliable sources.
However, I would appreciate an independent review of whether they have sufficient lasting biographical significance to warrant inclusion at their current prominence, particularly when the article contains comparatively little information about Busch's international television career, for which he is principally known.
In the case of the 2011 application, I am also concerned that readers could misunderstand the proceedings as having resulted in bankruptcy when no such order was made.
I appreciate that reliably sourced negative information should not be removed simply because it is unfavourable to the subject. My intention is to ensure that the biography provides an accurate, balanced and proportionate account of his life and career.
Both concerns have already been raised on the article's talk page, but remain unresolved:
I'd be grateful if an uninvolved editor could review these matters and consider whether the proposed amendment to the Greybrook paragraph, and any changes to the financial material, would be appropriate.
Thank you very much for your time and consideration.
I'm not sure that he meets the notability criteria at all; there's very little critical analysis and commentary about him. Most of the article(including the aforementioned litigation) seems to be about the park itself. That said, the litigation does seem to be a minor aspect. 331dot (talk) 09:56, 5 November 2026 (UTC)
The following discussion has been closed. Please do not modify it.
Hi,
Thank you for your reply. You are right that there is little critical analysis and commentary about him, but they are still a large part of a small section. I would still appreciate some context being added to the assault as it could be read as an unprovoked attack, even after the judge threw out 9 charges and sympathised with him. I would also appreciate if some consideration could be given to my points about the court proceedings, and their place in his biography now, which I do believe are valid. But understand your point about them being in regard to the park. Perhaps adding some more positive content could balance this out, I will endeavour to write some!. Thank you for your time.
International School of Temple Arts: single-sourced BLP allegations about Baba Dez Nichols
I am Baba Dez Nichols (Robert Dez Nichols), the living person named in these sentences in the Controversy section of International School of Temple Arts:
Dez himself was accused of pressuring students into sexual activities during ISTA workshops. He allegedly also propagated the belief that sexual interactions with male leaders could be healing for women, a concept referred to by some former assistants as “the magical cock.”
‘’‘Source.’’’ Cited solely to Anya Kamenetz, “The Neo-Tantric Sex Group That Promised to Change,” ‘‘The Cut’’, 28 February 2025. Added 1 March 2025 by User:SocialTechWorker; User:Peaceray flagged it the same day under WP:BLP (“individual accusations have no citations”), briefly rolled it back, then restored a shortened version noting the Cut cite “needs verification by another editor who has a subscription.” ‘’‘What the source actually says.’’’ The Cut does not quote me stating that sex with male leaders heals women. It attributes that idea to critics (3SC / Dave Booda: “dick is magic and can heal trauma”; “former assistants” / “magical cock”; “an idea they traced to Dez”) and parenthetically notes ‘’’(Dez disputes this.)’’’ Wikipedia puts the claim in article voice, drops the attribution, and drops my dispute — a misrepresentation of its sole source. ‘’‘Denials.’’’ I never pressured students into sexual activities during ISTA workshops; never propagated or stated that sexual interactions with male leaders could be healing for women; never referred to myself as having a “magical cock”; the claim as written is fictitious. ‘’‘Ask.’’’ Under WP:BLP and WP:RS, contested allegations about a living person must not remain in article voice on one poorly matched source. Please remove these sentences ‘’‘immediately’’’. Independent corroboration, if any exists, can be discussed after removal. — Baba Dez Nichols (Robert Dez Nichols) Babadez (talk) 19:44, 5 November 2026 (UTC)
Please chime in: I don't know who's right. tgeorgescu (talk) 09:30, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
Category:People with narcissistic personality disorder
Not a LP, but the Rodney Alcala article says says "Other diagnoses later proposed by various psychiatric experts at his trials included: narcissistic personality disorder..." The only actual diagnosis was borderline personality disorder.
Paul Bernardo was "diagnosed" by the magazine Elm Street.
Not a LP, but for Ted Bundy, NPD was "proposed as alternative diagnoses in at least one subsequent retrospective analysis".
And I only looked at A an B.
I also question any diagnosis that comes from expert witness testimony in a court case. It is very common for one or both sides to put an expert witness on the stand in an attempt to strengthen their case. Sometimes it is the defense, seeking to avoid capital punishment. Sometimes it is the prosecution, where the shrink -- who works for the prosecution -- makes a diagnosis of an unwilling and hostile patient. We can attribute the diagnosis in the body, but the category just says that they have the disorder with no qualifications or attribution.
I am thinking of going through the cat and removing any name that wasn't diagnosed by an MD that examined the person. --Guy Macon (talk) 21:47, 6 November 2026 (UTC)
Can having narcissistic personality disorder ever be a defining characteristic of an individual? It seems unlikely to me. Being verifiable doesn't make it defining. Being diagnosed doesn't make it defining. What exactly would? AndyTheGrump (talk) 13:54, 8 November 2026 (UTC)
I have been thinking about this and I have concluded that the concept of an attractive nuisance applies. Let's look back at the category that got me started down this rabbit hole: Someone listed Alex Jones under Category: People with narcissistic personality disorder. This sort of thing is inevitable. Many people hate Alex Jones and are new editors who don't understand that Jones gets the same BLP protection as any other editor.
There is no way to make it so that only extended confirmed editors can add cats to BLPs (feel free to suggest that when the WMF asks for "wish list" suggestions; I refuse to ride in that particular clown car) so I am going to start one of those giant contentious RfCs asking that all such cats be deleted on the grounds of [1] being the source of repeated BLP violations, and [2] not being all that useful to the reader.
If anyone wants to help, please list some candidate cats in a reply. I am inclined to only include medical conditions for now, with a possible future RfC for any other problem cats. --Guy Macon (talk) 02:34, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
I feel like single-issue position cats can also be grouped with the diagnostic ones as contentious and unhelpful to readers, such as Category:Zionists, Category:Atheists, etc. If these are actual significant aspects of the BLP subject in question, then there is probably a narrower category that suits them and gets the message across. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 23:29, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
By the way, we could definitely add an edit filter for non-XC category additions. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 01:13, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
Honestly question the ethics of such a category given this is a highly stigmatized disorder. GeogSage (⚔Chat?⚔) 03:15, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
I question having any cat about a medical condition. To be included in such a cat, a person would have to [A] be diagnosed by an MD who examined them, and [2] Publicly reveal that diagnosis. Trying to enforce that on a bunch of cats is a game of Whac-A-Mole. And even then what possible use would a reader have for a list of people who have narcissistic personality disorder? Who does it benefit? --Guy Macon (talk) 03:47, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
One use case is "I'd like to read about the accomplishments of public figures with [medical condition]", but that should still be sourced/official and shouldn't mean categories for every medical condition on the books. Getting rid of all condition categories risks stifling earnest mental health awareness/openness (which obviously isn't what's happening in these examples) Placeholderer (talk) 00:13, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
One clear example of a useful category is Category:Paralympic competitors by disability category Placeholderer (talk) 00:16, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
Given that paralympic competitors are going to be notable as competitors (or at least, should be to meet the relevant criteria), and given that their disability category affects how they compete, I'd think that that particular category might be justified. It is clearly an outlier in terms of the categories we are discussion here though. AndyTheGrump (talk) 01:26, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
Yes, this is different from the example this thread is about because it’s a definitive aspect (competitive category) of a definitive aspect (professional athletics) of the subjects covered therein. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 01:28, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
I definitely think disabilities and diagnoses are almost always way, way below nationality in terms of definitiveness for a biographical subject. Exceptions include Helen Keller. An analogue here is handedness, or eye color, or being gluten-free. Of course, medical diagnoses are above those in terms of significance, but I think in most cases they’re closer to those than they are to, say, nationality and occupation. ꧁Mangroves꧂ 01:44, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
Hmm... with CATDEF A defining characteristic is one that reliable sources commonly and consistently refer to, but, like, I don't see RS going around saying "Donald Trump, a man with Scottish and German heritage, gave a speech today", unless maybe that speech is in Scotland and Germany which would take quite the border adjustments!
I don't want to stray into RGW but I think completely getting rid of e.g Category:American autistic people would inhales play into the stigmatization of neurodiversity as being something to be kept under wraps and overlooked.
I'm not confident in category business myself, but surely inclusion within medical condition categories can be weighed like other categories? Like, if an artist is widely reported/discussed as schizophrenic, that seems appropriate for a category. If a politician publicly embraces their own schizophrenia, I'd think that points to inclusion. If Gawker "reveals" that some celebrity is schizophrenic, and that isn't picked up by respectable journalists (sorry Gawker), that seems less appropriate.
It should also be borne in mind (is that valid phrasing?) that the contentiousness of a condition is a social construct. We shouldn't get rid of Category:People with narcissistic personality disorder for being contentious or misused, IMO Placeholderer (talk) 02:51, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
Obviously there needs to be more subtlety than I first thought. I need to figure out what to ask for before posting any RfC.
I was thinking that you should only be allowed to put Alex Jones an Category: People with narcissistic personality disorder if he was diagnosed by a doctor who examined him (not by one of his enemies or the writer of a magazine article about him). Combing this with the fact that in most jurisdictions a doctor who revealed such a diagnosis without Jones' permission could lose their license.
Faking medical conditions is also common. See and Factitious disorder imposed on self. Many people self diagnose. We can explain this in the body, but categories have no room for subtlety. You are in or you are out.
On the other hand, what is the name of the MD who diagnosed Peter Dinklage with dwarfism? The MD who diagnosed Eric "Ricky" McKinnie with blindness? On the other other hand should we have put Ashley Kirilow in Category:Cancer survivor (before that cat got deleted)?
Easy to see that there is a problem -- attracting BLP violations. Not so easy figuring out what to do about it. --Guy Macon (talk) 03:23, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
Could there be a WP:TAG that labels addition of designated medical-condition categories? That wouldn't address categories like Zionists/Atheists, but would be a pretty nonrestrictive thing that might help. Expanding to other "contentious categories" would mean deciding which categories are contentious or not, which seems like a bigger undertaking. (Alternatively, could label all category additions to BLPs?) Placeholderer (talk) 03:53, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
Interviews with the subject as a BLP source
Hi, I'm reviewing an edit request at Talk:Michael Groce and I'm trying figure how best to represent the subject in a way that is neutral but also backed by independent sources. The subject is most notable for his relationship to the 1985 Brixton riot. He's made an edit request asking to expand the segments of the article about his life outside of that event, but the only sources he has for that are interviews with him.
Usually I try to avoid adding large chunks of an article sourced only to interviews because they aren't really independent sources. But on the other hand this guy has had a reasonably active public life over the last 40 years, and I can understand why he's unhappy to be boiled down to an incident when he was a teenager. It seems like a case where the subject is notable for WP:ONEEVENT, and if I interpret our requirement for indpendent sources "strictly" then there's very little else to say about him. Packrat3860 (talk) 22:42, 6 November 2026 (UTC)
@Packrat3860: Depends on the interview outlet - I'd treat it as pretty much reliable unless very controversial if it's a solid source (think The New Yorker, Interview Magazine) or if it's in a question the interviewer's asking in a reasonably reliable source, and even at the worst outlet, unless there's reason to doubt it being a true interview (which there doesn't seem to be considering the subject has made the edit request asking to use those sources) it'd be a WP:ABOUTSELF, which still allows in things that aren't "unduly self-serving nor an exceptional claim". Jishara (please ping upon response) (talk) 18:16, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
Paul Marsden MP coverage of post-parliamentary career
Could an uninvolved editor take a look at the sourcing and weight given to Paul Marsden Labour and Lib Dem MP's later career?
At the suggestion of other editors, I am bringing this issue here. There has been a lengthy discussion at Talk:Vladislav Doronin#Oligarch regarding the use of the term "Russian oligarch" as a primary descriptor in the lead sentence of Vladislav Doronin's BLP, after various new/temporary accounts began editing the article to read this way in recent months. All agree that some RS have called him an oligarch over the years, but there has been no consensus for using the term in wiki-voice in the lead sentence, nor for the notion that he has "widely" been described as an oligarch. Would someone here be willing to help resolve this dispute, or at least revert to the status quo ante version? I am not editing the article directly because I have a COI with the subject.
If it helps, I collected all the times Doronin has been mentioned by the top RS publications listed at WP:RSP, found via Google site searches, and noted which of these articles refer to Doronin as an oligarch and which do not. Even among the small percentage of these sources that do use the term, most are either in the context of passing mentions or are not the primary term used to describe him. See below:
References to Vladislav Doronin in top WP:RSP publications (135 articles; 9 refer to him as an oligarch)
"The Aspen Times has been critical of Doronin’s purchase, while the billionaire’s public relations team has staunchly fought the “oligarch” label, denied allegations of corruption and emphasized Doronin’s disapproval of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.
The Soviet-born Doronin left that country and renounced his citizenship in the mid-1980s, before the Soviet Union collapsed. He now lives in Switzerland and is a citizen of Sweden. He divested from his Russia-focused business in 2014, the lawsuit claims, and “has not conducted any business in Russia since,” his lawyers wrote.
The 59-year-old serves as CEO of OKO Group, a Miami real-estate development firm, and Aman Group, a luxury resort brand based in Switzerland."
"A separate statement agreed upon by the parties reads: "As part of an agreement to resolve Vladislav Doronin's defamation suit against The Aspen Times, the newspaper agreed to retract the letter to the editor that was the subject of that lawsuit and to amend two other articles related to Mr. Doronin. The Aspen Times agreed to take these steps because it determined, in its own judgment, that the pieces were not in keeping with the journalistic standards that the newspaper seeks to uphold."
"Residents have included Russian tycoon Vladislav Doronin" ... "Fridman, Deripaska and Doronin have to different degrees questioned Putin’s war" (no use of the word "oligarch").
I think it is clear that any claim calling Vladislav Doronin an oligarch must be attributed and not in Wikivoice, and that the section should also contain attributed claims that he is not.
Conflict-of-interest disclosure: I am assisting Dr. Shri Thanedar at his personal request. I have disclosed this relationship on the article's Talk page and am seeking independent editorial review.
Nature of the concern
The article's Early life and education section identifies the subject as “Shrinivas Prasad Thanedar.”
Dr. Thanedar has personally informed me that his correct name is “Shri Thanedar,” that he has no middle name, and that he is not “Shrinivas Prasad Thanedar.”
I recognize that personal confirmation alone does not necessarily resolve Wikipedia's sourcing requirements.
These sources identify him as Shri Thanedar, although I acknowledge that they do not necessarily establish whether he previously used another name.
Previous editing history
I previously attempted to correct the disputed name, but the changes were reverted. An editor raised concerns about reliable sourcing and the unintended alteration of existing links.
I acknowledge those concerns and am not seeking to continue an edit dispute.
A formal request for verification guidance has also been sent to Wikimedia's Volunteer Response Team.
Request for independent review
I would appreciate guidance on the following questions:
Which reliable published sources support the claim that his birth name was “Shrinivas Prasad Thanedar”?
Does the disputed birth-name statement satisfy Wikipedia's Biographies of Living Persons and verifiability policies?
If the available sources are insufficient or contradictory, should the disputed name be omitted pending reliable verification?
What would be the appropriate process for confidential identity verification, if necessary?
The subject has provided official identity documents, but these have not been published or shared on Wikipedia. Any verification would require his authorization and an appropriate confidential process.
My objective is to help ensure that the biography accurately reflects reliably sourced information while respecting Wikipedia's editorial independence.
Thank you for your time and guidance. ~2026-59618-49 (talk) 16:25, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
Thank you for bringing this to our attention. The name was added in February of this year without a single source by an editor who has since been banned. The middle name has how been deleted by another editor and I obviously agree with that decision. You did the right thing to try to remove it directly and then to bring the issue to the attention of the talkpage and this board. I have placed the article on my watchlist and hopefully this problem with not recur. Once again, our apologies and thank you. Slp1 (talk) 15:18, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
Thank you very much, @Slp1, for your thoughtful, encouraging, and reassuring response.
I sincerely appreciate your careful review, acknowledgment of the sourcing issue, and agreement with the removal of the disputed name. I am particularly grateful that you have added the article to your watchlist to help prevent a recurrence.
Your kind words and apology are deeply appreciated. I would also like to thank @Ser! for independently reviewing the biography and making the necessary corrections.
This was my first experience navigating Wikipedia's editorial process, and I am grateful for the guidance and professionalism demonstrated by the community.
For transparency, I am assisting Dr. Shri Thanedar directly with this matter and am participating through a Wikipedia temporary account.
Thank you once again for your time, consideration, and commitment to maintaining accurate information about living individuals.
An editor has been persistently adding an individual without a Wikipedia article in mainspace to the Notable former pupils section without any references. I have searched for sources about their attendance at this school and nothing comes up in any newspaper or magazine, or even the individual's website or social feed. I have engaged with the editor on their talk page pointing them to relevant policies against WP:OR and including unsourced information about living people (specifically WP:BLPPRIVACY) which have not been acknowledged. I initially reverted the edits until I found this page referred to in a clause in WP:3RR which I believe to be relevant in this situation. UltrasonicMadness (talk) 15:15, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
I concur with your assessment that this person does not seem notable and that the information should be removed. I have removed it once again. @TheRealFactEditor: can you please engage in the discussion on your talk page about these unsourced additions? Otherwise WP:ANI is the next step for an editor that insists on unsourced additions and refuses to discuss with the community. Packrat3860 (talk) 17:20, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
I'm not going to edit war about it, but if nobody arrives to discuss it soon I would suggest ANI Packrat3860 (talk) 18:12, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
I have partial blocked the editor from Dyce Academy for edit warring. Slp1 (talk) 18:52, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
Mariam Dabboussy
not an important person. living with terrorists does not make it worthy. should be removed —Preceding unsigned comment added by ~2026-60040-83 (talk) 07:22, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
This page is not for debating the notability of a topic; you may do that on the article talk page (Talk:Mariam Dabboussy) or make use of a procedure like Articles for Deletion(though you'll need help with that as a temporary account user). 331dot (talk) 08:51, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
Jensen Huang spying scandal
I am concerned that the current article title of Jensen Huang spying scandal may give readers the misleading impression that Jensen Huang himself is engaged in espionage, when this is not stated anywhere in WP:RS. There is currently an open move request, though the proposed title does not resolve this ambiguity, and arguably makes it worse.
Given the potentially serious implications under WP:BLP, I believe there is a case for an interim move to a less ambiguous title while the move request discussion continues.
I was going to go ahead and do this move myself, but I know non-admin moves of pages undergoing title discussions can be controversial, so I wanted to get an admin's take on whether immediate action is warranted on BLP grounds. SnowyRiver28(talk) 03:22, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Huang was allegedly the subject of spying, not the one conducting espionage himself. I don't see a BLP need to move the title while the discussion is underway(and largely against a move at the moment). 331dot (talk) 11:29, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Alice Huang is also a living person and there is currently no proof only allegation that she is an intelligence asset. Vacosea (talk) 01:15, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
I made what I deemed to be a non-controversial edit on Bruno Langley yesterday morning. I added the category "British people convicted of sexual assault". His conviction for sexual assault in 2017 is addressed and well-sourced within the article. This was reverted by a temporary account with no edit summary. I left a message on the talk page, and added it back this morning, and again I was reverted this time by another temporary account with no edit summary.
However, upon closer inspection, I noticed a similar thing happened from 20 April to 1 July this year. Another user added similar categories on 20 April, to be reverted by a temporary account on 17 May, to then add it back on 2 June, and then to be reverted by another temporary account on 1 July. I was not involved at that time, and it doesn’t look like any discussion came of it then.
I would like to note that I am backing away from editing the article for now as I do not wish to get involved in an edit war. Also, I have left a message on both temporary accounts asking them to engage on the talk page (not sure if it is the same user or not). I understand that it is a sensitive topic, but I don’t completely understand why temporary accounts seem to have an issue with the category being added since the sexual assaults are well-sourced in the article.
Again, I am stepping away from editing the article due to the risk of becoming involved in an edit war. I would like some advice on how to handle this going forward. Fats40boy11 (talk) 11:02, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Bruno van Pottelsberghe
MOST OF THE SOURCES ARE /WERE EITHER SELF-WRITTEN SOURCES / SELF-PUBLISHED SOURCES AND POOR QUALITY SOURCES. I'VE DELETED SOEM OF THEM. I FOUND BRUNO HAS SELF-WRITTEN HIS PROFILE AND GOT IT UPLOADED BY HIS MEDIA AGENCY (BECAUSE THE UNIVERSITY PAYS TO MEDIA AGENCIES, AND THEY FAVOUR TO CREATE AN EXAGGERATED PROFILE IN RETURN. OR IT IS WRITTEN BY HIM AND CREATED BY HIS SUBORDINATE, AS A RECTOR.
THERE WAS NO EVIDENCE/SOURCE THAT HE WORKED AT COLOMBIA UNI ETC .. OECD source was his own write-up about him...
He had advertised that he was MBA academic director for 10 years, but the source did not give info about YEARS at all..Moreover, the source was self-published source on his own college website. —Preceding unsigned comment added by Drfestival (talk • contribs) 03:00, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Most cited sources appear to be self-authored, self-published, or drawn from publications of questionable credibility and limited academic standing. I have therefore removed some of these sources.
In particular, I have concerns about the objectivity and independence of the material published about Bruno. It appears that his profile may have been personally prepared or commissioned and subsequently disseminated through a media agency engaged by the university. Given that universities often engage external media agencies for promotional purposes, there is a possibility that such profiles are designed to enhance an individual's public image rather than provide an independently verified and balanced account of their achievements. Alternatively, the material may have been prepared internally by his subordinates in his capacity as Rector.
I believe it is important to distinguish between independently verified achievements reported by credible third-party sources and promotional content that may have been influenced by the individual or the institution concerned.
See the changes I made and explanations given in the history section of his page.
THERE WAS NO EVIDENCE/SOURCE THAT HE WORKED AT COLOMBIA UNI ETC. He added that info his own, bec Colombia is a brand....Perhaps he got rector job by adding all these inof artificially... OECD source was his own write-up about him...
He advertised that he was MBA academic director for 10 years, but the source gave no info about the years at all. Moreover, the source was a self-published source on his own college website Drfestival (talk) 16:26, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
First, please don't use all caps. 331dot (talk) 16:34, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
WP:BLPSELFPUB specifies that self-published sources from the subject can be used for routine facts. That might include a basic career sketch, if there is no reason to doubt. It shouldn't be used for claims to notability, like the rector position at Corvinus. The article is not in very good shape, and I added the "like resume" tag. It is possible that some aspects of older versions of the article (which were more encyclopedic, even if written for earlier Wikipedia standards) should be restored. Russ Woodroofe (talk) 16:43, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
comparing two wiki articles (One with Notice on wall & the other one without notice)
The above is written, and 90% of the information comes from his own pages at his university/universities. However, there is no PRIMARY SOURCES notice on his wall.
At the same time, the article quoted below about JUSTIN PAUL has more secondary and independent sources (newspapers etc.), and you have put a notice on his wall. it has been there for a long time.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Justin_Paul_(scholar)
Hence,. requesting you to remove the notice on wall on the 2nd subject or display the wall on the subject 1 too. Drfestival (talk) 13:53, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
Given that Wikipedia currently has over 7 million articles, picking one out to support an argument relating to another proves next to nothing. Personally, I'd say that both are more reliant on primary sources than they should be, and that a primary sources template should probably be added to the Schmitt biography. As for the Paul biography, there seems to have been a history of badly-sourced and promotional editing, and the appropriate solution is to ensure the article complies with policy. A great deal of the content still cites material written by Paul himself. AndyTheGrump (talk) 14:21, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
This article has multiple issues. Several citations are either missing or are primary sources.
You appear to be looking for multiple articles to raise issues with, having been told that the template you originally asked about seemed legitimate. I suggest you stop doing that, it really doesn't look good. AndyTheGrump (talk) 16:53, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
Hihi. A couple of low-edit accounts this year attempted to remove the above-linked section outright, which popped up at SPI in a case I just closed. I see there's a previous BLPN discussion from June which resulted in ScottishFinnishRadish removing the section, though it was re-added with some additional sourcing in July. I think this would benefit from a review for BLP issues. Vermont (🐿️—🏳️🌈) 03:49, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
Severe BLP / WP:BLPCRIME and Undue Weight issues on Noah Levine
Hello, I am requesting urgent review from uninvolved editors regarding Noah Levine. The article contains a section detailing allegations from 8 years ago. These allegations were never proven, and police formally declined to file criminal charges. I recently trimmed this section to bring it into compliance with WP:WEIGHT and WP:BLP. In response, another editor reverted my edit and significantly expanded the section, adding extensive detail to uncharged accusations. Under WP:BLPCRIME, WP:NOTNEWS, and WP:BLPSTYLE, giving disproportionate space to 8-year-old, uncharged allegations violates our core policies on living people. Could uninvolved editors please review the recent history and help restore a neutral, encyclopedic policy-compliant version? Thank you. ~~~~Amberjol (talk) 12:51, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
Seems due to include. The sexual misconduct allegations were covered by major newspapers, and seem to have had a major impact on his career. WP:PUBLICFIGURE says If an allegation or incident is noteworthy, relevant, and well documented, it belongs in the article, even if it is negative and the subject dislikes all mention of it.Hemiauchenia (talk) 13:04, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
Just because there was no proven crime does not mean that this should not be mentioned. It did affect his career it seems, and most importantly was covered in secondary sources. However, I see that the current version contains material referenced court documents and other primary sources which is an absolute no-no per BLP and I will be removing all of that immediately. Are the Lion's Roar and Tricycle reliable sources for such information about a BLP? I am not sure they are strong enough sources, but maybe. It would be best if only very strong secondary sources were used.Slp1 (talk) 13:56, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
Lion's Roar (magazine) seems like a well-established WP:NEWSORG such that I think it's reliable for the claims here. Obviously references to primary court documents and similar should be excised. Hemiauchenia (talk) 14:34, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
I agree that the cited sources satisfy WP:PUBLICFIGURE especially with the academic journal article that goes beyond just NOTNEWS. Morbidthoughts (talk) 23:56, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
Note that the San Francisco Chronicle is also cited. Prezbo (talk) 14:41, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
I agree with others that the sources are enough to support this belongs. Significantly the academic journal but also some of the other sources seem to be ~2 years after it happened so this isn't just a case where something was reported in the news when it happened and then even forgot about it but instead received sustained coverage. And while Tricycle might be an opinion piece, since it's in a Buddhist magazine this suggests it was something still actively thought about within his community. It also seems to have had a significant effect on his career. More recent sources even news reports about Levine which mention the allegations would add even more support but IMO there's already enough to support some mention. Nil Einne (talk) 10:42, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Roger Rosenblatt
The article states: "With Jim Lehrer and Robert MacNeil, he created the first essays ever done on television." Eric Sevareid had been presenting essays on the CBS Evening News since 1963. They were titled analysis, but were his essays on news events. —Preceding unsigned comment added by ~2026-60515-14 (talk) 00:13, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Given the difficulty of defining exactly what constitutes an 'essay', I'd question that assertion even with a source. And given that the only source that it might be cited to, at the end of the paragraph, (archived copy ) says nothing about this, it should be removed as unsourced. And frankly, the article comes across as rather promotional more generally, and could do with editing for WP:NPOV. AndyTheGrump (talk) 01:19, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
I've now removed the claim. AndyTheGrump (talk) 15:28, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
No official siting of someone’s age
Ac sapphire age needs to be taken down Ac sapphire star (talk) 07:59, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Hi, there is a citation for her birth date, check the first sentence in the “Early Life” section. -- LWGtalk(VOPOV) 08:33, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
James F. O'Brien
Problems with sourcing and proportionate coverage.
I would ask for a review by uninvolved neutral editors of the allegations and litigation material in James F. O'Brien.
My concern is the amount and selection of detail do not follow the WP:BLP and WP:DUE requirements/rules. The problem sections gives detailed account of allegations, internal proceedings, and litigation arguments. The second paragraph of the Litigation Subsection reproduces additional allegations from an anonymous exit survey that has not verification. Is repeating those allegations necessary to explain the procedural issue, or could that issue be summarized without reproducing them?
I would also ask for review of whether the use of court records complies with WP:BLPPRIMARY. —Preceding unsigned comment added by Gornalwhell (talk • contribs) 20:48, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
I've removed the section on the article, and commented at the Talk page. Also, please remember to sign your comments on Talk pages. Cheers! Woodroar (talk) 23:21, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Hello. As the subject of Dave SharmaI have opened a request on the article's Talk page regarding a serious WP:BLP violation: an accusation of "insider trading" sourced to routine shareholding disclosures that make no such claim, a dead link, and a satirical website. Could an uninvolved editor please review the Talk page section and remove the unsourced claim immediately? Thank you. ~~~~~2026-60730-52 (talk) 03:36, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
I have addressed the concern and removed the material. -- Nat Gertler (talk) 03:48, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Reposting an unanswered thread (archive). COI declared: I am the subject's son. Three short sourcing problems in negative BLP material:
1. "Gertner was forced to declare bankruptcy by the High Court". He did not declare bankruptcy. The cited sources (Property Week, 22 Jul 2019; The Times, 21 Jul 2019) both say the court approved a creditor's petition filed by CFL Finance. The article now correctly adds that the order was set aside on appeal, so this sentence is both inaccurate and inconsistent with it.
Suggested: "In July 2019 the High Court made a bankruptcy order against Gertner on a creditor's petition brought by CFL Finance Ltd."
2. "Several Jewish charities and individual investors". The cited source (The Times, 29 Jan 2017) names only Kaupthing and CFL Finance as creditors. It says nothing about charities or individual investors. Please remove unless reliably sourced.
3. "Faced ruin after the 2008 financial crisis". The cited Times article (30 Mar 2011) says: "Fordgate has been hit by the downturn and some UK schemes have been sold or placed in administration." The Guardian citation does not discuss the Gertners' finances.
Suggested: "Fordgate was hit by the downturn following the 2008 financial crisis, and some of its UK schemes were sold or placed in administration."
Source PDFs available on request. ~~~~~2026-56958-50 (talk) 09:55, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Kenneth Whalum – birth year, subject objects, dead source
I am the subject of Kenneth Whalum and have a conflict of interest, so I'm asking here rather than editing. I opened an edit request on the article's talk page on November 4 and followed up on November 14, with no response so far.
The article states my birth year in five places: the short description ("American musician (born 1983)"), the infobox, the lead, Early life, and Category:1983 births. The only citation is an All About Jazz page that is marked dead, and the Wayback Machine has no archived copy. So the claim is currently unsourced.
Per WP:DOB and WP:BLPPRIVACY, birth dates of living people should be included only when widely published by reliable sources, and editors should lean toward leaving them out when the subject objects. I do object, for privacy reasons.
I'm requesting:
Remove the birth year from the infobox, lead and Early life
It looks like this has all already been done, from a quick look at the article. (If it's still showing up, bypass your cache; note we have no control over Google's (ab)use of the Knowledge Graph.) —Jéské Courianov^_^vThrillerNight! 18:02, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Sorry, I was going to update this thread after that edit but I got called away. ScottishFinnishRadish (talk) 18:51, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Thank you both for handling this so quickly. I appreciate it. Kennethwhalum (talk) 18:55, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
I was wondering if the edits of this user could be looked at. I think several of their edits are extremely gossipy, with significant balance issues.
I don't actively edit Wikipedia any more, but I've noticed these giant walls of text with nothing more than allegations appear and disappear from Mauro Icardi over time. The user appears to be a WP:SPA focused on this football player and his personal life. x42bn6TalkMess 19:04, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
William Perry (American football)
I have reached a stalemate in trying to enforce the BLP policy, in particular the WP:DOB portion. When I come upon BLP articles containing unsourced dates of birth, I have been removing them as BLP in general states All quotations and any material challenged or likely to be challenged must be supported by an inline citation to a reliable, published source. Contentious material about living (or, in some cases, recently deceased) persons that is unsourced or poorly sourced—whether the material is negative, positive, neutral, or just questionable—must be removed immediately and without waiting for discussion. However, on Football Player articles I'm running into an issue with the people who usually edit these articles, in particular Bringingthewood(talk·contribs) who keeps reverting me and demanding that I insert a source and fix the issue instead. That's not what the BLP policy says, and even if I did this it raises another issue that the people regularly editing these articles are not following the BLP policy whether I remove the DOB or not. There are likely many articles out there with unsourced DOB and I remove them when I see them, but I'm being obstructed here. In the latest case the notable edits are here ,. In another case at Maxx Crosby my removal was reverted (by someone else) with a snarky comment about how the source was in the infobox , apparently referring to a link to player statistics at the bottom of the infobox rather than as an inline citation as mandated by BLP. In that case someone else then added the inline cite so it was fixed.
So am I in the wrong here to remove DOB lacking an inline citation to a reliable source? Bringingthewood seems to think so. I've attempted to explain WP:DOB and WP:BURDEN, but was told "I'm not in the mood do go through it" and I'm being blindly reverted and told to gain consensus (consensus is not needed to remove BLP violations). Everyone at Wikipedia volunteers their time however they can and part of mine is to remove BLP violations as soon as I see them. Iggy pop goes the weasel (talk) 23:17, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
I'm still not in the mood. But .. you can mention every rule in the book, just let me know if the dozens of profootballreference and profootballarchives references are mostly in error. I'll need sleep for the upcoming workload if something happens to be brought up now .. without warning .. when it seems like a dart is being thrown at certain players. I'm not saying you're wrong, but I know some editors who added more places and and dates of birth, than you have in total NFL edits. By no means is that a slap in your direction, I would just would hate to see that we lived in some sort of fantasy world for the last few years. Bottom line, you can personally remove every stat there and replace them all with a valid reference, and I will not revert any of them. I just want to know, so I can sleep better at night, if the two references that I mentioned above were done for nothing. So far two different editors reverted such things. See: https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Maxx_Crosby&curid=60600803&action=history. Bringingthewood (talk) 23:34, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Another thing. I do know that PFR and PFA are wrong at times. For example, T. J. Watt was born in Pewaukee and not Waukesha, as stated by PFA. But a good way to not just delete info and run would be adding a reference, like what is shown in the Maxx Crosby revision history. Bringingthewood (talk) 23:44, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
You are attempting to place an undue burden on someone doing clean-up. Sure, if they're in a mood to hunt down a reference, great... but removing a date of birth that does not live up to WP:BLPDOB is moving toward getting the article more in line with the guidelines. The date can be readded at any time by anyone who has an appropriate reference; it is not incumbent on the person finding the problem to also find a reference. -- Nat Gertler (talk) 01:06, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Iggy pop goes the weasel: I had left you a previous message at the discussion at Bringingthewood's talk page, but perhaps you didn't receive the notification. The WP:PRESERVE policy reads:
Instead of removing content, consider cleaning up the writing, formatting or sourcing, or tagging as appropriate
It can't be cleaning up when several editors are saying it was correct. References were only added to prove a point. Let's see if I got this. Someone can remove something that doesn't meet the guideline, while not adding the correct info to make the article better? Oh yes, we wouldn't want to burden anyone. I just still can't get the current PFR or PFA removals, when three editors used verifiable info, adding ESPN to the mix. Again, check out that Crosby link I added up there, and that's just one player. Then there was Fred Dryer .. and when was William Perry really born? What we've been using .. now .. doesn't meet the guidelines? `Bringingthewood (talk) 01:36, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Yes editors can remove any content, and must remove some content (most notably contentious BLP details), if it is not sourced. That's doesn't mean editors should just go around deleting content, but content that has been removed shouldn't be restored without sourcing. The onus is on anyone wanting to restore the content to reference it. That means as an inline citation, not just in an edit summary. Although if someone includes it in an edit summary I would add it, as this is a collaborative project but that shouldn't be relied upon. -- LCU ActivelyDisinterested«@» °∆t° 15:11, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
I don't know removed an entry with an inline cite to PFR or PFA but it certainly wasn't me. Iggy pop goes the weasel (talk) 15:39, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
"Instead of removing content, consider cleaning up the writing, formatting or sourcing, or tagging as appropriate" This conflicts with BLP, "Contentious material about living (or, in some cases, recently deceased) persons that is unsourced or poorly sourced—whether the material is negative, positive, neutral, or just questionable—must be removed immediately and without waiting for discussion". As Bringingthewood mentioned up above, "PFR and PFA are wrong at times", which for me puts even those sources into question, although I don't plan to go around removing them. Deleting an unsourced DOB from a BLP should absolutely never be prevented because someone cannot find a suitable source. If I had a reliable source I'd add it, but now even the sources presented to me (PFR and PFA) are in question. I again want to reiterate that those who regularly edit BLPs of NFL players likely know the best sources, especially those who have participated in writing GAs, so if they want this contentious info included to just reinsert it with their preferred reliable source. Iggy pop goes the weasel (talk) 15:36, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
To save myself from getting blocked in the future, I won't respond much more regarding this issue. What I'll say now is pertaining to the Stefan Arngrim page. I see the reasoning stated in the history was 'removing unsourced D/O/B'. But the place of birth was also removed and the biography section was left intact. Hopefully I wasn't wrong with adding Canada back (per the citation that was already there), and I removed Toronto, Ontario only. Bottom line, these drive-by removals won't fly with NFL players. Besides not knowing 'why was that section removed and not that other one', I know editors who will revert them thinking it's out of boredom, laziness, etc. If someone does love the NFL section, please 'remove and replace' to make it better for all readers. Bringingthewood (talk) 23:16, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
"Bottom line, these drive-by removals won't fly with NFL players." The articles will comply with BLP or the disputed content will be removed. Period. Where is the source in Stefan Arngrim that says he was born in Canada? If there is one it's not added as an inline citation to "Canada" and I've removed it again. I don't understand why this is so difficult. You need to add a citation if you want that info kept. Iggy pop goes the weasel (talk) 23:20, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
See why I'm not in the mood? You actually didn't look in the article for it? In Arngrim's biography section, before reference #'s 1 and 2, #2 states he's Canadian and born in Canada. That's why I asked if it was okay that I just removed Toronto, Ontario. You went back and only hit the infobox (again) and the Canadian lead.
"He is perhaps best known for his role as Barry Lockridge on the Irwin Allen television series Land of the Giants which aired from 1968 to 1970. Arngrim was born in Canada, the son of actress Norma MacMillan and Thor Arngrim."
Do you know how many NFL articles are written like that. Won't fly. Period. Bringingthewood (talk) 01:36, 19 November 2026 (UTC)
Kagusthan Ariaratnam
Dear Wikipedia Volunteer Response Team,
I am writing to respectfully request an administrative and editorial review of the Wikipedia biography about me, Kagusthan Ariaratnam (Kagusthan_Ariaratnam), as well as to report paid-editing solicitations I have received since a Conflict of Interest (COI) banner was placed on the page.
1. Full Disclosure and Adherence to Wikipedia Guidelines Recently, while searching online for my memoir, Spy Tiger: The 05 File, I discovered that an independent editor had created a biographical article about me. Completely unfamiliar with Wikipedia’s Conflict of Interest policies at the time, I naively created an account (K ariara) and uploaded three personal images—a profile photograph, my book cover, and an award medal from the Institute of Defence and Strategic Studies (IDSS) at Nanyang Technological University—under the mistaken impression that Wikipedia functioned like a standard author profile.
Once I realized this was against Wikipedia's rules, I immediately stopped editing the article directly. In September 2026, I posted a formal disclosure on the article’s Talk page acknowledging my mistake and committing to submitting any future factual corrections strictly through the Talk page using independent, reliable secondary sources.
2. Neutrality, Sourcing, and Biographies of Living Persons (BLP) Concerns Following the placement of the September 2026 COI notice at the top of my biography (screenshot attached), the article has undergone edits that have left it vulnerable to unfair framing and factual distortion, affecting both my personal reputation and the reception of my work. Specifically, the current version suffers from structural and sourcing issues that conflict with Wikipedia’s Biographies of Living Persons (WP:BLP) and Neutral Point of View (WP:NPOV) standards:
Unbalanced Framing: The article places disproportionate emphasis on contentious claims while lacking proper encyclopedic balance across my broader background, education, and career.
Sourcing and Tone Issues: Certain valid credentials—such as my 2003 award from the Institute of Defence and Strategic Studies at Nanyang Technological University—currently lack independent citations, putting them at risk of removal, while other sections (such as Project O Five and Spy Tiger: The 05 File) rely on primary links (projectofive.ca) or stacked review quotes rather than neutral, third-party secondary reporting.
Because of the COI restriction, I am rightfully prevented from fixing these structural and sourcing issues myself, yet the lingering banner signals to readers, researchers, and journalists that the entire biography is unreliable.
3. Report of Unsolicited Paid-Editing Offers Since the COI banner appeared, I have been repeatedly contacted by individuals claiming to be "freelance Wikipedia editors" and "biography compliance consultants" offering to clean up the article and remove the tag for money:
On October 29, 2026, an individual identifying as (Redacted) contacted me offering a paid "full cleanup" after pointing out the COI tag.
On November 4, 2026, an individual identifying as (Redacted) contacted me claiming he and his team could rewrite the article and remove the maintenance tag for a fee of $500 USD. (At first, I was unsure whether these messages came from official Wikipedia moderators; once I realized they were external paid-editing solicitations, I declined to pay them.)
I have attached the complete PDF records of these email threads so Wikipedia’s administrators can investigate and take any appropriate action against undisclosed paid editing.
4. Request for Assistance In accordance with Wikipedia’s policies for subjects of biographies, I kindly ask if uninvolved, experienced editors or administrators could review the Kagusthan Ariaratnam article to:
Ensure the biography strictly complies with WP:BLP and WP:NPOV, removing any biased framing or poorly sourced assertions while summarizing my book and career in an encyclopedic, neutral tone.
Guide me on the proper process for providing independent, reliable third-party sources on the Talk page so neutral editors can verify my credentials (including my IDSS award and career history) and eventually resolve the September 2026 COI banner.
Thank you very much for your time, your dedication to maintaining fairness and accuracy on Wikipedia, and your help in resolving this matter cleanly and transparently.
Sincerely,
Kagusthan Ariaratnam
Lead Analyst, Project O Five Ltd
Wikipedia Username: K ariara —Preceding unsigned comment added by K ariara (talk • contribs) 03:02, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Did you use an LLM to help you compose this? If you did please read WP:LLMTALK and come back with something that was written without the help of LLMs or you may find you are ignored. About the paid editing solicitations, we know these happen and a lot of them are not even genuine but scams Wikipedia:Scam warning, I suggest you continue to ignore them either way. Feel free to send any emails etc you have received to paid-en-wpwikipedia.org since while there's often not that much we can do, we can at least block any accounts they used here to contact you. But please do not post them or any identifying information (even if it is likely fake) like names, usernames, company names, email addresses or other contact information here unless the editor themselves posted it publicly here since this will generally violate WP:OUTING. To be clear, this includes any allegations that they are editor X when editor X has not publicly confirmed it here. If there's any confusion please email it rather than post it here since they will advise you if it's okay to post it publicly. Please do not upload PDFs of any email threads on any Wikimedia site and do not post links to any PDFs (or anything) you've made of these email threads here. Note that the email is only for the paid editing stuff. It is not the place to get help with any disputes over or changes you want to make to any article. Please keep that here. Nil Einne (talk) 10:05, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
If you have already contacted the VRT and they asked you to come here, it's likely they will have dealt with any paid editing stuff as much as they can & there's no need for further contact unless they get back to you asking for more. You can ask them if you have any doubts. Nil Einne (talk) 10:08, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Hello there, Yes I did use LLM to edit my previous message.
I am thus rewriting it on my own words here as my issue has not been resloved yet.
I am writing to inform you that my Wikipedia profile -
The citizenship of Joji (musician) is not known, however this person is marked as Citizenship = Australia (by descent) United States. The musician was born in Japan. Someone has claimed to be an expert on citizenship rules for this person with an edit comment: "He automatically holds Australian citizenship by descent by virtue of his father being Australian. He is additionally denoted as Australian on the ARIA Charts (and elsewhere). Do not remove sourced content (can be found in Early life) without basis or consensus." There is no source. People can be on national music charts without being a citizens. There is no automatic citizenship by descent for Australia and most countries. A person can be described as "Australian" without being a citizen. Japan does not allow dual citizenship. There is no source that he is an American citizen, which was added at the same time. The edit is here . There is a false source #15 about "Filthy Frank". I seek help from Wikipedians who are familiar with WP:BLP policies to clear up this issue. Travelmite (talk) 08:33, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Even if the ARIA awards did require Australian citizen IMO it would still be WP:Syn to list them as an Australian citizen without a source more directly mentioning it. It's find for their nationality to be Australian based on it though IMO. Nil Einne (talk) 09:42, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Stojan Radenović
Stojan Radenović (edit|talk|history|protect|delete|links|watch|logs|views): dispute over describing him as acting President of the National Assembly and acting President of Serbia. Sources (CRTA, N1) describe him only as the oldest deputy chairing the constitutive sitting; no source for "acting" has been offered, only editors' readings of primary law. Discussion: Talk:Stojan Radenović. Outside eyes welcome. Communispyrus (talk) 14:12, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
A user keeps editing this article to add in press releases as citations, often adding a promotional tone. Some other users have also flagged the edits as possibly coming from an LLM.
The user "fancyflamingosinFlorida" keeps re-adding content w/ a promotional tone. I note the subject of the page was a US Attorney in Florida.
It appears this other user has consistently added promotional content to this wikpiedia page since 2022. —Preceding unsigned comment added by Johnbrownsbody120 (talk • contribs) 03:59, 19 November 2026 (UTC)