Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Incidents

Administrators' noticeboard/Incidents

This page is for urgent incidents and chronic, intractable behavioral problems.

When starting a discussion about an editor, you must leave a notice on their talk page; pinging is not enough.

You may use {{subst:ANI-notice|thread=}} ~~~~ to do so.

Closed discussions are usually not archived for at least 24 hours. Routine matters might be archived more quickly; complex or controversial matters should remain longer. Sections inactive for 72 hours are archived automatically by Lowercase sigmabot III. Editors unable to edit here are sent to the /Non-autoconfirmed posts subpage. (archives, search)

Apparent co-ordinated editing by SPAs at Nury Turkel

Over at Nury Turkel, a number of highly suspicious SPA accounts have removed and/or advocated for the removal of, the well sourced allegation that Turkel engaged in sexual harassment and subsequently resigned from the Uyghur Human Rights Project against multiple established contributors One of these SPAs made a thread at BLPN Wikipedia:Biographies_of_living_persons/Noticeboard#BLP:_Nury_Turkel--paragraph_on_allegations_and_resignation. Not counting the opinions of these SPAs, there seems to be an overwhelming opinion to retain the content. I am concerned that these accounts are sockpuppetry or meatpuppetry aimed at distorting the Wikipedia consensus regarding the issue. An account claiming to be the subject (Nturkel) has also posted to the article's talkpage, again requesting removal of the content. A sockpuppet investigation has been opened Wikipedia:Sockpuppet_investigations/Bizuyghur covering two of the accounts, which came back as "possible" that they were the same person, but the investigation seems to have stalled, and new accounts keep coming out of the woodwork to remove the content. Hemiauchenia (talk) 02:50, 10 November 2026 (UTC)

Even before the co-ordinated SPA editing, I had raised my concern about possible COI editing by the @OrbisLex account on the COI notice board (here). I am becoming even more convinced of the problem as the SPAs multiply. A further problematic element is apparent WP:LLM use across some of the meatpuppet, sockpuppet, or off-wiki canvassed account (see the notice board discussion linked above). JArthur1984 (talk) 03:47, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
Can somebody get the CU checks and clerking at the SPI pages over and done with? This had been dragging on for far too long. Hemiauchenia (talk) 01:57, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
I’d read this already. I’m asking about the opening claim that this was a “well-sourced allegation” and that Turkel later resigned. Which reliable sources support that? NOTUS article says the investigation found nothing to substantiate the allegations. Its July article says Turkel stepped down the following week, but doesn’t say why. RFA later took down its resignation story and changed its July article. Sautman’s footnote points to the earlier RFA article. What current sources support the paragraph as written? WildHorse1 (talk) 15:43, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

I've requested article protection at WP:RPPI. --Hipal (talk) 17:31, 10 November 2026 (UTC)

I’m replying so my silence isn’t read as anything other than not having had time to read everything carefully.
I have no connection to Nury Turkel and am not paid by anyone. I’m not Bizuyghur, and I haven’t asked anyone to edit or comment for me on- or off-wiki. I raised the BLP concern because I believe the paragraph goes beyond what the sources support. The details are at BLPN.
I removed the paragraph three times and shouldn’t have kept doing that. I haven’t edited the article since 30 October and won’t while this is discussed.
I use AI tools for research, fact-checking and typo fixes, and I’ve also used them to help draft some of my posts. I’m happy to answer any questions about that or anything else.
I’d ask that the BLPN discussion continue alongside this one, where I’ve set out the sourcing points. OrbisLex (talk) 03:43, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
For the record, the sockpuppet investigation found the following regarding the alleged connection between Bizuyghur and OrbisLex The technical connection is Possible - they share an ISP, and from the same region. Hemiauchenia (talk) 17:06, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
@Hemiauchenia: I think there's an important distinction here. SPI finding was "Possible" not confirmed. It says the accounts shared an ISP and were from the same region. That doesn't prove the two accounts belong to the same person or that anyone was coordinating edits.
I also don't think it's fair to call editors "highly suspicious" just because they've questioned the paragraph or its sources. People should be able to raise concerns about content without having their motives questioned. We should remember WP:AGF.
The paragraph is still being discussed at BLPN. I removed it once and explained my reasons in the edit summary. My concern is that it leaves out important findings from the investigation, RFA's later removal of its coverage, and UHRP's public statements that the allegations were unsubstantiated and that there was no pattern of sexually inappropriate conduct. These are important facts and shouldn't be overlooked.
I also question whether the Sautman book and the Turkish publication are reliable sources for these claims, particularly given their reliance on the now-removed RFA story and UHRP statements. Calling the paragraph "well sourced" doesn't answer those questions. We need to look at what these sources actually say and whether they support the paragraph under WP:BLP, WP:RS and WP:NPOV.
This is not about taking sides or deciding which editors should prevail. It's about looking at the evidence fairly. We're discussing allegations in a living person's biography, so we should be especially careful about what we include and how we present it. Bizuyghur (talk) 20:29, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
Fresh accounts like Yalqun Tash (talk · contribs) coming in to edit an article in order to to WP:TAGTEAM edit war against established users, or like ApikiMika (talk · contribs), coming in to weight on BLP discussions is highly suspicious. It is of course perfectly fine for Nury Turkel to make his case on the talkpage to remove the content on BLP grounds, disclosing his inherent conflict of interest, but attempting to manipulate Wikipedia via what seem very likely to be a mass of meatpuppet/sockpuppet accounts is not. Hemiauchenia (talk) 20:43, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
As an established editor, you should know better than to make statements like the one in your message, referring to "the well-sourced allegation that Turkel engaged in sexual harassment and subsequently resigned from the Uyghur Human Rights Project."
What exactly do you mean by "well-sourced"? Do you seriously consider Sautman and Aydınlık reliable sources for making allegations of this nature? I would suggest taking a closer look at the background of both before describing their reporting as reliable.
Aydınlık's reporting on Turkel is particularly concerning. One of its headlines actually labels him a "harasser" while framing him in the context of Uyghur separatism. I think that alone should give editors reason to look carefully at the source and consider whether it meets Wikipedia's standards for contentious material about living people.
You have stated that Turkel engaged in sexual harassment. That is a serious allegation. What evidence can you point to that establishes this actually occurred? And where is the evidence that it had anything to do with his resignation?
Wikipedia's policies on Biographies of Living Persons (WP), Reliable Sources (WP), and Verifiability (WP) are there for a reason. We have a responsibility to look at what the sources actually establish, rather than turn allegations into statements of fact. Bizuyghur (talk) 21:07, 15 November 2026 (UTC)

Should we request protection of the article talk page at this point? --Hipal (talk) 18:18, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

Not enough activity there. I only see one potential SPA editing there. EvergreenFir (talk) 18:25, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

Ggck2/Flavonoids Yet Again

Ggck2 (talk · contribs · deleted contribs · logs · filter log · block user · block log)

Last month, Ggck2 was brought to ANI not long after being unblocked (the original block was disruptive COI editing and then maintained because of lying). A topic ban was proposed and discussion of it kind of petered out inconclusively.

October discussion

After a month away from editing, Ggck2 has now returned, and immediately resumed edit warring at Flavonoid , , , . Getting Ggck2 to use the COI edit template has been challenging, because of their insistence (in the summary) that there has to be an active consensus that they have a COI on an edit for it to be considered a COI edit.

Rather than seek discussion or any of the normal WP:DR steps, Ggck2 has now taken the step to file an extremely frivolous ArbCom request after being warned on their talk page by two different editors about edit warring.

To pick up where the last discussion ended up, I don't see any signs of this problem resolving itself without sanctions. User:Rosguill admirably took a leap of faith in giving Ggck2 a chance to return despite the dishonesty and ongoing COI issues, in (I believe) the hopes that this editor could work within Wikipedia's constraints and improve our articles in this area. I believe that this has not worked out, and as such, propose that Ggck2 be topic-banned from food science and nutrition, broadly construed.

I believe here is at least some chance that, forced to edit topics in which they do not have a difficult COI to navigate, they may learn to learn to work with the Wikipedia community and maybe even someday return to this topic area successfully. I support an indefinite block/community ban as alternate options, though I prefer the simpler topic ban. CoffeeCrumbs (talk) 19:00, 10 November 2026 (UTC)

Support. ArbCom request was hilarious. Jako96 (talk) 19:17, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
I haven't looked through this in depth but my impression of the October discussion was that Ggck2's concerns were partially vindicated, with some participants calling for boomerang sanctions against Zefr (and others agreeing with the case against Ggck2). ARBCOM wasn't the appropriate next step, but I don't think it's unreasonable for an inexperienced editor to come away from an inconclusive ANI thread and think that this comprises the community exhausting efforts to deal with the case. The edit warring, however, is completely unacceptable and I don't understand why they would have thought that was appropriate, so that may in the end be actual cause for sanctions. signed, Rosguill talk 19:33, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
Support - immediately resuming an edit war upon returning is not a good idea. Hopefully they can be normal in other topic areas. GarethBaloney (talk) 19:35, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
I apologise for using ArbCom prematurely - I naïvely assumed this to be a less formal way to come to a solution that provides me with a clear guidance on how I should proceed. At least to me, the ANI thread was inconclusive - hence I have made a request for information on the Conflict of Interest noticeboard Special:Diff/1384538723, where I was directed to WP:EXPERT.
Regarding the accusation of "edit warring": I have made several changes to the Flavonoid article in recent days, and the first two (Special:Diff/1384710117 and Special:Diff/1384712550) were accepted and corrected by @Zefr (Special:Diff//1384716423). I did interpreted this as a sign that following the ANI discussion, we have found some kind of common ground were an editing is accepted.
I have made a further edit today which was - in my opinion - very similar to the ones made before (Special:Diff/1384887441)) and supported by relevant references, and suddenly, they were reverted with a WP:COIEDIT comment. Considering the edits the day before, the discussion on ANI and the advice I have been given, I did consider this to be unreasonable, especially as none of the edits introduced fundamental changes but simply corrected outdated and incorrect information.
Admittedly, I have found myself in a difficult position. Prior to the ANI discussion, @Zefr declined an WP:COIEDIT request on the topic in question (metabolism of flavonoids) without engaging with the scientific argument. Now, they have simply reverted an edit that was based on WP:MEDRS and meeting all relevant criteria and refused to engage. Reverting the revert was unwise, and I apologise for doing this. However, being essentially blocked from contributing by an editor who declines any edit they disagree with - makes contribution difficult.
As I have said before in ANI: I would like to contribute on topics where I have expertise - and I am more than happy to follow the relevant rules. But the recommendations I have been given were contradicting. When using WP:COIEDIT, it was queried why I believe that I have a COI just because it is my research area Special:Diff/1378667727. As part of my unblocking, I have asked @Rosguill for advice - and I have tried to follow this advice (Special:Diff/1371806329).
I am still in the same situation as before: some editors expect me to use WP:COIEDIT for all edits in the wide field of nutrition, others find this excessive, and I appreciate that an excessive number of WP:COIEDIT simply add to the queue. I do not wish to upset anyone, I would simply appreciate a clear guidance on what to do, so that I can follow it.Ggck2 (talk) 22:19, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
Having considered this, I think it might be in the interest of everyone if I take an hiatus of several months. If this needs to be formalised, please let me know. Ggck2 (talk) 22:29, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
Support topic-ban at the very least on flavonoids, but a nutrition/food science t-ban seems appropriate as well. No doubt the editor has the ability to locate, digest, and summarise information that others can't in the field of nutrition. However, between the dissembling during their attempt to be unblocked earlier and now their laser-focus on making sure the flavonoids article says what they think it should say, I don't believe the potential benefit outweighs the very clear disruption and I find it difficult to believe they won't dissemble again. Meadowlark (talk) 05:40, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
One could apply the same criticism to others: why are all of my edits that provide data that show that polyphenols are not rapidly excreted, do not have low bioavailability or have an physiological effect (supported by WP:MEDRS evidence almost always and instantly reverted (or requests declined) without providing any scientific justification? My expertise are polyphenols - it is a subject I am familiar with and I can contribute according to WP:EXPERT. I would feel uncomfortable editing topics with which I am unfamiliar. Ggck2 (talk) 08:27, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
The dull duty of a Wikipedia editor requires the ability identify, understand, and summarise appropriate sources to produce a tertiary text. This generally doesn't take particular expertise in the subject matter. Bon courage (talk) 08:50, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
Bon courage, expertise may not be required, but it is still a highly useful asset to the project. Many errors or misleading statements would require a non-expert to consult each and every source, whereas they would be obvious to an expert or enthusiast upon reading them that they are wrong. And I've read plenty "dull" content on Wikipedia written by editors who did exactly what you describe, and had no talent in the topic. You describe a process which frankly is entirely replacable by AI, if one merely wants dull dutiful teritiary text. -- Colin°Talk 09:30, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
Obviously - but there is also a duty to ensure that the text is correct. The statement in question - which I had suggested to change for some time - was:

Flavonoids are poorly absorbed in the human body (less than 5%), then are quickly metabolized into smaller fragments with unknown properties, and rapidly excreted.

This is factually wrong - but an explanation of why this is wrong with secondary sources was simply rejected. Obviously, one can have very different opinions on the level of detail that should be included - and an experienced editor will have considerably more understanding of this than I do. However, it is difficult for me to understand why one change is accepted, another change is rejected with WP:COIEDIT as justification. Ggck2 (talk) 09:30, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
I can only presume that other editors have good reason to decline or revert your edits, Ggck2. Whether that's because they believe that the sources aren't MEDRS, that the sources don't say what you have summarised, that the information isn't due, that you have a conflict of interest and shouldn't be making the edits, or something else entirely I don't know. What I do know is that in my opinion you have been more disruptive than helpful in this area, and the unblock appeal gave me no confidence that you will be truthful if you feel that being dishonest will be more advantageous. Meadowlark (talk) 09:33, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
"Flavonoids are poorly absorbed in the human body" is a factual statement as they are nearly all bound to sugar molecules (glycosides) and do not pass straight through the intestinal wall. Please see "Research has now proven that flavonoids are poorly absorbed by the body, usually less than five percent, and most of what does get absorbed into the blood stream is rapidly metabolized in the intestines and liver and excreted from the body . Also "In general, the bioavailability of flavonoids is low due to limited absorption, extensive metabolism, and rapid excretion" . Ggck2 holds WP:Fringe views about polyphenols and that is why they were reverted. Carrot juice (talk) 17:27, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
Actually, this is a very interesting point, because in nutrition, bioavailability is often used different - which can be confusing. And with flavonoids, it is quite complicated as not all have a sugar moiety (e.g. flavanols are not glycosylated). Referring to the total amount of metabolites excreted can be more informative and is quite commonly used:

"However, total urinary recovery of flavonoid metabolites varies between less than 1% for some anthocyanins, 30% for some flavanols and about 70% for some isoflavones.[27]"

They are rapidly metabolised - as is written in the text - but not necessarily rapidly excreted, this depends on the compound. Some metabolites have half-lives of >6h, others reach their maximum concentration after 12h, which I don't think is generally considered to be "rapid".
The reference you use is a media report from 2009 - the reference I have used [] is a systematic review which, in my opinion, clearly meets WP:MEDRS. And the statements therein are commonly accepted in the field of flavonoid research and are definitely not WP:FRINGE. Ggck2 (talk) 17:45, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
I might add that a 2023 systematic review [] describes a fairly high bioavailability for one group of flavonoid.
Ggck2 (talk) 18:06, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
I disagree, there is a simple definition of bioavailability in nutrition - it doesn't fit your narrative so you move goal posts. Papers 22794138 and 36207170 co-written by Daniele Del Rio who is your colleague, and you have published letters and papers with him. You have a massive conflict of interest. Everything you cite is by the same group of researchers, the ones you are personally involved with. It is impossible for you to be impartial in this topic area. Carrot juice (talk) 18:17, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
There is a difference between the definition of bioavailability and how it is interpreted. One might not like it, but this doesn't change the fact that it is commonly used.
Paper 36207170 [] is a review conducted by a large group of authors from several European countries - it meets WP:MEDRS. The fact that I have collaborated with some of the authors (none of them is a direct colleague) does not mean that the results are unreliable or should be dismissed. In a small field such as that of flavanols, it is very difficult to find publications of authors one has never collaborated with.
You accuse me of a conflict of interest - could you please tell me which WP:COI criteria are met that are not explained via WP:EXPERT?
The changes I have suggested are supported by various sources - including the source you have just cited [] which states:

"In general, the bioavailability of flavonoids is low due to limited absorption, extensive metabolism, and rapid excretion. Isoflavones are thought to be the most bioavailable of all flavonoid subclasses, while anthocyanins and galloylated catechins are very poorly absorbed (8, 22). Yet, given the wide variability in structures within subclasses, it is difficult to generalize the absorbability and bioavailability of flavonoids based only on their structural classification."

This largely agrees with my suggested edit. Ggck2 (talk) 18:24, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
Comment Those in support may wish to clarify what exactly they are supporting, given that the motion was "an indefinite block/community ban as alternate options, though I prefer the simpler topic ban" which, by my 'rithmetic, provides for three different sanctions. -- DoubleGrazing (talk) 08:47, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
CoffeeCrumbs said "I believe that this has not worked out, and as such, propose that Ggck2 be topic-banned from food science and nutrition, broadly construed." Therefore, supporters including me support the TBAN. Also, supporters except me did include TBAN in their messages, except GarethBaloney said "Hopefully they can be normal in other topic areas.", so all supporters support the TBAN. Jako96 (talk) 17:53, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
Oppose topic-ban because the editors involved in this dispute and community in general have not helped this expert editor contribute their expertise to the project. Instead I see a couple of anti-nutrition fundamentalists determined to keep out anything that suggests food might be good for you (that's a little joke by the way, not something to pick apart) edit warring with a new editor who clearly hasn't figured out how Wikipedia works yet. There's no serious talk page response other than mocking. The first !vote on this ANI page is to laugh that they thought arbitration might be a solution. You know, the concept of "arbitration" is exactly what this needed, because the editors Ggck2 was up against were behaving terribly too. That that particular form of arbitration is unsuitable is only something experienced editors know. Laughing at a newbie (Jako96), should imo deserve a 24hr block and/or ban from this noticeboard. Their question at the COI noticeboard was met with a link to WP:EXPERT and nothing more.
Once again ANI fails to serve Wikipedia's core interest: the response to an expert getting into quite typical difficulty on their expert topic is to mock them and enforce that they must instead edit articles on English Literature or whatever. Don't you see how, em, "laughable", that is? Clearly the current situation isn't acceptable. Maybe a solution would be to hold the threat of a topic ban over Zephr and CoffeeCrumbs and MrOllie unless they together actively work with Ggck2 to educate them (as one might a friend who one had invited to Wikipedia, not as a enemy who one hates with passion) about our requirements, without the use of heavy implements and sharp sticks, and find a way to use their expertise on Wikipedia. Do the fellow edit warriors have any interest in working with others who are knowlegable but not entirely aligned with their personal beliefs and prejudices? I see no evidence of that on the talk pages or user pages, and for me, that's more concerning than some newbie getting themselves into trouble with editors who want them to get into trouble. -- Colin°Talk 09:30, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
Maybe a solution would be to hold the threat of a topic ban over Zephr and CoffeeCrumbs and MrOllie unless they together actively work with Ggck2 to educate them.
I'm having a hard time taking this as good faith comment; I have never directly commented on nutrition or food science as far as I can remember. Feel free to point out a diff if I'm mistaken. So to characterize me as an "anti-nutrition fundamentalist" is absolutely preposterous. Ggck2 has a very short rope after being unblocked following a long stretch of lying and evasion. You should propose your WP:YESEDITWARIFEXPERT idea over at the Village Pump. CoffeeCrumbs (talk) 09:35, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
I'm not going to try to parse out whether your "solution" is good faith or not, but you surely must understand the several problems inherent in expecting unpaid volunteers to be compulsory instructors. But if you think such mentoring is a good idea -- and it almost always is, after all -- I've my own solution in hand. You mentor Ggck2. You're certainly motivated to help here, and you've been around long enough to know the rules of the road. Ravenswing 10:02, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
Oppose - proposed sanctions seem harsh for an edit war. I would support a temporary ban of the article in question. I have to echo @Colin's assessment; reviewing the history and talk page of the Flavonoid article, there doesn't appear to be real effort from other editors to work with Ggck2.
Zefr replies to Ggck2's comments with very short responses that don't drive towards a solution or shared understanding (compare with this to another user elsewhere).
Here, Zefr indicated the wording was too complicated, but did not propose a simpler phrasing when asked by Ggck2.
Zefr discounted an easily verifiable fact that is unrelated to Ggck2's COI, and this inaccuracy (that the EFSA approves drugs) remains in the article today -> I corrected it myself in the meantime.
Most recently, Zefr responded over a month after Ggck2 created a talk post.
I am not excusing the edit war, but the situation is likely frustrating for Ggck2 and it is not surprising that given the lack of collaboration on the talk page, he decided to edit the page directly.
Rather than a ban, a more constructive solution would be to pair up Ggck2 with a more experienced editor willing to guide them through the wiki processes and support with translating complicated topics into easy to understand language. GreyZoneLife (talk) 12:19, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
Oppose CBAN, as that seems premature. Support temporary article space ban or partial blocks, which would allow editor to propose changes on talk pages and build consensus for edits. OhNoitsJamie talk 14:27, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
Oppose topic ban, with two comments: (1) there is no point in insisting on building consensus on talk-pages because Zefr in particular is not open to compromise; consensus is basically impossible (the umpteen RfC's and abandoned DR on flavan-3-ol are ample evidence), and (2) the argumentative situation in phytochemical articles makes it extremely unpleasant for anyone to edit in those areas. This ANI is yet another example of ANI being weaponised to win a content dispute; I don't doubt the good intentions of Ggck2's opponents, but I regard the anti-Ggck2 group as somewhat unaware of their own limitations and at risk of becoming a net negative to the quality of phytochemical articles; we need Ggck2's side of the argument to retain balance. Elemimele (talk) 17:39, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
I think this discussion has reached a point where it might be best to pause. I am very used to scientific disagreements, and I don't mind being criticised. But I do think that one can disagree without piling on personal attacks. Speculations about my relationship with other scientists, comparing fairly main-stream opinion in flavonoid research (that are supported by sources that all sides seem to agree) with Panspermia and accusing me of "pumping out countless papers for the last 10 years claiming polyphenols offer all sorts of of protective effects against major chronic diseases" (which is demonstrably wrong) are - in my opinion - a step too far (see Special:Diff/1385069087).
I do not wish to upset anyone, and I would have appreciated if this discussion could have been had without personal attacks. As I have said before, I'm happy to contribute and it would have been helpful to have the rules to follow outlined in a way that is as unambiguous as sensible. But it appears that this is not possible. Ggck2 (talk) 18:56, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
Ggck2, I believe my opinions were accurate. I just read a paper you published in 2002 claiming health benefits from dietary polyphenols. You have been at this for over 24 years but never provide the evidence. It's ok publishing all this mechanism or pathway data, I applaud your dedication and you are an expert on molecular structures. But this personal group of researchers you are involved with 24 years later have still not provided any good clinical evidence that polyphenols offer any significant health effects. It is all just noise. I realize promoting polyphenols is your career and day job and I am not saying your research is not legitimate but you obviously have a massive COI on this topic. It's not just the COI, you have been arguing for all sorts of health benefits from polyphenols for nearly 3 decades so I don't see how you could impartially contribute to a page in this area when we see a lot of disruptive edits. BTW before anyone weighs in and accuses me of an anti-polyphenol bias, 4-5 years ago I was a big believer that polyphenols had significant health benefits and I was adding sources to Wikipedia but I realized I was wrong. Similar to the last ANI thread this has gone off topic again so it's not worth continuing this discussion about polyphenols here. Carrot juice (talk) 21:36, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
The three papers I have published in 2002 were all about metabolism of polyphenols - claims about potential health benefits of compounds might be in there (I can't remember), but my work always focused on metabolism and the identification of metabolites. By all means, scrutinise my publication record - it's public and you might notice that I have published null results as well as results that show an association with health. You might however also notice that I am very clear about potential adverse effects. You make very bold claims that I have been promoting "all sorts of health benefits from polyphenols" for the last 30 years - which is simply not true. If you make such an accusation, I think you should provide evidence.
And I think here is a conflation of different questions:
  • How are polyphenols metabolised? - this is the core question for the discussion here. There is ample evidence - some of which cited by you - that polyphenols (please note - this is a much larger group than flavonoids) vary considerably in their metabolism, with some having a bioavailability (in the loose sense used in nutrition) of considerably more than 5% - and some remain in the body much longer than 12h
Whether these compounds have a physiological effect or an health benefit are quite different questions, and for the majority of polyphenols - or flavonoids - I simply do not know and therefore would not suggest any edits in this respect. As you know, I have an opinion about one group of polyphenols, but I have learned - and understand and completely agree - that this does not meet the evidence threshold for here.
You also accuse me of WP:DE: I have attempted to work within the rules and guidelines given to me.Ggck2 (talk) 22:27, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
I have attempted to make an edit to an unrelated topic (Hippuric acid), using two references, both of which have been reviews. This has instantly been reverted by @Zefr with the justification that these references were outdated - even though they refer to biological pathways:
Special:Diff/1385675789
This edit has nothing to do with health benefits or my research; I know some of the authors of one source, none of the other source.
I would really appreciate some guidance on what I should do.Ggck2 (talk) 18:02, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
According to WP:DISCLOSE, you have to disclose if you have a WP:COI about something. That editor's revert might be justified if your edit was from a COI, but you didn't declare it. However I do not really know if you have a COI about that article or not. Btw, to note, it's not against the policies or guidelines to edit articles that you have a COI with, but if you do, you must declare it per the WP:DISCLOSE, which is part of the WP:COI guideline. Jako96 (talk) 18:20, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
My COI are all disclosed on my talk page and I have sought advice - which has been contradictory. Some believe that I don't need to use WP:COIEDIT for all edits, others believe it has to be done for all edits they disagree with (and then simply decline it). If I want to contribute? At the moment, I'm essentially blocked from contributing by editors who revert edits and decline requests.Ggck2 (talk) 18:33, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
It's frankly sad to hear this. You should probably try to follow WP:BRD with Zefr, but if you'd not be satisfied from that, then you can go to the relevant WikiProjects for further discussion. You can also go to the teahouse for further help, but be sure to ask general questions. Jako96 (talk) 18:40, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
Thank you! Ggck2 (talk) 18:51, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
Your editing is obviously disputed, whether you have a COI or not, so you should be discussing these things on talk pages, not trying to edit war them in. You do indeed have to discuss on talk pages to secure WP:CONSENSUS support for any edit someone disagrees with. That's not unique to you, we all have to do that. MrOllie (talk) 18:42, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
I'm happy to discuss then in good faith, but this does not appear to be possible (look at previous discussion, that consist mainly of and hominem accusations and a very selective rejection of arguments).
In this instance, I simply added some evidence to a statement that was already in the article (polyphenols as precursor of hippuric acid) which is well established in the literature and added a review that is a WP:MEDRS source). What else should I do? @Zefr removed my edit and the text in the ledge, instead of simply looking at the sources. Ggck2 (talk) 18:49, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
You can discuss this at WP:CHEMICALS. Also, @Zefr, I noticed that you marked Ggck2 as a COI editor but still reverted their edit. It's not against the policies or guidelines to edit pages that you have a COI with. Jako96 (talk) 18:59, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
What else should I do? - You haven't even tried to discuss it in this instance. In the recent edits to Flavonoid you jumped straight to edit warring. If you're not willing to even try to discuss you should not be editing either.
You have obviously faced a lot of disagreement, but that's how it goes sometimes. You have dispute resolution processes available to you, but ultimately you will have to find some way to discuss and coexist with Zefr, who is a long time editor who is interested in this topic area.
Having looked at the discussions I do not agree that your summary ('mainly of and hominem accusations and a very selective rejection of arguments') is accurate. MrOllie (talk) 19:00, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
I have tried to suggest changes via WP:COIEDIT on flavonoids, but it was rejected in a way by that did he it allow any discussion - because the criticism were not relevant (I used references to explain my edit that were not WP:MEDRS - but did not suggest to include them in the edit.
On a different article (polyphenols) a suggested edit was rejected, questions asked and answers simply ignored. At an RfC on Flavanols, my contribution was simply deleted.
I don't mind scientific disagreement, but it is difficult to have such a discussion when one side refuses to engage (and for example dismissed as unacceptable all publications of authors that were ever a co-author of me.
Ggck2 (talk) 19:25, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
I've reverted Zefr's edit per my message above that editing an article you have a COI with, as long as you declare it, is not a violation. However, any editor should feel free to revert my revert for another reason. Jako96 (talk) 19:07, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
MrOllie et al., I think the problem here is that Ggck2 has attempted to discuss, at length, over years, but has met not one tiniest bit of compromise; Ggck2 isn't alone in their views. Something I find completely inappropriate, was Zefr's rejection of Ggck2's CoI edit request here. Zefr has brought Ggck2 to ANI and made it quite clear that they abhor Ggck2's position and want them banned from editing. I think this makes Zefr extremely involved, far too involved to be assessing Ggck2's edit requests - if they're going to do so, Ggck2 is effectively already banned from editing on phytochemicals because they cannot make edit requests with a chance of acceptance greater than 0%, and they cannot edit without being reverted. There is, as I've found at Flavan-3-ol, no point in discussing when people have adopted utterly rigid positions. Elemimele (talk) 20:07, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
Yes. I think there's a hounding issue by @Zefr in this case. Zefr, please address these issues here. Jako96 (talk) 20:09, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
And a biting issue, to add. Jako96 (talk) 20:10, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
Daniele Del Rio is a personal friend and colleague of Ggck2 and they have both co-authored papers and letters (for nearly 3 decades in fact). This was already mentioned a few days ago. I find this unacceptable that Ggck2 is still inserting papers by his friend Daniele Del Rio onto Wikipedia. This is not neutral editing. I am not going to waste time listing diffs but but I could upon request but I have counted over 10 times that Ggck2 has inserted his colleague Daniele Del Rio as a reference on polyphenol related articles (so this is not new behaviour). This user was caught very early on inserting his own papers onto Wikipedia but as of date he is still inserting his colleagues papers. I don't see any other option other than a topic-ban on polyphenols for this user. At this point I believe the block should be made quicker than later as there might be other COI edits. Carrot juice (talk) 22:05, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
I certainly feel far more strongly about a topic ban at a minimum if there are more hidden COI edits hiding. Zefr's conduct has been far from perfect, but I still see Ggck2 as the proximate cause of issues here, and the editor with by far the shortest rope due to their history of dishonesty and evasion and an ongoing COI. CoffeeCrumbs (talk) 22:11, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
Are you able to be more specific about the "hidden COI edits"? GreyZoneLife (talk) 22:22, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
Can you please tell me where I acted against the COI rules? I have asked multiple times for clarification - and it appears that there is not a consensus. However, my edits do not promote anything or stray from mainstream consensus. In contrast, the edits enforced by other editors are often outdated and deliberately ignore any evidence that suggests a physiological effect of phytochemicals.
Ggck2 (talk) 22:23, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
Is there something inaccurate or misleading about the sources that Ggck2 proposes/introduces? From what I can see here in the guidance for medical experts article, citing even your own work is permitted if it is recent, relevant work. Similarly, if Del Rio is doing relevant, noteworthy work, we shouldn't be excluding it just because Ggck2 happens to know her. The edits and sources should be evaluated on their merits. GreyZoneLife (talk) 22:20, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
"Daniele Del Rio is a personal friend" - I am really surprised at the claims that are made here by people who do not know me. We have co-authored one paper on ultra-processed foods.
Please provide evidence for your accussations.
Ggck2 (talk) 22:21, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
We should not be linking to anything per WP:OUTING but I have seen a paper and a letter you co-authored with that person. Also I checked your former account Ggux and there examples going back many years where you have cited that person's papers on Wikipedia. I do not think it is incorrect to say this a colleague of yours. You are obviously in contact with them. Jeremy P. E. Spencer is also a colleague of yours (you also created their article) and you have cited this person on Wikipedia. I have no objection to citing these people but this does fit the description of a "hidden COI edit" as you did not disclose anywhere you co-author papers with these academics. Carrot juice (talk) 01:04, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
I have one single publication with Del Rio, on a very different topic. We work in the same field but don't collaborate - it's not really surprising that I use their papers as references as I would not want to use one of mine. You claim that from all that you can infer a "personal friendship", yet you still have not provided any evidence for this.
In a very small field such as flavanol research, the choice of reviews is very limited - and another author of the paper in question is the reviewer of the Linus Pauling Institute's documents, which are used by a range of editors; are they therefore also questionable?
I edit here with my full name and everyone can easily see what I have done, with whom I have published etc - I don't think I can be any more transparent. Ggck2 (talk) 07:18, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
This is becoming slightly ridiculous, but as @Carrot juice keeps making false accusations:

"[...] Ggck2 and they have both co-authored papers and letters (for nearly 3 decades in fact)."

This is a Pubmed search of publications that we have co-authored: []
The review I have used [] has been cited more than 3500 times [] - it is a fairly commonly used review, and there are unfortunately not many alternatives that are not primary sources.
I assumed that 'guilt by association' is something of the past, but clearly it is not for some people. Earlier this year, @Zefr dismissed studies Special:Diff/1357460885 partly because the authors are colleagues/collaborators.
Now, @Carrot juice makes insinuations about personal relationships (without any evidence) - all to stop any statement that could possibly make claims about phenolic compounds that does not meet certain criteria. Ggck2 (talk) 07:43, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
Ggck2 I apologize, I was confusing Jeremy P. E. Spencer with Daniele Del Rio. You have co-authored only one paper and letter with Del Rio, but the source in question you have added many times to Wikipedia was co-written with Spencer. This person works at your university and you have co-written at least 8 papers together going back decades so my comment was accurate. You also wrote his Wikipedia article. I have mentioned this here . I think it is problematic when you add your friends papers to Wikipedia and do not even put a note in an edit summary but it appears this ANI discussion has tilted and users are now saying they have no issue with you doing that. I am not convinced, but let's just agree to disagree. Lastly, you have received funding and unrestricted grants from Mars Inc for many years. There isn't really any difference to yourself and someone funded by Beef Checkoff in my opinion. At the end of the day they are pushing red meat and you are pushing flavanol supplements. I do not feel the need to engage you any further. It is impossible to have neutral editing with this type of industry-funded research. This will die down for a while but I suspect we may be back at this ANI board in the future over COI editing but I will not be further commenting. Carrot juice (talk) 15:10, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
Apology accepted - thanks. And I think I have outlined why I have chosen this paper. Should we suspect everyone who keeps citing the Linus Pauling Institute's page on micronutrient of having an ulterior motive, or assess the source based on the source?
I'm not sure where I push flavanol supplements, or where an edit on hippuric acid precursors is tainted by previous funding. It is perfectly possible to have neutral editing - and other editors are more than welcome to challenge an edit if they believe it is wrong. However, that does not mean every edit is biased and most edits that were rejected had nothing to do with flavanols (I have decided to stay away from that topic for this very reason and will only engage on the talk page and answer requests).
Everyone is biased - I think this is something we can all agree on - and it is therefore important to recognise and address these biases as much as possible. Ggck2 (talk) 15:18, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
Oppose. There's a clear biting and hounding issue here, especially by Zefr. I earlier supported the TBAN at a first glance, but when the biting issue is taken into consideration, until there's clear evidence through discussion that Ggck2 can't edit constructively in these areas, no sanction should be applied. Also, "indefinite block/community ban" are definitely not "alternate options". Jako96 (talk) 07:58, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
As I have said before, I do not mind to be criticised for content or indeed for conduct - I am not an experienced editor and I am still learning how to contribute best. And of course, I have made mistakes and I try to address them. However, I believe that some editors have now crossed a line - and perhaps someone else could help to put the discussion on a track that helps to resolve the problem.
@Carrot juice has spent considerable time attacking me, and doing so with false claims. First, there was an accusation of a personal relationship that was only rectified after several attempts at correction. Now, I am accused of being a paid editor:

Lastly, you have received funding and unrestricted grants from Mars Inc for many years. There isn't really any difference to yourself and someone funded by Beef Checkoff in my opinion.

I have never made any promotional edits, I was never paid for editing and I was never given any instructions for editing. This is the second time @Carrot juice made personal attacks here, without having provided any evidence. Ggck2 (talk) 15:50, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
I have not made any false claims. I confused your friend Jeremy P. E. Spencer with Daniele Del Rio. Yeah that was a mistake which I apologize for. All of the claims I made were factual. Jeremy P. E. Spencer works at your university and you have co-authored papers with him for decades and you have spent years on Wikipedia on both of your accounts inserting him as a reference. Pointing this out is not an attack. You created his Wikipedia article. So far I have counted 8 papers you co-authored with him since 2003. I listed some of these here. As of November 2026 you are still inserting your friend Spencer papers onto Wikipedia articles .
Both yourself and Jeremy P. E. Spencer receive unrestricted research grants from Mars Inc to conduct your polyphenol research. Again this is not an attack. Anyone can read your papers even recent (2026) and it says "G. G. C. K. has received an unrestricted grant from Mars, incorporated" . I did not suggest you are being paid to edit Wikipedia, I basically said your industry funded polyphenol research is no different than someone working for Beef Checkoff. I stated this as an opinion not a fact. In your most recent paper you make the claim that flavanol intake can significantly reduce the risk of cardiovascular death. This is an industry funded claim that lacks scientific evidence. As noted by Prof Naveed Sattar there was no real evidence yet showing actual reductions in heart disease outcomes . Carrot juice (talk) 18:39, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
I have pointed out the mistake and you kept doubling down - but I accept your apology and that's fine.
But you accused me of being a paid editor by likening me to someone receiving Beef Checkoff funding. That's quite different: before, you simply speculated about my personal relationships, now you accuse me of violating Wikipedia rules. I do not deny my funding - why should I? It's declared where appropriate.
You continue with personal attacks:

"In your most recent paper you make the claim that flavanol intake can significantly reduce the risk of cardiovascular death. This is an industry funded claim that lacks scientific evidence."

This is a very strong claim, and - the way it is written - it is a statement of fact, not opinion. But it is also irrelevant here, unless you can provide any evidence for me making claims without evidence. Could we please return to the actual topic and stop ad hominem attackes?Ggck2 (talk) 18:59, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
It is not forbidden to have a conflict of interest (Ggck2's are declared) and you are allowed to cite even your own work (if done neutrally) as an expert editor. The trend in these discussions is that Ggck2 is interested in discussing edits and improvements to articles, and in return certain other editors instead discuss him and his intentions rather than the suggestion itself. See WP: NEGOTIATE. GreyZoneLife (talk) 18:59, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
I agree. Editors such as Zefr and Carrot juice are quite biting Ggck2 in my opinion. Completely apart from that, to note, with a simple Google search, I can see that "flavanol intake can significantly reduce the risk of cardiovascular death" is pretty correct, but this of course arguably might not be true (Google isn't a reliable source itself, so I understand a small opposition on this, but Google is still a good tool on such relatively broadly known topics), but it's definitely worth noting. Jako96 (talk) 19:10, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
@Carrot juice. So, here is the edit by Ggck2 you provided above as COI and problematic. What exactly was wrong except a minor typo? It uses two supporting references, the second of which is not to Spencer. Was this edit an improvement? I am not an expert in this, but the included info seem to be relevant. Yes, anything on the the risk of cardiovascular death would need to be WP:MEDRS supported, but BBC you used is not one of such sources. My very best wishes (talk) 19:08, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
Jako96, there is no good clinical or consistent epidemiological evidence that flavanol intake can significantly reduce the risk of cardiovascular death. There is only one industry funded study the COSMOS Trial that found that participants taking a cocoa extract supplement (500 mg cocoa flavanols/ 80 mg epicatechin) reduced CVD death by 27%. The supplementation did not significantly reduce total cardiovascular events. One short-term trial funded by Mars Inc who donated the cocoa extract pills fails WP:MEDRS. This is a single biased study that has had no independent replication and has no relevance to the population at large. Independent replication is very important, we do not just look at one single trial and accept it at face value that flavanols can reduce cardiovascular death. There are no dietary or clinical guidelines that make this claim. There is no WP:BMI review supporting this claim so we can not state it on Wikipedia. There is currently a discussion on the Flavonoid talk-page featuring Ggck2, Zefr, My very best wishes and Elemimele. It doesn't look like any definite conclusion is going to occur with this ANI discussion & like the last as it has gone off topic again; so I guess if anyone wants to continue these discussions it should be done at the flavonoid talk-page. Carrot juice (talk) 11:55, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
@Carrot juice - what about [Raman et al. 2019? A systematic review & meta-analysis? "Available evidence supports a beneficial effect of flavan-3-ol intake on cardiometabolic outcomes, but there was considerable heterogeneity in the meta-analysis.". There is also a recommendation by the US Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics, but since I have been a co-author, I assume we should not really rely on it as I must have dominated all other co-authors and forced them to accept my bias. (And "short term" is usually not used for studies that last several years.)
But: this is not about flavanols, is it? It's about hippuric acid. Ggck2 (talk) 12:02, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
This doesn't answer the question. The added sentence by Ggck2 to which we are referring is "Hippuric acid can also be formed from from polyphenols and aspirin by the gut microbiome." We are not debating an edit claiming that flavonoids have health benefits. GreyZoneLife (talk) 12:03, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Indeed. Jako96 (talk) 12:07, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
.. and while we're off the topic, Carrot juice, what is the justification behind your statement that the cosmos study fail WP:MEDRS? Is it because it has been published in (and its publications have been reviewed in), inadequate journals deemed unreliable via the reliable sources noticeboard? Or is it because of the Mars funding? Industrial funding does not automatically mean that research is invalid and non-notable; attempting to cite industrially-funded research does not automatically mean that an editor is a puppet of industry out to promote bad science. Elemimele (talk) 13:37, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
I think you would be just fine with editing pages directly on the subject of your research, including referencing to your articles when appropriate, i.e. per WP:SELFCITE. By the same token, I would like to see any recent edits by Ggck2 where they would promote their products or people (as opposed to making WP:V and WP:NPOV consistent contributions), inserting references on himself on pages where they do not belong or promoting clearly WP:FRINGE ideas. My very best wishes (talk) 23:03, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Generally self citation is a form of COI as it's rarely appropriate. If an editor is an expert in their field, they shouldn't be reaching for their publications of their friends first, and that problem has already been fleshed out here. KoA (talk) 15:01, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Oh no, self-citing is explicitly allowed by WP:SELFCITE, and for a good reason: we want experts to create good content. What should be cited first? It depends. It well could be that the most appropriate article (one that supports best the statement on the page) was authored by the WP contributor. I am not saying this is the case here, I would need to study this better. My very best wishes (talk) 17:20, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
WP:SELFCITE is of a different opinion - and sometimes, there are very few alternatives. The review in question is the most comprehensive review of flavonoid metabolism, and one of the most cited papers in the field. Should one use a different source simply to meet a criterion that does not exist? And is a colleague automatically a friend? Does the criterion change if this is a colleague from a different Department?
WP:SELFCITE states:

"Using material you have written or published is allowed within reason, [...]"

But the citation is not a self-cite - it includes co-authors that were at the same Department as I am. But there is further guidance linked there WP:MEDCOI

"Citing your own organization, such as a governmental health agency or an NGO producing high-quality systematic reviews, is generally acceptable – if the conflict of interest is disclosed, it is done to improve coverage of a topic, and not with the sole purpose of driving traffic to your site."

So please do show me the guideline which states that using a high-quality source supporting a very mainstream statement is not acceptable simply because it has been authored by a colleague?
The review also cites papers where I am a co-author, which - according to @Zefr (Special:Diff/1385907743 - does this mean one is required to review the references of any source and avoid any paper?
This is getting absolutely ridiculous, as it is no longer about the question whether phenolic compounds are a precursor to hippuric acid - which is the actual question. It has turned, by some, into a witch-hunt of an editor they disagree with, whom they have effectively blocked from editing and whom they want to leave. Ggck2 (talk) 15:17, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Ggck2, constantly pinging Zefr, who has indicated they are staying out of this and had nothing to add since the ANI about you in October, does come across as WP:BATTLEGROUND behavior (and it still would be even if they had commented here) They did not open this ANI about you, and last I checked, they are readily engaging on the flavinoid talk page focusing on content. You're the one raising the temperature making WP:TPNO violations by making accusations on article talk pages about editor behavior. Had that of stopped before I read through this entire ANI I may not have considered a topic ban, but you are repeatedly justifying the need for some kind of preventative sanction.
What you're engaging in here with regards to self-cite is what we call WP:WIKILAWYERING on Wikipedia. Because one section does not cover every possible scenario does not mean it's ok to insinuate there's an exception or it's fine. The COI guideline is very clear that COI can arise on things related yourself, family, friends, clients, employers, or your financial and other relationships. as a broad base. Otherwise, please read my comment below. KoA (talk) 15:50, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
I consider it polite to alert an editor to the fact that their name is mentioned - if this is not appropriate, I shall not do this. Please do tell me where I make personal attacks? I have tried - as best as possible - to abstain from any personal comments or insinuations. Which accusations have I made? I have attempted to address a core claim of the discussion - do flavonoids have an biological effect - with some data on the Flavonoid talk page. I have done this neutrally - I'm not sure what else I could have done.
The WP:Wikilawyering is something you have to pass on to others: I have been accused of violating wikipedia COI rules - and I appreciate that these are rules that I follow. However, when I point out that what is claimed to be a violation of rules is not actually in the rules, I'm accused of lawyering. I agree, the COI rules are very clear, and I have not violated them here. Ggck2 (talk) 16:05, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
I consider it polite to alert an editor to the fact that their name is mentioned - if this is not appropriate, I shall not do this. Please do tell me where I make personal attacks? I have tried - as best as possible - to abstain from any personal comments or insinuations. Which accusations have I made? I have attempted to address a core claim of the discussion - do flavonoids have an biological effect - with some data on the Flavonoid talk page. I have done this neutrally - I'm not sure what else I could have done.
The WP:Wikilawyering is something you have to pass on to others: I have been accused of violating wikipedia COI rules - and I appreciate that these are rules that I follow. However, when I point out that what is claimed to be a violation of rules is not actually in the rules, I'm accused of lawyering. Ggck2 (talk) 16:07, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Whatever the outcome of this discussion, can I suggest that an interaction ban between @Zefr and me might be sensible? I have attempted to provide some evidence that the claims which seem to be at the bottom of this argument, i.e. whether flavonoids have biological activity or not, are rather mainstream. But instead of engaging with them, in Special:Diff/1386171177 they simply dismiss all evidence as irrelevant, including references from regulatory agencies and require regulatory agency recommendation for flavonoids as the only evidence admissible (even though this is outside their remit, as they well know).
In Special:Diff/1385907743, they criticise a review article as "self-citation" because it cites some of my early work, and claim a source from 2013 to be outdated, when most of the other sources are older.
In other edits, they require studies where people are sequestered for a long time as evidence for the physiological effect of compounds, or consider well established physiological pathways as WP:Fringe theories.
For whatever reason, @Zefr will never allow me to edit any page where they believe I have a conflict - and this is not restricted to flavanols but a much wider field. So perhaps the best solution is to separate us. Ggck2 (talk) 08:03, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Furthermore, they are lobbying for a TBAN elsewhere: they have added a tag to the flavonoid talk page, which not only highlighted my COI but - in my opinion - also made a judgement about me as character. I wrongly believed that it would be appropriate to edit it, but realised that this was inappropriate and reverted it as quickly as possible Special:Diff/1386030530. They saw this as evidence of some ulterior motive Special:Diff/1386175620, called it academic misconduct that required disciplinary measures and called - again - for a TBAN:
{{blockquote|text="
  • Re: the temporary Special:Diff/1386030530 on this talk page to change COI status: specifically concerning Ggck2's bold-faced lies repeatedly about his persona as user Ggux (discussed in June during the block decision with 2 admins, Cullen328 and Yamla, and other editors) would - in the academic world - result in misconduct discipline and reputational damage. It should apply here for TBAN on all flavonoid/polyphenol and nutrition topics - how can we trust anything Ggck2 says about flavonoids when he lied about Ggux?"}
I appreciate that I have made many mistakes in the past, and that I have not always followed the letter and the spirit of the rules - but I have tried to do so, especially since the long blocking and unblocking discussion. Obviously, editors will still see me with suspicion, and I understand - trust has to be earned - and this is why I have attempted to make small and, in my opinion, uncontroversial edits that reflect fairly mainstream opinions in the field of nutrition. Zefr has decided to stay out of this discussion, but still lobbies elsewhere for bans or TBANS, and uses very unusual interpretations of rules to discredit edits - and never engage with the actual content apart from simply dismissing it. Ggck2 (talk) 09:39, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
I would agree a IBAN would be helpful. A good example of where @Zefr disregarded seemingly a reasonable and accurate request without much consideration is here. 1) The European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) does not approve drugs, it is indeed the European Medicines Agency (EMA), and 2) Ggck2 was correct, the drug Catergen was approved and subsequently rescinded, so the statement that no flavonoid drugs had ever been approved was misleading. I've since updated the section. GreyZoneLife (talk) 11:07, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Zefr is a long term editor who has been active on many of these articles for a long time - for example they first edited Flavonoid in 2009. An interaction ban may end up being more or less a topic ban for Ggck2 anyway. MrOllie (talk) 15:55, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
I'm already banned from the topic, because Zefr reverts any edit, refuses any WP:COIEDIT or any engagement with scientific arguments. We have reached a stage were evidence is rejected because it comes from an Italian regulatory agency Special:Diff/1386175620. Ggck2 (talk) 16:00, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
No one forced you into the edit warring that kicked off this thread. Blaming others doesn't excuse your own share of this problem. MrOllie (talk) 16:04, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
I completely agree that I should have behaved differently, and I have - and do so again - apologise for it. My intention is to improve articles and contribute my expertise where I can. However, it is difficult to do so when edits are selectively reverted with explanations that focus more on the person than the content, and when rules are applied in a way that is very inconsistent (e.g. a 2009 reference is fine, but a 2013 is outdated). Ggck2 (talk) 16:07, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Seeing the battleground behavior from Ggck2 and constantly pinging/WP:HOUNDING Zefr (who has not commented at this ANI and indicated the October ANI already had all they needed to say here) and then asking for an interaction ban looks really bad honestly. I was in favor of a more limited in scope topic ban related to polyphenols, but maybe something more broadly construed is needed afterall to give Ggck2 more distance from the subject. They aren't helping themselves here. KoA (talk) 16:06, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
As I have explained above: I was under the impression that it is polite to inform an editor when they are subject of a discussion. If this is against the rules, I will not do it again.Ggck2 (talk) 16:08, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
You might also wish to peruse the Flavonoid and Hippuric Acid talk pages.Ggck2 (talk) 16:11, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
  • I have decided to withdraw from Wikipedia for now. There is clearly a fundamental disagreement whether polyphenols can have a physiological effect or not, and how they are metabolised. Unfortunately, the discussion has developed in a way that focuses on me as a person and not the content. While I have attempted to follow the relevant rules, I have of course made mistakes - for which I am sorry and apologise, this was never my intention. I would like to thank those who have tried to find a solution to this.Ggck2 (talk) 16:18, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
    (I will - as I assume it is expected - wait until this discussion has ended, so I am aware of any sanctions.)Ggck2 (talk) 18:49, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Given that you have declared the COI and already have a conflict with at least one contributor (who is acting in a good faith), I would suggest you to voluntarily refrain from editing flavonoids (and other closely related compounds) and edit pages about other subjects, including unrelated biologically active compounds. Or you can suggest a specific sourced text to be included on article talk page, discuss it with others, and make an RfC if it will not be resolved and you feel this is important and others will support you. My very best wishes (talk) 19:26, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Thanks - the problem is, that won't work. I have tried this on several articles before: there were RfCs and 3rd-opinions, but they were either abandoned, not implemented or later reverted. WP:COIEDIT are declined, without any good explanation - when questions are raised, answers are simply ignored and any edits are simply reverted. Discussions are very difficult when other editors point out straight away all of my flaws but don't engage with content.
So apart from withdrawing, what else can I do? There is a point when personal attacks, circular arguments (follow the rules - but if you do follow the rules, it's WP:Wikilawyering) and a complete refusal to engage with the actual argument (i.e. whether the edits are appropriate or not) send a very clear message. Articles on many phytochemicals on here are in incredibly biased, because they ignore any data that might even hint at physiological effects. They use rules that do not exist (e.g. that a regulator must approve that a physiological effect exists) or make demands that are impossible to meet (long term studies in metabolic chambers) - and anything that could challenge the statement is simply dismissed (an EFSA Health Claim? A "cherry picked" example. An EFSA Health Warning? A "cherry picked" example.
Accusing me of not engaging or WP:HOUNDING, as done by KoA, is interesting: Carrot juice has accused me of being a paid editor, Zefr has called for bans on talk pages without informing me - many have made inferences about my character. I have tried to ignore those and stay on topic - but clearly, this violated some unwritten rule. Ggck2 (talk) 08:16, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Sorry - I forgot to add: if you read the previous discussion [], you might notice that there are other editors who find it rather difficult to edit articles on phytochemicals. They are more experienced and know that stepping away is more sensible than having an extensive discussion. In the discussion, some editors actually suggested sanctions for Zefr - something that I and many others do not want - but I think it suggests that the situation is a bit more complicated. Ggck2 (talk) 08:24, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
What can you do? I see that Zehr is one of contrubutors who aggressively remove sourced content on many pages (as a random example: ). But it requires a lot of time to critically evaluate such examples. If their edits are clearly problematic (I do not know), you might complain about them, which could result in you be sanctioned. But you have declared the COI and therefore have no chance. If you can edit in this area without causing anyone's objections (a lot of people can), then fine. But if you have a conflict like this, there is nothing you can do, please go edit something else. My very best wishes (talk) 20:11, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
i mean... we could enact the proposed 2-way iban, that's one thing we could do. I dont know enough about this topic to say who is materially correct, but some of the diffs above do seem like Zehr is just flatly rejecting all of Ggck's suggestions. There are plenty of other people in this topic area, i feel like if Ggck does decide to return, maybe it would be better to let someone else handle those requests. ~2026-61218-33 (talk) 07:10, 19 November 2026 (UTC)
This is an utterly crap conclusion to an utterly crap situation, and doesn't bode well for the content of Wikipedia. We have a situation here where what amounts to well-intentioned blinkered bullying has driven away an editor who had expertise and was trying to contribute positively in an area where many articles are, frankly, bad. I'm appalled. Elemimele (talk) 17:28, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
I can probably agree. Jako96 (talk) 17:32, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Yes, I have the same impression. GreyZoneLife (talk) 17:42, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

Unsourced edits by FilipinoTiger

FilipinoTiger (talk · contribs · deleted contribs · logs · filter log · block user · block log)

He edited unsourced details many times in MGI All Stars 2nd Edition such as in 1 Nov. and 10 Nov. in Selection Committee’s part.

/I was explained when I removed his edits as unsourced already, but he still put same unsourced details back into the same article without source and no reason, like selection committee’s names. Can you check his edits, warning and explain to him, or block him for a few day if still adding unsourced details in this article and other articles?. I seen other editor warned him about unsourced edited in his talk page before.

/and his unsourced edited are looks like IP address ~2026-57156-07 edits in this article or in Selection Committee’s part?.--PradaSaetiew (talk) 20:00, 11 November 2026 (UTC)

Information Note: Reporting someone just because of "unsourced details" is unacceptable reason, I'll quickly close this request if needed. TienMinh-mun6xnChing (talk) 18:22, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
@TienMinh-mun6xnChing: Do not inappropriately close an ANI report. I have reverted this closure. Lavalizard101 (talk) WP:SOLIDARITY 20:01, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
@Lavalizard101: The user (FilipinoTiger) behaviour is being monitored following the WP:NOTHERE, reporting this without severe warning is unnecessary, again please do not delete my message. I'm responsible for this thing and I know what to do on this mission. TienMinh-mun6xnChing (talk) 21:28, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
I’m agree with you, why we don’t waiting admin to checking his edits first before close, or waiting FilipinoTiger to discussing here because I let’s him know about this report in his talk page already.--PradaSaetiew (talk) 04:16, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

I and other editor ever warning him about Verifiability and Reliable sources in his talk page already, but it didn’t work, he still editing some of unsourced detail with same detail in the same article after it was removed. Then I looking for this option and let’s him know about this report but he removed it all from his talk page. /In other case some editor advised me that should look at other options if warnings didn’t work or can’t help.--PradaSaetiew (talk) 23:10, 15 November 2026 (UTC)

User:Asieon does not recognize core citation policies like WP:OR WP:CITE WP:RS

Asieon (talk · contribs · deleted contribs · logs · filter log · block user · block log)

User:Asieon does not recognize or understand WP:CITE WP:RS WP:OR. Per edits , they added content that was not sourced, based on only primary sources, not found in the source they added, and sourced to a fringe "pseudohistorian" Lee Deok-il . I alerted them to this multiple times but they refused to recognize their behavior and tried to get me to engage them in talk discussion . However in light of the clear cut nature of adding content without sources , their belligerent language over basic Wikipedia policies , extensive editing history going back to 2022 , previous run-in with OR issues , and prior block over socking , I thought it would be more prudent to just bring the issue here than continue engaging with the user. Qiushufang (talk) 11:54, 12 November 2026 (UTC)

This is rather disingenuous IMO. In my defense, I have stated multiple times that all the edits were properly sourced. And since Qiushufang was the only user who had issues with my edits, I respectfully asked them to engage with me in a discussion as seen here. The user also accused me of "belligerent language" which I am genuinely confused as I was neither hostile nor aggressive as seen in my response: here. In fact, I had to ask them to refrain from using negative nuances when approaching someone they have a dispute with. All in all, this is clearly indicates a violation of WP:AFG, WP:ASPERSIONS as well as WP:AVOIDYOU and WP:PA as the previous issues I had it resolved through proper discourse. In which Qiushufang has not engaged with. Asieon『✉』 12:04, 12 November 2026 (UTC)

References

To counter the "unsourced" postulation, I hereby provide the sources I in fact did provide:
  1. 中国が基礎をつくり日帝が釘を刺した ‘平壌’ の漢四郡 - by historian Lee Deok-il. Yes, this historian is considered fringe but the sentiment is shared across other sources, even in government in regards to the existence of Kija Choson. #1 #2, #3, #4 and many more. Changing the source due to author's reputation does not change what is being said in the article.
  2. '단군신화' 조작, 그 처참한 현실 - by Lee Taeryong. This article properly discusses about how Naka Michiyo debunked the existence of Kija Choson and considered it "fiction (虛構)".
  3. 『初 朝鮮王準爲衛滿所破 乃將其餘衆數千人走入海 攻馬韓 破之 自立爲韓王 其後絶滅 今韓人猶有奉其祭祀者。』 Book of the Later Han, Dongyi chapter (東夷列傳)
This above is in fact a primary source that was not present in the original version (only alluded to) which I added for better context. I did not use this as a "source" but as quote for better readability and context for the reader. In fact, I added it because the user questioned it first: "the named text was not written in ancient China, perhaps it's the wrong text?" It was to clarify that it was indeed from the same text.
So again, the user's assumption that I "made edits without sources" is clearly blatantly wrong. I am happy to have done my research, and asking for Qiushufang to refute my findings is not a "belligerent" reaction, but a genuine, heartfelt request for clarification as per WP:CON in which the user simply did not comply. Asieon『✉』 12:20, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
The addition at the bottom here has no citations at all. The Korean government sharing the same opinion as the pseudohistorian does not improve their reliability as the government itself has been criticized for citing the pseudohistorian Lee Deok-il . If the same content can be found in a reliable source then use that instead. The OR issue found here is not addressed - the content is personal analysis and not directly stated in the source. Tthe article subject does not appear in the source and the source does not have any direct statements for it. You cannot do analysis and deductions not found in the source. The WP:PRIMARY source is disconnected from the first source in another section and Wikipedia does not primarily rely on primary sources. The primary source says nothing about periodization, which works differently for China than the West and generally begins after the fall of the Han in 220 AD. I did not assume good faith for the reasons stated in my opening incident report. This is not your first rodeo, you are a multi-year editor, have had another user explicitly explain how OR works, have socked with multiple accounts in the past, lied about it , and gave yourself a barnstar for good measure . Nothing in your history suggests you are an inexperienced editor, and you have had integrity issues in the past, so I am treating you as such. Qiushufang (talk) 13:03, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
What's funny is that you could've engaged this discussion with me in my talk page and not cause a scene here, but you already chose to do this.
I'll go by one by one.
  1. The addition at the bottom here has no citations at all. That is because the page that is being alluded to clearly has it written that the state existed in 108 BCE. I did not imagine that number, it is clearly written on that page and in maps since 2008.
  2. The Korean government sharing the same opinion as the pseudohistorian does not improve their reliability as the government itself has been criticized for citing the pseudohistorian Lee Deok-il Let's use that logic in reverse. Both The Chosun Ilbo and JoongAng Ilbo are very conservative, right-wing newspapers in Korea. Meaning, both newspapers are HIGHLY biased towards right-wing agenda similar to Wikipedia's attitude towards FOX News which I think does not comply with WP:RSPS.
  3. the content is personal analysis and not directly stated in the source. How is that OR? It is clearly mentioned in Kija Chosŏn page, historians such as Sin Ch'aeho, Ryū Imanishi, and Naka Michiyo (with proper sources) clearly refuting Kija Chosŏn's existence.
  4. Wikipedia does not primarily rely on primary sources. Hence why I never used it as a source in the first place.
Finally, I do not really care about your reasons for not assuming in good faith. It is still against Wiki guidelines and especially does not warrant the personal attack I received. If you have issues with my edits/reasoning, please stay on topic, and don't bring up irrelevant past drama to reinforce your argument because it has nothing to do with King Chun or Wiman. Asieon『✉』 13:21, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
None of the reasons you gave are even remotely appropriate for not including a source or using non-RS. Just because something is alluded to does not mean it is sourced and just because right wing media criticizes something does not make it more reliable. Lee Deok-il is a nationalist pseudohistorian outside the mainstream academia by any reading of their work . There is simply nothing in the source included in the edit that mentions King Wiman or Chun or a flight to Mahan. This is original research because it is your personal deduction. Your consistent refusal and avoidance of even acknowledging the issue is the behavioral issue here. I am proposing for an admin warning and further prohibition if the issue continues. Qiushufang (talk) 13:45, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
And like wise, just because the reputation of an author is bad doesn't mean the primary source they are alluding to is false. Same logic.
Also, I am inclined to believe that you are being intentionally dense. Where in the edit does the source allude to King Wiman or Chun or a flight to Mahan?
The edit was:
However, due to the existence of Kija Chosŏn (first mentioned in Shiji and later in the Book of the Later Han) itself being scrutinized by Korean and Japanese historians, the claim (due to the nature of its connection to Kija Chosŏn) is also often scrutinized.
This was the original statement. There is a reason why the preface to the statement was written in the first place. If the kingdom of Atlantis is scrutinized then the authenticity/historicity of the ruler of Atlantis is also scrutinized because it likely never existed in the first place. You don't need to prove that Atlas was the King of Atlantis when Atlantis itself didn't exist. That is counter-intuitive thinking.
Also, trying to silence me after threatening me, lying and personally attacking me is quite low. Asieon『✉』 13:58, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
Ironically, the same newspaper that you provided has supported the very argument I made.
Because again, it is logical thinking. Nitpicking whether there's a source for every single claim doesn't undermine the overall message that was being sent. Asieon『✉』 14:11, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
You can see in your edit that the attached content is more than that where the source was used to justify another statement Supposedly, King Chun fled to Mahan and called himself the "King of Han (韓王)" though it is not accepted by modern Korean historians (see Mahan confederacy's misconceptions). This is not in the source. The example you used is also still original research in isolation and the example of Atlantis you gave is exactly what WP:OR tells you not to do: Even with well-sourced material, if an editor uses it out of context, or to state or imply a conclusion not directly and explicitly supported by the source, that is original research; see below. Qiushufang (talk) 14:15, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
Also, the aforementioned source does allude to the edit I made as it says this: そこで今西龍は1922年 ‘箕子朝鮮伝説考’ で箕子は楽浪の韓氏が家門を輝かせるために箕子の後えいだとかこつけただけであり、朝鮮人の先祖ではないと否認した。 which in fact does coincide with the statement of due to the existence of Kija Chosŏn (first mentioned in Shiji and later in the Book of the Later Han) itself being scrutinized by Korean and Japanese historians. Asieon『✉』 14:11, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
This reply was made after mine, which I restored. Please avoid editing a comment after someone has already replied or edit over an already existing version. Qiushufang (talk) 14:29, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
That is not out of context. If you simply stated: Can you provide citation for the flight to Mahan statement. That would've sufficed. Also to keep the record straight, the source is added after "[...]is also often scrutinized" not the sentence you claim it to have been which is "[...]though it is not accepted by modern Korean historians". That is simply not true. Please check the page again.

Also, the misconception section of Mahan confederacy clearly explains it better under Shim, Jae-hoon (2002), "A New Understanding of Kija Chosŏn as a Historical Anachronism" p. 278-279. Why is it necessary to add the same source when the explanation is much better presented in an article much better suited for the topic? That criteria is not even in WP:OR. Feels very nitpicky. Asieon『✉』 14:40, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
Stop talking to each other. You're both making it vanishing likely that anyone will look at this. ScottishFinnishRadish (talk) 14:42, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
I clearly offered to resolve this privately. Qiushufang decided on their own to bring it here. Asieon『✉』 14:44, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
Regardless of the action performed by Qiushufang, I have added necessary additional sources to alleviate and accommodate to Qiushufang's criticisms. Though the user did antagonize me, personally attack me, and defamed me, I do consider their feedback worthy (as they did not leave a single comment for reverting changes this time) and provided actual insight for bettering the articles.
For some reason, Qiushufang acts hostile towards me, but I will let them know that there is no personal grudge between them and I, and in hindsight, this could've been solved if they reached out privately. Asieon『✉』 15:48, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
I want to start by saying I have not fully clicked through either editors links, and have for the moment just skimmed the comments on this thread. I reverted the page back to Qiushufang's edit due to this ANI discussion (which at least from my read, appears to be ongoing) to prevent further edit war, but Asieon says this has been resolved?
From my brief read of this, I get the feeling that Qiushufang and Asieon are still in disagreement (because Qiushufang has not given their consent if they actually agree with Asieons old and new edits), I don't think Asieon's edit summary was appropriate nor entirely accurate. Ill have to do a more through read later but I do not think it was right to say this ANI has been resolved. Sunnyediting99 (talk) 16:56, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
Having read through this a bit more, I do think its correct to say that Lee Deok-il is certainly a fringe pseudo historian pushing a Korean nationalist POV and it would be very inappropriate to cite his works after reviewing the links. If Asieon's point that other historians share this view (and it is entirelty possible for legitimate historians to share an overlapping view with a fringe historian) then only the legitimate ones should be cited and Lee's should be removed. I strongly urge Lee's work not be pushed as any credible historian would not be saying the Hwandan Gogi is a real work of history. I am very wary of citing government sources unless its absolutely needed, whether it be Korean, Chinese, Japanese, etc, just because government agendas can absolutely mess with accuracy.
Kija Chosun's existence and the issues around it are a whole other can of worms, which I think both users have legitimate points on (the Kija myth itself, like the Dangun myth, only appeared millenias after their presupposed date, and both the Kija and Dangun myth were politicized even back during Goryeo and Joseon for various Korean-Centric (Dangun) or Sinophilic (Kija) purposes), but regardless, I strongly encourage Asieon to not have new edits on the Old Chosun topics until this ANI is resolved. Sunnyediting99 (talk) 18:03, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
It is not a dispute I started anyway.
I am more than happy to replace Lee's source with a less controversial one as I said, the sentiment is shared by multiple authors and historians. Again, I am more than willing to cooperate. It is entirely up to Qiushufang who started this dispute. Asieon『✉』 18:48, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
"Again, I am more than willing to cooperate."
It's funny how I get the blame of "behavioral problem" when my initial stance was this from the very beginning.
Instead, I get personally attacked first and get blamed second, because the person kept asking for reasons, not asking for better sources. Simple as that. I don't know what to say, truly. Asieon『✉』 18:36, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Hi Asieon, I think for now a good starting point please remove all and any sources that cite Lee as they are a controversial historian. I understand you might be upset but Qiushufang provided some good faith criticisms.
I would like to lower the tension in this ANI while we wait to see what other users might suggest. Sunnyediting99 (talk) 20:15, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
I need more specification. Remove and leave it unsourced? Or must there be a replacement source? Asieon『✉』 10:48, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
Honestly for now just remove it based off Esimybro's comments about there being OR. Better to have something unsourced so that editors and viewers know theres potential issues with a sentence. Sunnyediting99 (talk) 22:47, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
Sorry, I was really busy the past few days. But I think that is a very fair suggestion. Duly noted. Asieon『✉』 08:54, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
@Sunnyediting99: What legitimate points about Kija Chosun are you referring to? It is immaterial to Asieon's use of OR and SYNTH, which is the reported issue. Since they have decided that this ANI has ended and the issue resolved (it has not), they have synthed together a frankenstein paragraph at Wiman of Old Chosŏn with multiple inline citations using a dead link, "Shim 2002" an incomplete citation copied from Mahan confederacy, an ohmynews article concerned with the historiography of Tan'gun, ujeil an unprotected site, and another article on the historiography of Tan'gun. Not in any of these sources is the basic premise of the synthed statement Supposedly, King Chun fled to Mahan and called himself the "King of Han (韓王)"[2] though it is not accepted by modern Korean historians (see Mahan confederacy's misconceptions). However, due to the existence of Kija Chosŏn (first mentioned in Shiji and later in the Book of the Later Han) itself being scrutinized by Korean and Japanese historians,[5][6] the claim (due to the nature of its connection to Kija Chosŏn)[7] is also often scrutinized,[8] as in native Korean records, no king named "Chun" is found in any of the genealogy. substantiated. I challenge @Asieon: to provide a statement from these sources which states directly something approximating "King Chun fled to Mahan but this is not accepted by modern Korean historians", otherwise this is simply WP:OR. A statement such as "Kija Choson is considered an anachronism by the mainstream academia" based on WP:RS would be much easier to substantiate is my guess. Qiushufang (talk) 19:05, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
I do believe I provided a source somewhat answered your "challenge" or assertion already?
특히 마한은 기자조선의 후예가, 진한은 진나라의 유민이 세운 것으로 기술하는 등 삼한의 주도세력을 중국계로 파악한 것은 일연의 소중화주의적 면모가 여실히 드러나는 대목이다. 또한 모든 사실을 기술할 때 그가 신봉한 중국측 기록을 주요 자료로 삼고, 국내 자료는 이를 보완 설명하는 주석으로 처리하는 정도로 이용한 것에서도 그의 소중화적 면모를 확인할 수 있다. This is just an excerpt, but the author is very critical towards Iryeon and others for believing things without scrutiny. 고려 후기의 소중화주의자들도 기자동래설을 그대로 믿었다. Which means "[people] believed [Kija Choson theory] without question." The author Lee Heegeun is said to be a historian, and unlike Lee, he seems credible.
In regards to the other sources, I do not know the content of the sources as it was present prior to my edits. I only used them because they were pointing to the same sentiment found in the other article.
Regardless, I think you have your answer. Asieon『✉』 19:25, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
The more appropriate statement based on that quotation would be "X author believes that Iryeon's claim that Mahan was founded by Gija is unsubstantiated and based on Sinocentric historiography. Gija Chosun is considered to be a historical anachronism by scholars." without mention of King Chun since it is a general statement. Qiushufang (talk) 19:33, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
I never mentioned King Chun when using that source. Again, you are getting yourself confused. Asieon『✉』 19:36, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
None of the other sources mention King Chun either. That's the point. It is WP:SYNTH and WP:OR because none of the sources mention King Chun or his flight to Mahan.
Qiushufang (talk) 19:39, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
Let me repeat myself (which I hate more than anything in the world). The point of source/edit was to indicate that the claim found in the Book of the Later Han, where it asserts that King Chun was the descendant of Kija, is not reliable. And there is no historical/archaeological evidence that substantiates the claim outside of ancient Chinese primary sources such as the Book of Han (asserted), Shiji and the Book of the Later Han. Following this, claiming that King Chun fled to Mahan as also stated by the Book of the Later Han (the same book that asserts Kija Choson) cannot be substantiated or proved.
Again, I repeat.
Kija Choson is not accepted by modern Korean academia nor Japanese academia. Only Chinese academia supports it, but it lacks archaeological evidence from native Korea. Asieon『✉』 19:48, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
I (based on numerous historians) am criticizing the claims found in the Book of the Later Han which asserts both the claims you are fixated on. The same way historians criticize Samguk yusa the entire book for being unreliable.
Just because historians don't directly mention King Chun's flee to Mahan doesn't mean it is real, because again, no native Korean records show this. Only Chinese records, specifically the Book of the Later Han posits this. Which in and of itself is highly criticized similar to the Samguk yusa. Asieon『✉』 19:52, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
Hi Qiushufang, I wanted to clarify I read Asieon (and your) comments on this ANI + a significant amount of the edits made though Asieon has made a lot of edits so its a bit hard to keep following theirs. I think Asieon's comment about scholars questioning Kija's existence "historians such as Sin Ch'aeho, Ryū Imanishi, and Naka Michiyo (with proper sources) clearly refuting Kija Chosŏn's existence" is a legitimate point I was referencing since that is something that is disputed by scholars. Now they obviously need to provide better sourcing for that too but that is something that they have some legitimate grounds on.
That said, as inferred (but not stated so I want to clarify) from my previous comments I do mostly agree with your concerns and your overall position. To any readers, Qiushufang's point on the King Chun is a good example of this. Asieon is not providing appropriate sourcing, and a lot of what they are commenting and posting is either borderline OR or is OR. I dont want to drag out this point but to anyone who reads this Qiushufang is raising some very legitimate and valid concerns on Asieon's synth + OR.
It does not help that Asieon tried to claim the dispute was over when it wasn't. Asieon, again I STRONGLY encourage you to stop arguing with Qiushufang and either find reputable, academic sources or articles published by historians that directly support your point, or to just drop the stick. Trying to edit war is not an appropriate response to Qiushufang's concerns. Sunnyediting99 (talk) 20:01, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
I did find reputable academic sources written by legitimate historians that are not controversial. Qiushufang just did not read them properly and I had to repeat myself multiple times.
I asked them to take it to my talk page, they refused. I ask them to start a discussion on the article's talk page, they refused.
I can't keep engaging with someone who is clearly deflecting every olive branch I am extending and put the blame on me for "edit wars". They flat out refuse to communicate. Asieon『✉』 20:07, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
Asieon, Qiushufang did read them properly (hence why they found you cited Lee, it would require them to read your source to know who you cited). While it probably would have been advisable for them to start on the talk page for either your own or on the article, it is their right to go to an ANI as well. They have raised serious and very legitimate concerns with what you have added onto the page.
Additionally, please do not accuse them of not reading sources properly. Unless you have direct proof this is bordering on a personal attack. Sunnyediting99 (talk) 20:23, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
I kindly request you to read the conversation above. It is not a personal attack but a direct observation that took place in regards to a source that was clearly added prior to Qiushufang's "challenge". That indicates that they did not in fact believe my words nor read the sources I provided properly. Qiushufang's opinion on Lee was made hours ago. His new "challenge" happened mere minutes ago.
I am not frustrated over their direct approach to ANI. I'm frustrated over their lack of actions AFTER they brought up the topic in ANI. And speaking of rights, I have the right to feel frustrated based on their actions too. Asieon『✉』 20:32, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
I have and still am reading through Asieon's sources, multiple times. I noticed in one of Asieon's sources that they introduced "King Chun" in parentheses in one of the translated quotations when it is not in the original language, which seems to be a minor infraction of WP:TRANSCRIPTION but just continues their trend of original research and how they WP:SYNTH together content.
I'm not sure what Asieon means by my "new challenge". The problem was stated from the beginning (King Chun is not mentioned in the source). They added new sources and content to the pages since the start of this ANI , which still have the same problem. There are ways around this to say something similar according to the sources used (example), but this fact seems to have eluded Asieon or maybe they object to it.
You've been pretty even handed, but it should be apparent that there are some WP:BATTLE and WP:IDHT issues going on . I've stopped responding to them because it's repetitive to keep saying "what you're describing about how you use sources is synth" and they've started shouting in bold. Even their responses to you have been avoidant of addressing the issue. They just don't seem to get it but I'm not sure if it's deliberate or WP:CIR. They already have a storied past, which they describe as irrelevant past drama, but past user history tends to predict current behavior. Previous tactics trying to invalidate another user's concerns one way or another and being on the other side of the argument over source validity don't suggest this is simply an inexperienced editor. After 4 years and 2,952 edits, other users should not have to haggle with them over talk discussion to provide a source for unsourced content or have to explain in minutiae why you can't just link to another page as a source. Their ability to admit issue with their sources such as Lee also seems contingent on others forcing them by virtue of numbers rather than independent analysis. I do not think I am being ungenerous in this description. Qiushufang (talk) 09:47, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Bold fonts don't indicate shouting. It's emphasis.
Second, I have tried to alleviate the situation by providing better sources, and yet I get warned not to edit further.
You can't have it both ways. You can't say that I haven't provided better sources when you won't allow me to. That's nonsensical. Asieon『✉』 11:18, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Fair point Qiushufang I think you are providing an accurate description on this, I was hoping it wouldn't have to escalate further but at the rate its going its going to happen. The IDHT appears to be the more serious issue of the two atm.
Asieon, when I say provide better sources, you can provide them here in the ANI rather than push them onto new pages. What you were previously doing was add new sources/edits onto a page as an ANI was ongoing so I had asked that you stop to prevent an edit war. Please do not confuse my comments with Qiushufang's.
Realistically, the best way to resolve this is to hopefully get more users to provide their input on this to help render a decision on Asieon's OR/CITE issues. Sunnyediting99 (talk) 15:34, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
I am moving on from this ANI. I think I've already made my point and I don't want this to turn into another Guile's Theme situation, which I'm sure you remember, where I'm just repeating myself ad infinitum. My last point is that saying roughly the same thing while sticking to reliable sources really isn't that hard. There are many ways to imply the same conclusion by just stating the source's content without having to link multiple sources together in a single sentence or paragraph, which frankly just scares readers away anyway. Having 5 different sources interspersed throughout a 3 sentence paragraph is a good way to make sure nobody takes it seriously. Qiushufang (talk) 15:55, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
I wouldn't blame you, I don't think I told you this but I thought you handled the Guile situation very well given how bad their behavior deteriorated near the end (and just how long the whole situation went on for, that was one of the longest ive ever seen on Wikipedia).
As for this ANI I hope other users can provide their input and help address Asieon's behavior. Its clear we need more input/thoughts on the issues. Sunnyediting99 (talk) 16:17, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
I checked Asieon's latest edits at Chun of Old Chosŏn, and there is rather obvious WP:OR. At the moment I'm not familiar enough with the their edits to comment on other behavior issues raised here, though. Esiymbro (talk) 08:45, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
The "unprotected site" is actually from 울산제일일보 a city-run newspaper of Ulsan.
The OhMyNews article clearly says this: 상나라가 망하자 '조선'(漢의 고을) 땅으로 들어가 살았다는 단순한 기록인데, 고려 유학자들은 기자가 우리나라 왕이었을 뿐만 아니라, 오랑캐인 우리 민족을 교화시킨 '성인'이었다고 추앙했고, 조선의 유학자들은 기자를 성현으로 만들어 '기자광풍'을 일으키면서 기자 숭배가 극에 달했으니, 참으로 어처구니없는 과거사이다. which is also highly critical of Kija.
The incomplete citation can be fixed.
You just don't seem to read the sources I provided comprehensively. Because they're all in there if you actually read them. Asieon『✉』 19:34, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
Note that besides Wiman of Old Chosŏn, much of Chun of Old Chosŏn in its current form with unsourced content are by Asieon. I realize that Wikipedia standards are low, but is it really that much to ask for a source when someone adds unsourced content? I really don't think any of this has to do with our stances on Kija Chosun, which I have not stated, edited, or even disapproved of. My basic stance here is that the academic opinion is that it did not exist, and a statement of that nature based on WP:RS is more than OK, but that is just not the issue here. Qiushufang (talk) 19:24, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
Both Qiushufang and Asieon are clearly editing in good faith, so I can't help thinking that this discussion should be held in a talk page rather than at ANi. You've both said more than enough here to make your positions clear, so please allow others to weigh in now. Phil Bridger (talk) 20:38, 13 November 2026 (UTC)

Mass rollback with dismissive edit summary

On 12 November 2026, Jay8g (talk · contribs) reverted a series of independently sourced corrections to Topical steroid withdrawal with the edit summary "roll back to last version that isn't a complete disaster."

The rollback reversed multiple distinct edits, including removal of an unsupported timing thresholds, clarification of an indirect prevalence estimate, removal of an uncited claim about recovery duration, and improvements to citations, etc.

To keep things orderly and clear, each of the changes had been made individually, with edit summaries identifying their purpose. Jay8g's blanket reversion provided no specific objections to the individual corrections or their supporting sources.

I am requesting an independent review of the wholesale reversion and the accompanying dismissive edit summary. I would also appreciate guidance on how to address the individual corrections without entering an edit war.

Revision: https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?oldid=1385323914 Corinna Kennedy (talk) 22:39, 12 November 2026 (UTC)

@Corinna Kennedy, your first step should be to communicate with Jay8g, either on the article talk page or their user talk page. Schazjmd (talk) 22:52, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
Both steps have been taken. Jay8g was notified on their user Talk page, and the matter has been raised on the article's Talk page for independent editorial review.
The ANI report concerns the conduct accompanying the wholesale reversion of individually documented, sourced corrections. Corinna Kennedy (talk) 22:55, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
Yeah, neither of those posts are what I'm suggesting. You should talk to Jay8g, ask them to explain the revert, discuss with them why you believe the edits were constructive. Admins don't mediate content disputes. Schazjmd (talk) 22:57, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
@Corinna Kennedy, look at the state in which you left the article. Then look at absolutely any other Wikipedia article on a similar topic and note the differences. You took a properly formatted article and left it a complete mess. Feel free to try again, but actually look at other articles to see how they're written and formatted. Jay8g [V•T•E] 23:21, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
Thank you, you have now twice characterized my edits as a "complete disaster" or "complete mess," yet have not identified the specific issues supporting that assessment.
The alterations were all textual edits within preexisting sections, including corrections to citations -- which were each individually documented, providing clear explanations of the changes and their supporting evidence.
The page flows the same, but you are insistent, so I ask you to be specific and not make broad, sweeping claims condemning a fellow editor's work as a 'complete disaster' and 'complete mess' when all text edits were made within preexisting sections and all related to cited works.
So that we may bring this page into alignment with cited source material, I ask, again, which provisions of the Manual of Style have my edits violated. Corinna Kennedy (talk) 00:20, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Have you gone through some other articles and looked at how they are written compared to how this one was written? That's always the most helpful thing for new users. Also, please read MOS:LEAD for starters.
For the rest of the article, I've brought back your changes, but the lead needs a lot of work. Jay8g [V•T•E] 00:41, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
@Jay8g: I fear that labelling edits as a "complete mess" is uncivil. Had you worded it in a way that doesn't strike people as rude, then this thread likely would've never existed in the first place. Beta Beta Beta - talk 00:34, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Jay8g, I have no doubt of your well intentions, however your input here still hasn't made clear how anything can be improved.
And, I sincerely want the page to represent the best it can be for the content material credibility and information accuracy generally. It was a huge mess of a page well before I began picking and my goal was to bring the material into alignment -- with no alteration to flow or construction. I had plans to spend a lot more days along the same vein I was travelling -- so your input is really valued here.
But, it's three-times now you've just vaguely waved back to look in some yonder direction which still feels incongruent because my edits all reflected cited material.
So, I ask, could you perhaps provide only 2 or 3 examples? From that, I am certain I will comprehend your meaning more clearly and be able to navigate forward in a more learned matter. (I have noted a cite name typo, that one I know but that doesn't fall under your claim.) Corinna Kennedy (talk) 00:57, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Sorry for replying to the wrong comment... I am having a much needed tub time and will close this window. Corinna Kennedy (talk) 00:58, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Here's a great place to start: Wikipedia:Good_articles/Natural_sciences#Medicine. Medical topics aren't something I know all that much about, as I said, but I'm sure there are some there that are similar to what you're looking for.
You seem to be focusing on the sourcing part of things. I can't really comment on that, but it seems like you know what you're doing there. It's formatting and, simply, making it look like a Wikipedia article that you need to work on.
I can see if I have time to sit down and work on a rewrite of the lead section you wrote at some point.
I apologize if what I said earlier didn't come across as I intended it. I can tell that you mean well too and I wasn't meaning to imply otherwise. Jay8g [V•T•E] 01:08, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
@Jay8g, I'm not a heavy contributor but I have been somewhat active with editing pages over 10 years so I did wonder if my language choices contributed to some issues in this article. In the TSW article, some edits done were to bring language inline with meaning, for instance when use of 'peeling' was replaced with the accurate 'desquamation,' per source material. The reason for the materials' use of desquamation is to represent an ongoing process which is more involved and disruptive than superficial peeling -- so scope was being lost.
TSW is a really challenging topic to write above due to the longstanding controversy around it — which leads to so much lack of clarity, and more uncertainty. That weight contributed to that lead section you note. I will take a look at some articles on that link you shared and revisit it with that in mind.
Thank you, I can only do better from good criticism so do appreciate your time. Corinna Kennedy (talk) 01:53, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
@Corinna Kennedy, you might find it useful to read MOS:LEAD as well. Schazjmd (talk) 15:48, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Yes, I see what is being called out clearly now.
I created a supportive narrative around origin to lead the reader back to solid ground — those two teaching doctors with years of first hand experience training while treating patients of the condition in an academic clinical over many years and who both settled with one position which is that primary causation was avoidable, if things are properly treated this condition should not exist as there was little need to use the medication. Thus addressing the iatrogenic nature of the condition, while the rest of the material generated around the condition presents promotion to further iatrogenesis. That explains the message contained in a lead which within the reality of the condition contains the only solid part of the entire article.
This is an iatrogenic topic regarding one of the most well known and relied on medications, it represents a classic hot potato — one that's been subject to heated debate with active management since a 2005 FDA roundtable took on the matter of creating safe OTC prescribing practice guidelines. I summarized the bulk of the report and learned they shelved things to be resumed at a later date after the roundtable learned, as they all sat with their own inputs finally hearing from other silos, how far reaching this situation was, how confounding the specialists reports were insofar as what was showing up — ultimately comprehending how little was understood regarding how exogenous override of the GR disrupts regulatory function well beyond the skin.
Guess what they did with that info. ;)
I try not impose my thoughts outside of settings, because it would undermine the point of expending energy around it -- my hope was to maintain a high level of that conscientiousness when representing existing material... but, I came with blind spots and mine showed up here.
As much as I look, I can't find anything that aligns for guidance on how to present what has so many opinions and represents such a clash of medical dogma, scope of injury and social outcry. Corinna Kennedy (talk) 20:46, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
I apologize if this is out of place, but for context I thought it helpful to highlight the unique energy around the material
This narrative captures a broad overview of the situation, written by NIH Dr Ian Myles (LCDR_IAM) it substantiates the complexity. Full disclosure my opinions are cited as well here (#101, Biomarkers).
https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/medicine/articles/10.3389/fmed.2026.1786331/full Corinna Kennedy (talk) 21:01, 13 November 2026 (UTC)

Since User:Corinna Kennedy asked to explain certain things, here are two suggestions. First, this is a medical topic so content needs to meet WP:MEDRS rely mainly on recent secondary reviews and major guidelines and give each view the weight those sources give it WP:DUE. The lead should summarise what the body says rather than build an argument towards a conclusion in the lead. Second, you mentioned that your own views are cited in the Frontiers paper you linked. It would be good to disclose that article talk page as per WP:SELFCITE. Dz5t 8O12 (talk) 07:17, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

Thank you @Dz5t 8O12. Upon recommencement, I will be sure to follow these suggestions as well. Corinna Kennedy (talk) 16:04, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

DoeDoIt's disruptive editing

The following discussion is closed. Please do not modify it. No further edits should be made to this discussion.


DoeDoIt (talk · contribs) has been edit-warring to introduce poorly sourced content at three articles: Sjaak Swart, Piet Keizer and Davy Klaassen. I explained on their Talk page why their sourcing was insufficient. They didn't respond but twice re-instated their changes.

They're a mobile user so it may be a case of WP:THEYCANTHEARYOU. That doesn't change that it's disruptive. Robby.is.on (talk) 11:06, 14 November 2026 (UTC)

Clear SPA with WP:FANCRUFT issues. GiantSnowman 11:46, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
They are still at it. Robby.is.on (talk) 18:29, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
The discussion above is closed. Please do not modify it. No further edits should be made to this discussion.

Series of weird and sometimes meaningless edits maid by temps including ~2026-59705-26

Noticed it first from ~2026-59705-26 which may be the same as ~2026-54709-48 and ~dozen or so others. Often they are very weird, like wikilinking or un-linked a basic word/phrase (diff 1) and sometimes to the wrong concept, a lot of adding/removing spaces (diff 2) in source text, very slight image size adjustments (diff 3), etc. Never any edit summaries, no responses to Talk warnings, and exclusively no actually new, readable article content. Probably WP:AIBOT Mausfield (talk) 18:27, 14 November 2026 (UTC)

Seems to be based on some LLM instructions, ex: bolding article title in lead (diff 4); alphabetical re-ordering of See Also links (diff 5, diff 6) Mausfield (talk) 18:39, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
Autonomous agents are definitely a thing in today's world. However, I don't see any reason to think what you've posted has anything to do with AI. NinjaRobotPirate (talk) 19:21, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
How about re-ordering "Christ Jesus" to "Jesus Christ" and then only wikilinking "Jesus"? I'm surprised that what looks to be very explicitly defined edit types missing context obvious to any human doesn't look in any way like LLM to you, but I don't actually need to die on that hill. Mausfield (talk) 19:50, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
Newspapers report when LLMs say and do bizarre things. However, in my experience, humans are more irrational than LLMs. An old model from several years ago suggested that people should put glue on their pizza, which is absurd. However, thousands of humans continue to believe that shapeshifting reptilians control the governments of the world. People were making strange edits like that far before ChatGPT became a thing. I'm not saying you're wrong, but I just don't see it, personally. NinjaRobotPirate (talk) 00:04, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
The glue on pizza thing was a joke from an actual human being that the model took literally. I don't know whether that makes it better or worse. Sumanuil. (talk to me) 22:40, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

Is this language okay?

Can someone please take a look at the response posts, edit summaries and images posted by Joshua Jonathan? There are concerning references towards another editor. view.A file image link of Everyone Poops with the caption: That’s a nice book! Some Freudian issues here? linking to Anal retentiveness view and an image of the Jacksons performing ABC view.Their edit summaries included:Poop! and: and now for the ABC! Swing along and have fun! and: link to the genius additions view view. Inviting others to laugh at the disputed revision saying: youre laughing? :) and later described it as: linguistic expose view view. Also his reaction to a students work calling it: sloppy, because they failed to incorporate the feedback and provide references view. As someone with learning disabilities such double down tit for tat and calling something like that as sloppy is uncalled for. Sam7412 (talk) 22:32, 14 November 2026 (UTC)

It looks like Joshua Jonathan made some snarky replies to an editor's post on Joshua Jonathan's talk page: ... It's...... perfectly readable English if you're genuinely literate. You might want to work on that before destroying other people's good-faith efforts. I recommend Grover and the Everything in the Whole Wide World Museum and Everybody Poops to start with; after that, you can move on to your ABCs. The responses don't seem outrageous to me in that context. For the second, Joshua Jonathan had provided detailed help on the student's page, but the student didn't take note of that feedback in their subsequent edit. After the comment that you call out, the student thanked Joshua Jonathan and apologized for the error. I don't see that administrator involvement is needed in either instance. Schazjmd (talk) 22:47, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
@Sam7412, I also see that you haven't notified Joshua Jonathan of this discussion. Please see the explicit instructions at the top of this page and do so. Schazjmd (talk) 22:49, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
Whoops I missed that. I’ve notified them. But snarkiness isn’t the issue. Yes the original comment was insulting and Joshua Jonathan did not ignore it. He let the other person know they had made a personal attack. But what justifies continuing in engaging in the double down behavior with comment, images and edit summaries, after already informing the other person? In the Everyone Poops image caption, he intentionally linked the words: Freudian issues to Anal retentiveness. That goes beyond returning the original joke and to me, feels like a personal insult towards another person. There was also the sarcastic edit summary: link to the genius’ additions. And then the remark: for the serious (youre laughing? :)) interested. Which appears to invite others to laugh at the exchange. Again my issue is not that he responded to an insulting comment but that he continued to ridicule even after informing the other person. Having experienced bullying in real life this exchange has been going around in my mind and I’m struggling to understand whether this kind of conduct is considered acceptable and something I should expect to encounter if I continue my editing. Could an administrator please help me make sense of this. Is this a safe space? Sam7412 (talk) 15:31, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
Is this a safe space? This is the internet. --JBL (talk) 19:44, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
Sam7412, please see WP:DEADHORSE. JimRenge (talk) 20:44, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
Alright so there are rules and principles to follow. Your link lead me to a link about civility which says: editors should always treat each other with consideration and respect. It also reads: incivility is harmful to the functioning of the project irrespective of the merits of the underlying dispute.
So how is this related issue from just a few days ago already a dead horse? Of course this is the internet, but isn’t Wikipedia a collaborative project? Having read about civility could an administrator clarify? Sam7412 (talk) 02:08, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

USNerd2025 inaccurate edit summaries, no response

USNerd2025 (talk · contribs · deleted contribs · logs · filter log · block user · block log) continues to submit edits with inaccurate edit summaries ("grammar" when adding content) despite warnings. This covers all of their edits to mainspace. They have not responded to their talk page; the first warning for this issue was posted a month ago, and they continue to perform such edits after my attempt at communication today (examples from today ). TheAlienAdventures (talk) 05:09, 15 November 2026 (UTC)

They appear to have never used a talk page. Blocked from mainspace until they respond, at which point any admin should feel free to unblock without consulting me. WP:Communication is required. Rusalkii (talk) 07:13, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
This might be moot at this point, but the editing pattern of USNerd2025 seems very similar to that of Usnerd2000 (talk · contribs), who also made numerous edits of dubious quality with inaccurate edit summaries. Usnerd2000 last edited on 20 September 2026 while USNerd2025 created their account a day later. Bissarlda (talk) 17:06, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
Even if that is the same person, there is only one account being used at a time, and the two accounts were not editing the same item in any way that could be seen as an attempt to deceive or mislead. — rsjaffe 🗣️ 18:50, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

Calling me a slur

The following discussion is closed. Please do not modify it. No further edits should be made to this discussion.


User:Bestiea192 (talk · contribs) directed an ethnic slur and personal attack at me in their edit summary on Palimbang massacre ("You stupid Filipino, you don't know anything"), while also falsely calling my sourced edits vandalism when its clear estimates should range from highest to lowest

Clear violation of WP:NPA

Its in here: https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Palimbang_massacre&diff=prev&oldid=1385793331 Samarblvd22 (talk) 06:26, 15 November 2026 (UTC)

Nirosu (talk · contribs) even said in a an edit summary this user has a history of insulting people
Its in here:
https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Moro_conflict&diff=prev&oldid=1385726838 Samarblvd22 (talk) 06:28, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
He also called me a slur over here:
https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Maluku_sectarian_conflict&diff=prev&oldid=1383587170
This is most certainly Bestiea, just look at the style he writes Samarblvd22 (talk) 06:51, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
That is a clear personal attack, and there is further evidence of a battleground attitude and a focus on character rather than content with relation to casualty figures: "Are you perhaps embarrassed that the death toll associated with your religion is so high?", "(translated by Google from Thai) Why did you abandon it? Are you ashamed of your nation's defeat?" that should also be raised in an admin action. CMD (talk) 06:40, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
Blocked for a month without prejudice to another admin extending to a longer block or other sanctions. Rusalkii (talk) 07:07, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
(Note that this is only not an indef because I don't think they have ever been warned before for conduct towards other editors and I am reluctant to indef on a first offense with no warning; insulting another editor on the basis of their ethnicity is completely unacceptable.) Rusalkii (talk) 07:10, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
should someone really need to have been warned to understand that calling someone you stupid Filipino is unacceptable? I feel like that's something we should be able to expect of our editors without having to tell them about it. ‑‑gurkubondinn (talk) 14:49, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
the loutsocking (as multiple TAs it seems) should probably also be addressed, the ~2026-58090-96 (talk · contribs) was used to call @Samarblvd22 stupid Filipino in an adit summary. ‑‑gurkubondinn (talk) 14:52, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
I have indef'd the TA, and blocked the /64 which should put a stop to some of the LOUTSOCKing. Mfield (Oi!) 19:32, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
I would say it is remarkable that someone who has been here for 6 month and 91 edits managed to get such a collection of warnings on their talk page. With the personal attacks referenced above this poses a question whether further participation of this user on the English Wikipedia is beneficial. Ymblanter (talk) 07:07, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
I understand Rusalkii's position on doing an indef without at least a warning. However, I think gurkubondinn's comment carries more weight. There's basic expectations of human conduct in any environment when you're working with other people. This should have been learned by age 5. That they got to the point of being able to edit something on the Internet without learning this very, very basic lesson of life speaks to their general character. I don't see that changing in a month of not being able to edit here. --Hammersoft (talk) 15:40, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
A month off is a pretty good punishment for the slur, but how do you get to indef? There was no discussion on the users talk page to try to solve the concerns and further educate this editor before bringing it here, as per ANI criteria. Is this concern intractable, as required by the criteria? We don't know at this point. But a month off to consider and study how language is used on Wikipedia and about fellow Wikipedians seems reasonable. Randy Kryn (talk) 15:52, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
Agree with Randy. GiantSnowman 15:58, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
Fair enough. But, (restating what I said) if a person hasn't reached this level of understanding in their lives by now, they're not going to get there in another month. We'll see if they continue. --Hammersoft (talk) 16:29, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
This is why WP:ROPE exists. GiantSnowman 16:40, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
It's ok we disagree. In this case, I feel the ROPE was their life up to this point that guided them to thinking that making deeply racist insults against others was somehow, incomprehensibly, a productive pathway forward. I have no patience for this sort of behavior. Maybe that's on me. But, if you substitute in things like the "N" word, we likely wouldn't be having this conversation. --Hammersoft (talk) 19:08, 15 November 2026 (UTC)

(Non-administrator comment) If anything, this user might have to receive a topic ban from death tolls if the conduct continues after the block expires, even without more racist insults. –LaundryPizza03 (dc̄) 11:03, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

The discussion above is closed. Please do not modify it. No further edits should be made to this discussion.

Persistent vandal Nehme1499

It’s impossible. His talk page is blocked.--~2026-60474-32 (talk) 20:08, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
Yes, I see that now. The block was not public unless someone logged off. Jako96 (talk) 20:11, 15 November 2026 (UTC)

Another SafariScribe?

I noticed the very fast (four minutes!) AfC accept of Oluwatosin Oladele by User:Reading Beans. Looking at his other AfC accepts, they usually take much longer after they are submitted.

The circumstances seem very similar to what led to Special:GoToComment/c-Sohom Datta-20260718221300-Proposal 1: Site Ban. ~2026-60454-57 (talk) 18:48, 15 November 2026 (UTC)

I do think that was a bad accept, @Reading Beans. The four sources are classic promoslop. I have moved back to draft. qcne (talk) 19:55, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
Some other brow-raising accepts;
They accepted Spree AI (a fashion tech company whose founder is Nigerian, John Imah) after it was declined for AI by another reviewer.
They accepted Semzi, about a Nigerian music producer, which I probably would've declined. It's kind of promotional, being nothing more than a record of the subject's work, and may be of dubious notability since afaik producers are not covered by WP:NMUSIC
They accepted David Akande, about a Nigerian film producer, which was declined for AI by another reviewer and was thereafter still clearly AI, see this edit summary from after the decline.
I'm sure I could find more. I wouldn't go as far as to allege UPE right now, but it does seem they might have a national interest in accepting Nigerian subjects which is impairing their judgement. Athanelar (talk) 21:57, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
Also, you needed to inform them about this thread. I have now done so. Athanelar (talk) 21:58, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
I apologize for that. I thought I did.
I suspect that if we look closely at Reading Bean's AFC acceptances of Nigerian topics (excluding obvious things like members of their Congress) we will find many questionable, potential UPE, acceptances. Here are a few deletion discussions of articles accepted by Reading Beans:
If you look at the SafariScribe discussion, Reading Beans comes very close to admitting (and at minimum supporting) a bias in favor of Nigerian subjects which is a problem even if it's not UPE. This definitely gives that impression.
Also worth considering this, he clearly was acquainted with Safari Scribe who was banned for similar behavior. ~2026-60435-79 (talk) 02:21, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
You are contradicting yourself. I am almost acquainted with all the Nigerian editors you can think of. You just haven’t dug in enough and this same pattern was raised in the last discussion.
While I understand that some acceptance I did was deleted, Nkiru Olumide-Ojo was accepted due to the discussion that happened in the first AfD which you conveniently skipped. And for others that I may have accepted, I didn’t even participate in the AfD! You can go through my declines and acceptance, let’s cross check and see!
And for the message I posted on WikiProject Nigeria, how were you able to find it? You’re not a member of the WikiProject and I’m quite sure that I NEVER mentioned this discussion in that message. I haven’t participated in AfD for some days (if not weeks) due to how overwhelming it is that no one seems to understand that I am saying and you’re saying it is UPE? Is that how you throw the words around? I don’t have a bias for Nigerian topics, I have put in a lot of work into encouraging people both offline and online to write articles about Nigeria, if you dig in deeper, you will find that out.
I was writing this reply when this text occurred to me: I suspect that if we look closely at Reading Bean's AFC acceptances of Nigerian topics (excluding obvious things like members of their Congress) we will find many questionable, potential UPE, acceptances.—emphasis are mine. This particular text shows that this report was filed by an American against a Nigerian who wants a fair representation of their people and this has now dawned on me that this particular IP has a vendetta against me and I won’t waste my precious time to reply to you—or anyone at all neither would I edit any longer. If this “tribunal” of Americans find me guilty, I’ll probably come back in a week to know your verdict. Good bye and best regards! Reading Beans, Duke of Rivia 04:16, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
In general, responding to concerns about your editing with accusations such as "but they're Americans!" is not advisable and verges on an ad hominem, especially if you can't see where the IP user is from. Most of your reply, as a matter of fact, seems to be like this (for example, "how were you able to find it?"). I recommend changing your approach immediately. Accessedgrant (Epicgenius mobile alt) (talk) 04:40, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
I forgot to turn off the notification on this. This “Congress” issue (we call it Assembly anyways), started at AfD, some group of editors (who were not Nigerians) was angry that editors were creating articles that adhered to WP:NPOL simply because it didn’t conform to what they think that a politician should be. I was honestly hoping to iron the issue out but when I found out the reason for filing this report, I wasn’t happy to be honest.
I apologize for the remark about Americans and I’m hanging my boot from accepting any article. I don’t want to waste precious community time. I hope this keeps the community safe from me. Best, Reading Beans, Duke of Rivia 05:39, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
@Accessedgrant, I have now applied for my name to be removed. Thank you all so much. Best, Reading Beans, Duke of Rivia 05:45, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
some group of editors (who were not Nigerians)
This remark in the same post where you apologize for mentioning that an editor is American somewhat blunts the force of your apology. You need to stop discussing or even mentioning the citizenship or ethnicity of other editors altogether. An editor's ethnicity has no bearing on the validity of their behavior. I'm sure you wouldn't be happy if another editor criticized your actions and part of their argument was that you are Nigerian. CodeTalker (talk) 16:53, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Hello, I’m just going to quickly drop this here. I review with WP:THREE in mind. If an article has 50% of survival, I would accept them as that’s what the policy said (unless it has been changed and I’m not aware). I review when I have the time. David Akande, Oladele and Semzi were judged by WP:CREATIVE#3 and Spree AI was judged by NCORP. I was just wondering why this wasn’t raised with me, if my answers were unsatisfactory, you could have escalated. Anyways, I reckon that this is going to be a very long thread, so, I would try as much as possible to be online against my work schedule but if I don’t, be rest assured that real life issues has tangled but I would surely reply. So, that’s that. Best, Reading Beans, Duke of Rivia 23:46, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
Oh, and to talk about the minutes, I filter Nigerian articles in the New Pages Feed, I only remove them when I start to see old articles that I can’t decide whether to accept or decline. So, most times, due to network issues, the feed is VERY LIKELY to refresh and I’ll see an article that was just submitted, and so… yeah. I sincerely don’t really know what you want from me or insinuating but I wouldn’t want to think that you want me to blocked or sanctioned anyways but if that’s where the consensus tilts to, be rest assured that I wouldn’t appeal it, it’s likely what the community wants. I don’t think I pose as a harm to this community. Best, Reading Beans, Duke of Rivia 23:51, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
@Reading Beans This is a really strange and dramatic response to this ANI thread. Your escalation to resign AfC rights is really out of proportion to potential reviewer issues in this thread? qcne (talk) 09:14, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Im sorry Qcne but I have actually been wanting to leave the English Wikipedia, I guess I just needed a catalyst and this thread seemed to have been it. Best, Reading Beans, Duke of Rivia 09:30, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
@Reading Beans Have you ever edited for pay, or accepted a draft for pay, or ever accepted a draft you have a conflict of interest with? Since you want to leave the English Wikipedia anyway you might as well be honest with us. qcne (talk) 09:35, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Darn it! I’m supposed to be retired. Well no, I haven’t written about anyone that I’m close to nor have I edited, or accepted any draft in exchange for any form of payment neither do I plan to do so in the future. I’m well aware that no one has a 100% acceptance rate but then… it is well. Best, Reading Beans, Duke of Rivia 10:15, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Support topic ban, just as I wrote last year. ~~ AirshipJungleman29 (talk) 02:06, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

Uyghur mass changes (general sanctions topic)

The Account 2 (talk · contribs · deleted contribs · logs · filter log · block user · block log) JArthur1984 (talk · contribs · deleted contribs · logs · filter log · block user · block log) Cambial yellowing (talk · contribs · deleted contribs · logs · filter log · block user · block log) guninvalid

Requesting admin action to stop the mass changes and moderate a full discussion on the matter and approval to revert the changes until the discussion is concluded.

An editor User:The Account 2 made mass changes (100+) to the name of the Uyghur camps. [General sanctions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:General_sanctions/Uyghurs] Specifically this has been changing "Internment camps" to "re-education camps". "Internment camps" was selected as the name that meets WP:NPOV. Two page names were also changed. One without discussion. One with brief discussion that the community was not properly informed of. The name issue has been long discussed and and is covered by general sanctions.

I reverted and restored the original names of the Uyghur camps per previous discussions and WP:NPOV and requested BRD or an RfC to discuss the changes. The original editor has engaged in the discussion (but this needs a full RfC again).

Another editor User:JArthur1984 is now changing the names again, and belatedly engaged in the discussion and will not self revert per BRB pending discussion.

Since this is a general sanctions subject, I have not reverted again. However BRD needs to be respected and followed to resolve the issue, and it is not.

Discussion at: Special:Permalink/1384937543#Mass changes to consensus/neutral wording on a Wikipedia:General sanctions/Uyghurs topic

I will post an RfC to discuss the changes and seek community consensus, but the changing needs to stop until the discussion is concluded.  // Timothy :: talk  22:53, 10 November 2026 (UTC)

Having made a revert on a grand total of three articles related to this issue, it's not clear what behaviour on my part Timothy thinks needs to be discussed.
I think it speaks volumes that Timothy fails to include any mention of the page move discussion that preceded TA and JArthur's edits. The move discussion was publicised at the WikiProject China, WikiProject Islam, WikiProject Human rights, WikiProject Central Asia, and WikiProject Correction and Detention Facilities and ran for just shy of six weeks. Timothy can take his proposal up at that talk page, publicising even wider if he believes that wider community input will produce an outcome that he prefers. Cambial — foliar❧ 23:02, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
This does not mean you are freed from BRD and general sanctions. A request for a full discussion and an RfC was made and not respected despite multiple requests for BRD.  // Timothy :: talk  23:06, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
BRD is one of many optional strategies that editors may use to seek consensus. [emphasis in the essay]. I don't need to be "freed from" BRD nor general sanctions to make a single revert on each of three articles, to reversions on your part that ignore MOS:LINKCLARITY and WP:COMMONNAME. Cambial — foliar❧ 23:10, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
Whereas you do no need to dial it back and take up the issue at Talk:Xinjiang re-education camps in the first instance, which is where the consensus that you evidently vehemently disagree with was reached. Cambial — foliar❧ 23:13, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
I will open a move review for the camp page.
I will open an RfC to discuss the name (again) and it will result in the NPOV choice of internment camps again.
BRD always needs to be followed. Especially on topics with sanctions. The mass changes to articles needs to stop, until this is resolved. // Timothy :: talk  23:24, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
You are incorrect. BRD is neither a policy nor a guideline, and does not "always needs to be followed". Nevertheless, making a single revert on an article does not contravene BRD. Wikipedia:Civility is the central conduct policy. You are required to adhere to it. Falsely accusing me on my talk page and here of engaging in "mass edits", on the basis of three edits, fails to do so. But again, there is nothing inherently wrong with what you describe as "mass edits", and aligning numerous pages to conform with the manual of style and common name policies can be appropriate. Cambial — foliar❧ 23:35, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
BRD is a summary of Wikipedia:Consensus: it is policy.  // Timothy :: talk  00:12, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
It is not. And repeatedly claiming it is in direct contradiction of the easily-checkable fact is a waste of everyone's time and the kind of WP:IDHT behaviour that can result in a boomerang topic ban. Cambial — foliar❧ 00:15, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
— MarkH21talk 23:59, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
See: The January 2021 requested move moved the page from Xinjiang re-education camps to Xinjiang internment camps, citing NPOV, WP:NOTADVOCACY and WP:COMMONNAME; it was closed as consensus with large community participation.  // Timothy :: talk  00:08, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
BRD is a summary of Wikipedia:Consensus, it is policy. Discussion is not optional to resolve conflicts.  // Timothy :: talk  00:13, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
There were also two move discussions before January 2021. Here, we have a move discussion in 2026 that closed with consensus, also citing policies like WP:COMMONNAME. One doesn’t pick older consensus-building discussions over newer ones, nor should one re-litigate new decisions just because there existed older ones.
Nobody said that consensus-building is optional. But WP:BRD has stated that BRD is optional for a long time:

The BOLD, revert, discuss cycle (BRD) is one of many optional strategies that editors may use to seek consensus. This process is not mandated by Wikipedia policy

— MarkH21talk 00:18, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
And just to add to Mark's quote from the BRD essay: "This page is not one of Wikipedia's policies or guidelines". Cambial — foliar❧ 00:20, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
BRD is referred to all the time as a simple synopsis of WP:CONSENSUS. This requires edits that have been reverted need to have discussion to achieve consensus. If you don't like the discussion requirement, change WP:CONSENSUS.  // Timothy :: talk  01:01, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
BRD is not "referred to all the time"[by whom?] as a synopsis of consensus. The discussion has already taken place over a period of six weeks. A consensus has already been reached. That you dislike the outcome does not permit you to start edit warring with multiple editors against the established consensus while facetiously claiming others are behaving wrongly. Cambial — foliar❧ 01:08, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
I'll start just using WP:Consensus requires discussion and consensus  // Timothy :: talk  04:20, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
Pointing out that the "brief discussion" regarding whether or not Xinjiang internment camps should be moved lasted 40 days (longer than the 2021 discussion), was relisted 3 times, and included notifications to the 5 WikiProjects most relevant to the topic (China, Islam, Human rights, Central Asia, and Correction and Detention Facilities). It is a mischaracterisation to say that the community was not properly notified or given enough time to discuss. Obviously a move discussion is going to involve more participants when the article is a hot topic.
An editor may start a move review if they believe the result does not match the policy-based arguments made in the move discussion, but it would not make sense to start a request for comment because they believe that ample time and opportunities were not given to the community to discuss the matter, which is just not the case. Yue🌙 (talk) 00:39, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
Also, what is the admin action being requested here? To unilaterally go against a move decision and force a new discussion? Why would a responding admin not just recommend following the steps to start a move review? Yue🌙 (talk) 00:51, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
A request to reopen the Move discussion has been made. I created an RFC to determine the most neutral way to refer to the camps in other articles.
Admins need to make it clear that when something is reverted and discussion is requested, the changes need to stop until a consensus is reached.  // Timothy :: talk  00:58, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
Admins have made clear just the opposite. WP:BRD is optional. Were it not, the WP:3RR would never apply because even two reverts would be against policy. While I definitely found some of @The Account 2's edits strange and baffling, they make sense in context. I found their responses on their talk page satisfactory. Not commenting on the other two reported. guninvalid (talk) 04:07, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
I'll start just using WP:Consensus requires discussion and consensus  // Timothy :: talk  04:19, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
Internment camp is probably not the most accurate term to use, as it is generally used to refer to a facility used in the confinement of "enemy citizens in wartime or of terrorism suspects." The Uyghurs are a recognized Ethnic minorities in China, and most have citizenship in my understanding. Therefore, the camps would be better characterized with the more term Concentration camp. GeogSage (⚔Chat?⚔) 00:58, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
@GeogSage, this thread is not the place to litigate this. If you'd like to start a new WP:RM, you may, though you will be WP:SNOW closed. guninvalid (talk) 03:34, 11 November 2026 (UTC)

Disruptive editing by TimothyBlue

TimothyBlue has now opened a malformed RfC asking to rename the article just 4 days after the last 40-day RM was closed against their favored title. They have also pinged 100+ editors, the scale of which is inappropriate.

This behavior has moved far into WP:IDHT and WP:FORUMSHOP territory, especially considering the responses here and on the talk pages. — MarkH21talk 04:20, 11 November 2026 (UTC)

I pinged people involved in the previous discussions. The RFC is broader than the question of what to call the article, it is what term is preferred in text. I have opened a reopen move from the closer to further discuss the name of the page. I posted here hoping admins would calm down the mass renaming until there was a consensus and moderate the discussion.  // Timothy :: talk  04:22, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
You opened this ANI thread, then ignored discussions here and elsewhere, and then included renaming the article title in your RfC (i.e. including relitigating the RM in its scope) while this thread is ongoing. This is very poor form. — MarkH21talk 04:27, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
There are discussion in two other appropriate forums - the closer talk for reopening the move discussion and the page for the RfC. I have also communicated with the person who was making the mass changes, again allowed. We are allowed to request move discussion be reopened. We are allowed to have discussions on talk pages about contentious issues. I thought we were allowed to ask admins to moderate a discussion. Your disruptive editing comment is just an attempt to silence me. It's almost working, I wish I had never started editing again.  // Timothy :: talk  04:36, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
I’m not trying to silence you, and I hope we can both assume good faith. Of course, you can open discussions, but opening multiple overlapping discussions simultaneously (user talk pages + ANI + RfC + 100+ pings) is explicitly discouraged by WP:FORUMSHOP:

Raising essentially the same issue on multiple noticeboards and talk pages, or to multiple administrators or reviewers, or any one of these repetitively, is unhelpful to finding and achieving consensus

The community just spent 40 days on an RM that the closer found had reached consensus. You have now simultaneously asked the closer to reopen that RM, opened an RfC that seeks to revisit the article title before that request has been resolved, and brought the post-RM editing dispute to ANI. Opening all these discussions in parallel with 100+ direct pings imposes a substantial burden on the community’s time and makes it harder to resolve the underlying issues in an orderly manner. — MarkH21talk 12:25, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
@MarkH21: Are you suggesting CT sanctions against TimothyBlue? While what they are doing is highly likely to be disruptive editing, I guess I'm not really sure what the proposed outcome is here. Maayaaaaa (talk) 12:37, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
I did not intentionally delete your comment, this was obviously an edit conflict. Sorry it happened.  // Timothy :: talk  04:41, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
This is an ANI which should WP:BOOMERANG for TimothyBlue's disruptive editing for making tens of edit summary-less mass reversions to patently good edits and then trying to manipulate the ANI process to achieve his desired content result by threatening to bring multiple different editors to ANI (which, as we can see, he is now done).
I am particularly bothered because when I last logged in, I was responding on my talk page with TimothyBlue (here). My last message was:
"I already engaged on the page you linked and I’ll certainly be part of an Rfc that seeks to reconsider the strong consensus on the page move. I don’t understand why you would ask me to self-revert? I fixed the damage caused by your edit summary less mass reversions to a second editor. Those edits are obviously correct from a perspective of NPOV, common name, and matching the wikilink destination. Yours didn’t even have edit summaries. What am I missing?"
I am logging in for the first time since to find that TimothyBlue launched this ANI against me and others 27 minutes after I posed the question above. JArthur1984 (talk) 13:06, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
This ANI was briefly closed after TimothyBlue posted on their talk page that they were taking a wiki break after being “crucified.”
In fact, they did not take a wiki break.
I requested that this topic be re opened. I think it’s important that TimothyBlue have consequences for their 100+ disruptive edits and forum shopping in a sanctions warning contentious topic area. JArthur1984 (talk) 20:59, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
TimothyBlue has announced they're taking another wikibreak. —ClaudineChionh (she/her · talk · email) 13:13, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
It is remarkable to me that TimothyBlue made tens of reversions without providing an edit summary, then argued with me and the other editors who fixed their damage, then opened an ANI against these users mid-discussion, and now they state that they have been the victim of "mob attacks" and are "being crucified." JArthur1984 (talk) 14:22, 11 November 2026 (UTC)

User pages

I'm about to go AFK, but I've just noticed that the permalink that Timothy left on many editor's talk pages actually points to an old version of the page where the RfC is still open. One editor has already edited the old version in error to add a !vote, thus re-opening the RfC again. It might be worth reverting the edits he made, or at least changing the link if possible. Black Kite (talk) 15:32, 11 November 2026 (UTC)

Close if you want

The following discussion is closed. Please do not modify it. No further edits should be made to this discussion.


  • If an admin wants to close this and the RfC on the subject main page they can do so and I will not protest. I no longer wish to suffer abuse from a few editors that want to shut down discussion. But someone else will come along and because there are obviously people that want to have a discussion about this. Hopefully an admin will realize that this is a legitimate discussion that needs guidance and try and moderate the discussion. But I surrender.  // Timothy :: talk  04:56, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
    A move discussion didn't go your way, you decided to edit against that consensus and start a superfluous RFC then dragged editors to ANI to try and get them sanctioned for enforcing the consensus of the move discussion. Now you want it to be closed claiming you are being abused.
    This all just seems like a woe is me attempt to avoid sanctions for disruptive editing in a topic under GS. Traumnovelle (talk) 06:26, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
    @Traumnovelle: As for sanctions, bring them on if you want: propose them right here, try to ban me, whatever you like. Everything I’ve done is still here and on the main page discussion. I gave up because it was a losing battle, not to avoid sanctions. And yes, general sanctions apply here and I am aware of them. So go ahead and try.
    Admins will see that I’ve done nothing wrong in trying to start discussions and get help moderating them and that I backed off once I realized it was a losing battle, rather than driving it into the ground and wasting everyone’s time, which is exactly what you’re supposed to do. So I’m not worried.
    You, however, are making a childish attempt to provoke me (successfully) and drag out a disagreement in the hope that I’ll do something sanctionable but its not going to work. If anything is sanctionable its provoking more disagreement when the other side has stopped - something you are doing - this is disruptive editing.
    And I was not aware of a move discussion, so I am not crying after the fact. I only became aware of it when the mass changes started. And the ANI discussion came before the RfC, so get your facts straight before you write up what I should be sanctioned for or back off and let it drop as I am doing.  // Timothy :: talk  07:14, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
    @TimothyBlue, please don't make comments like so get your facts straight at ANI. This isn't about winning an argument. Please stop WP:BATTLEGROUNDing for your own sake. Sometimes consensus goes against you, and that is okay. We all just want to improve Wikipedia. guninvalid (talk) 07:52, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
The discussion above is closed. Please do not modify it. No further edits should be made to this discussion.

Purportedly malformed RfC at Talk:Xinjiang re-education camps#RfC: Describing the Xinjiang camps

The following discussion is closed. Please do not modify it. No further edits should be made to this discussion.


I have requested the RfC be procedurally closed at WP:CR. To be honest, I'm not even sure how I was dragged into this mess or why I got pinged about the RfC. But it seems to me that if TimothyBlue wants to take a second bite at the apple regarding the choice of of re-education camp/internment camp/concentration camp, the proper venue would be WP:MR. Opening a brand new RfC to debate what is substantively the same topic as the requested move seems rather disruptive to me, especially when there's already a path for those unhappy with the outcome. Besides, this seems like a WP:SPADE/WP:DUCK situation. If the article is Xinjiang re-education camps, then we should be calling it that in the body.

@TimothyBlue: I think the obvious question here is: why couldn't you have just discussed this on the talk page first? This would have saved everyone a lot of time and frustration, it seems. RfCs are generally for issues where talk page discussions fail to yield a consensus, as opposed to a tool of first resort. Maayaaaaa (talk) 10:56, 11 November 2026 (UTC)

The discussion above is closed. Please do not modify it. No further edits should be made to this discussion.

Reopened

I was asked to reopen as TimothyBlue has returned to editing and I have done so. I have not looked further into the issues. Star Mississippi 20:12, 15 November 2026 (UTC)

I think a GS warning/reminder (or GS topic restriction) for disruptive editing would probably be appropriate here. I'm having my doubts that Timothy can edit collaboratively in this area without losing his cool. But, at the same time, I don't think it's necessary to WP:BRICKS or dogpile the poor guy. Maayaaaaa (talk) 21:13, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
Yeah Timothy has made a bunch of valuable content edits but their recent actions and user page comments weren't a good look. I also find them making mass edits regarding the "index", and "outline" articles that I doubt have consensus. (t · c) buIdhe 21:18, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
I guess probably a GS topic restriction would be appropriate here, since their responses at ANI and on user pages don't inspire much confidence that they can edit collaboratively in WP:GS/UYGHUR. While I do understand that this topic can be emotional for some people, at the same time Wikipedia not the place to WP:RGW. Maayaaaaa (talk) 21:34, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
I think it's important for TimothyBlue to be actual consequences given the scope of their damage, time other users had to spend fixing it on 100+ pages, simultaneous forum shopping, and also the attempted misuse of ANI. The flipside of being a user who has previously made valuable edits is of course that such a person should know better than to engage in this kind of large scale disruption. So I would urge that the result not be a mere warning. I am not experienced in ANI discussions so I defer to the weight of experience. My reaction is that a topic restriction suffices and is a good targeted consequence. JArthur1984 (talk) 22:09, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
Looking at past cases, other editors have been indeffed from WP:GS/UYGHUR for similarly disruptive conduct, so I think this would be an appropriate sanction here Maayaaaaa (talk) 22:22, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
Of course, if banned, Timothy would be free to appeal it later on Maayaaaaa (talk) 22:28, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
For example @Tankpiggy18: was topic banned from this area for a single disruptive edit. So, editors have been tbanned for far less than Timothy's behavior. Maayaaaaa (talk) 22:38, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
@Buidhe: What indexes or outlines are you talking about? If they are ones I wrote it may be that I was finishing them.  // Timothy :: talk  23:48, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
@Buidhe: I went back and searched my contributions, Going back a year, I don't see any mass changes except when I had just published an Outline and I was finishing it up, I wasn't changing anything. Can you let me know what Outlines you are talking about so I can look.  // Timothy :: talk  00:11, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Just yesterday you made several edits like this. looking at your past contribs, in other cases you have linked your creations into a 100+ articles at once, which could certainly be considered spam, especially when your creations aren't adding anything to navigation that categorization doesn't already cover better. (t · c) buIdhe 00:28, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
"especially when your creations aren't adding anything to navigation that categorization doesn't already cover better." - ouch but I think some would disagree. We are encouraged to link our articles, and I search cat trees to find articles that outlines and timelines of a subject would benefit.  // Timothy :: talk  00:45, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
I'm doubtful many editors would agree that means you should be adding 100+ links to your creations and it's concerning you think it does. Nil Einne (talk) 05:32, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

Proposed TBAN for disruptive editing and WP:BATTLEGROUND behavior

Here is a proposed tban:

TimothyBlue (talk · contribs) is indefinitely topic banned from the subject area of the Persecution of Uyghurs in China, broadly construed

Feel free to support, oppose, or suggest changes. Of course, indefinite does not mean permanent. And even if they have cooled down for now, that doesn't necessarily prevent further disruption in the future. Maayaaaaa (talk) 23:04, 15 November 2026 (UTC)

I support this result as necessary and it is nicely tailored to the specific harm caused. JArthur1984 (talk) 23:13, 15 November 2026 (UTC)

I have given up editing for a while.

  • I had a few edits I had ready to make and I made them and I saw the Yezidis name change and and made it in the index.
  • Since I work in VS Code mainly, I had some bibliographies in some state of completion that I wanted to add to my user space and draft them so someone could finish them in case I can't return.
  • I am definitely not returning to the Uyghurs. Bans and blocks are not punitive, and there is no prevenative value in banning or blocking me as I have retreated on this issue, acknoledged that the consensus is against my position, and do not plan to bring it up again.
  • Since I have clearly retreated on this area, this seems like reopening an issue just to kick me when I'm down.

I obviously would prefer not to be punished. We all have bad days and I've learned my lesson.  // Timothy :: talk  23:25, 15 November 2026 (UTC)

These things are not punishments, the objective of topic ban is to prevent future disruption. So far, your conduct in this topic area has not really shown that you would be able to edit collaboratively in the future. And, editors have been topic banned from this area for far less disruptive conduct. Maayaaaaa (talk) 23:29, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
I've been editing in this area for 7 years. I'm not a problem, I just had a bad day. One bad day vs 7yrs of editing I think some mercy is worth considering. Given my 7yr history, I'm not going to repeat this, so a ban or block would be punitive, and not prevent future disruption  // Timothy :: talk  23:40, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
To be clear, if you were a new user or temporary account, you probably would have been reported to AIV and blocked for edit warring for doing so many mass reversions on articles. Maayaaaaa (talk) 23:50, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
It is difficult to credit the statement this user's statement that they have learned their lesson, given that they (1) did not fix their disruptive edits, at least three other users had to go back and fix them on 100+ pages, and (2) this user stated on their page, referring to this ANI, that they had been "crucified" and were the victim of "mob attacks." JArthur1984 (talk) 23:38, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
I thought going back for any reason, would not be met positively, and I was not asked to fix anything. If it had been suggested and encouraged I would have done so.  // Timothy :: talk  23:45, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
Right, and the fact that it immediately turns to this seems like reopening an issue just to kick me when I'm down when we're clearly all just trying to build an encyclopedia suggests a general lack of WP:AGF. I don't have a grudge against Timothy, but at the end of the day, what they did is disruptive editing followed by WP:BATTLEGROUND behavior when asked to stop, and a topic ban seems like an appropriate remedy. Maayaaaaa (talk) 00:00, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Overall, the main question here is: if Timothy changes his mind and decides to edit in the Uyghur topic area again, would they be reasonably likely to do so constructively and collaboratively? And right now, just based on your history, the answer seems like a no. People do have bad days, so I'm sympathetic to this reasoning, but at the same time bad days can happen in the future as well. Maayaaaaa (talk) 00:11, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
My history? I've been editing this area and Wikipedia in general for 7 years without a ban or block, and then had one bad day. 41,000+ edits, 200+ articles created, 3000+ votes at Afd, lots of time helping with new page reviews, lots of time helping and encouraging other editors. And one bad day. I have clearly accepted consensus and moved on. That is my history if its to be considered. If I am blocked or banned, it would be punitive, not preventative. WP:BEFOREBLOCK "In general, administrators should ensure that users who are acting in good faith are aware of policies and are given reasonable opportunity to adjust their behavior before blocking"  // Timothy :: talk  01:13, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
WP:GS/UYGHUR is a contentious topic for a reason. It's certainly possible to be able to make constructive contributions in other areas, but have difficulty with specific CTs. Wikipedia has millions of articles, and there's plenty of other things to edit. Nobody is suggesting that you should be sitebanned or siteblocked. Nor is anyone suggesting that you should be punished. Maayaaaaa (talk) 01:31, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
And also, Timothy, Uyghurs are one of the less contentious CTs on Wikipedia. It's likely that if you had tried this sort of mass reversions on WP:ARBPIA, you would have been swiftly taken to WP:AE, tempblocked, and topic banned. These CTs require extra care and caution. Maayaaaaa (talk) 01:45, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
I am an uninvolved administrator and I was quite disturbed by Timothy's dogmatic attitude and somewhat disruptive behavior as shown earlier in this discussion. But he has since made it clear that he had a bad day, understands his error, and won't repeat the behavior. So, I recommend closing this with a warning to Timothy to stay on the straight and narrow. Cullen328 (talk) 02:56, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
How do you square the idea that this user understands his error with the user’s statement that he was being “crucified” and the victim of “mob attacks” via this ANI? JArthur1984 (talk) 03:48, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Technically that's part of the bad day I think, since AFAIK all of that happened when they had their problems which lead to this. I'm not going to investigate much more so I'm unlikely to !Vote so this will be brief. But I am concerned TimothyBlue seems to be downplaying the problems with their editing. Even putting aside what happened on that day, I'd note that while they posted a lot of time above "I'll start just using WP:Consensus requires discussion and consensus" on their bad day, which was neither helpful not really an accurate description of how consensus works, they haven't anywhere above acknowledged their mistake or withdrawn it other than to say generally that they had a bad day. When people are questioning them on adding 100 links, I find their defence questionable. My biggest concern though is that we know this isn't the first time this has happened. As they said in their message saying they planned to take a break which they didn't follow through with, they were on break before and their last major break also ended up with them leaving a similar message . They did similar the previous time to Plenty of us including me have when stressed and deciding to take a break said stuff we probably shouldn't have, but it is concerning if it keeps happening in such short order. While they never named any editors any of those 3 times, still it's not hard to guess some of the editors they were referring to in their recent message and I'm sure it was not last two times either. I'd also note despite having changed their mind this time, it doesn't seem TimothyBlue was one of those who asked for it to be re-opened despite I'm guessing them knowing it had been closed because or their decision to take a break. Again I'm not going to investigate more, but what happened on the bad day combined with what's happening now and the previous times makes it seem a lot more like that this isn't just a case of one bad day but unfortunately TimothyBlue has problems dealing with conflict and disagreement maybe especially when consensus is against them but they feel strongly over the issue and/or when they are the main contributor to an article. Which is a problem on a collaborative work. Whether this TBAN actually helps with the issue, I have no idea. Nil Einne (talk) 05:49, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Thanks for pointing out that they've had issues in the past. To be honest, I was too lazy to look through their contribs, so I kind of just took their word for it when they said it was a first-time incident. Also, TimothyBlue hasn't said what contributions to plan to make to WP:GS/UYGHUR in the future, if any, and editors can always change their mind. That said, their highly defensive attitude towards the ANI suggests (for example, claiming that the proposed topic ban is just an attempt to beat him while he is down) that their battleground behavior is not really a one-off incident, and their core attitudes remain the same. For these reasons, a topic ban is still probably likely to be effective at preventing disruption to the WP:GS/UYGHUR topic area, in case Timothy changes his mind and decides he wants to edit in this area in the future Maayaaaaa (talk) 08:02, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Additionally, Timothy is still using words like "I surrender" referring to the ANI, and those are the types of words you use when you have a battleground attitude towards Wikipedia. Maayaaaaa (talk) 08:04, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
  • "But I am concerned TimothyBlue seems to be downplaying the problems with their editing." I've stopped, I've acknowledged consensus was against me (which means I am wrong), I've said I was having a bad day (which means I was not doing things correctly), and said I'm taking a break (which means I know I need time off).
  • "people are questioning them on adding 100 links" This just is not true. Some of my articles have over 100 links, but I do not go mass linking the pages I create.
  • "Which is a problem on a collaborative work." Two problems in seven years with 41,000+ edits I think shows I can work collaboratively, but I am human and have bad days. Two problems and both times I stopped, acknowledged consensus was against me and let go of the issue. The last time was very brief and did not come to ANI and the only reason its remembered is I posted that I needed to take a break. This is the only time I have been taken to ANI for a problem, never been blocked or banned.
  • I did not intend metaphors such as "I surrender" to be taken as battle grounding. I should have just said I will stop or I have stopped.
  • "just an attempt to beat him while he is down" I've acknowledged the problem I created, acknowledged that consensus was against me and stopped, but people are still piling on, so it does feel like a beat down.
  • "As they said in their message saying they planned to take a break which they didn't follow through with" I was copying the work I had done into my sandbox. while I was doing this a name change happened to Yezidis and I made the change to the articles and links I had used this in. If I had known this was going to reopen this I would not done any of this. Coming back here was the LAST thing I wanted to happen.
Yesterday, this was closed. I was grateful it was closed. I copied some material into my sandbox and this was misunderstood that as me not going on a break (my fault). I ask that this be reclosed because it was reopened due to a misunderstanding about my intention to take a break. All I did was <10 edits to my sandbox and fixed the name I had used when an article was renamed. I will take my break. I was never my intention not to take a break.
WP:BEFOREBLOCK states editors should be given reasonable opportunity to adjust their behavior before blocking. I've stopped, I've acknowledged consensus, I said I will not continue. Blocks and bans are preventative, not punitive.
I'm asking for grace in this matter.  // Timothy :: talk  12:40, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
You're not correct when you say "All I did was make <10 edits to your sandbox." You edited 18 articles, in addition to whatever sandbox work you were doing.
We should keep this open until you receive whatever consequence is ultimately appropriate. It was improvidently closed after you posted a message saying you were taking a break after being "crucified" and the victim of "mob attacks." Just three days later, you resumed editing.
A skeptic could interpret your request to "re-close" because you're really taking a "break" this time as an attempt to manipulate the outcome. Especially coupled here with your incorrect statement that you only edited your sandbox, when in fact you edited 18 articles. JArthur1984 (talk) 12:51, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
I literally just finished typing this and was reading it through and corrected my mistake. You must have been waiting for a response from me because you noticed it almost before I did. I'm exhausted and its hard to type of long response to someone when your exhausted. Here is the diff I found out about the name change Special:Permalink/1383979718#Requested move 29 October 2026. I don't remember how or where I saw it while I was working in my sandbox.  // Timothy :: talk  13:03, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
I do understand the frustration that your behavior is being put under a microscope. However, coming to ANI requires clean hands, indeed because reviewing and participating in ANI threads opened requires significant attention from other editors. ANI can WP:BOOMERANG, and that's something to expect when you open a case. Maayaaaaa (talk) 13:19, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

I'm confused what you fixed or what you're acknowledging so my response is mostly based on your earlier post. You said you were going on a break here . A little over 2 days later you created this in your userspace and as it's just a list of the articles you created (or similar), I'd say it's fine. You then proceeded to make 4 edits to articles . These are 4 edits adding a "see also" to an article you created. As noted above, adding links to articles you created can be controversial e.g. when you do it too much or when the links is see as too irrelevant.

Regardless, since it's in mainspace it's not something you would be doing if you were truly on a break especially not a break which resulted in the closure of this discussion. It doesn't matter if no one had raised problems with your links at the time, nor if it's not in the problem topic area. It's possible someone would have discussed these problems if the discussion had continued & it was shut down because you said you were going on a break, rather than you saying would withdraw from the topic area or whatever. You then made a bunch of edits to your sandbox which don't seem be in any way problematic so again I'd say it's fine.

A day later you started to make edits to mainspace again. The first group I'll talk about more later. You continued with more mainspace edits, mostly I think adding links to articles you created e.g. . One of this edits was changing your break message to suggest you were going to continue to publish articles, so even you seemed to acknowledge you no longer planned to go on a break. The first request to reopen this thread seems to be which was well after all this, in fact well after your last edit to mainspace . To be clear, AFAICT, most of the edits were you adding a new link to the page. The page might have been moved by you, but mostly you were not fixing any existing links, you were adding new links.

As for the page move, while it might have been uncontroversial, it's also not consistent with a break. Editors are likely to question any break which resulted in the end of discussion if you do anything outside of uncontroversial stuff on your own userspace and maybe edits that are BANEX territory. (While you are not banned, if your break is to be treated as no need to discuss because you are no longer editing, it's the only type of editing which fits.)

Note the while it is normally uncontroversial to rename articles for consistency after a move, sometimes it is controversial. So it's also simply not a good idea to be doing this when you are on a break. If someone did query anything you did or you made a mistake, how could they talk to you if you were on a break? Regardless it's irrelevant anyway when you also added a bunch of new links.

So it doesn't look to me like editors misunderstood your "All I did was <10 edits to my sandbox and fixed the name I had used when an article was renamed". Instead it looks like you barely went on a break & then changed your mind. You even acknowledged this by changing your break message. I think most of us would be fine with accepting you went on a break and changed your mind. The problem is you are now blaming editors for misunderstanding what you did instead of accepting you had changed your mind about your break for a while.

This will probably be my last message here but it affirms by belief it wasn't just a bad day since the problems continue and I'm not convinced it's just the topic area since few or none of these seem to be in the topic area. I acknowledge it hasn't been that long and you must still be under a lot of stress, but you're still responsible for your actions. It would have been better to go on a real break for several days which to be clear would not include mainspace edits whatever the reason except maybe BANEX type edits. And then come back when you were hopefully less stressed and respond then. Or if you found you were still under stress several days longer, just kept with your break plans. I'm confident that this discussion would not be happening if you did take your original planned break.

Also, while we give editors the chance to respond and you have gone on long breaks before, it's perfectly normal editors might decide to just continue this discussion rather than wait and see if you do go on a break this time especially since they might feel if you ever do come back there's already enough it will be better to set limits on your editing with the hope they guide your behaviour to reduce problems when you do come back. There is no reason to think you're going to change if you've had persistent problems and editors have asked you to change before and you did not do so, no matter how long a break you take especially since you've already gone on several long breaks.

P.S. When it was claimed above "other cases you have linked your creations into a 100+ articles at once". Your response was to suggest it was not a problem rather than that it never happened. If you're saying it never happened, you should have asked for evidence above since that's a far better response than just saying it's okay. Otherwise it's reasonable for me to take it as something that did happen.

P.P.S. No I wasn't waiting for anything from you.

Nil Einne (talk) 14:04, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

  • Oppose. I think the objections by Timothy to rename the page were well founded. Yes, these camps do appear as "re-education", but usually in scare quotes ("...") as in the publications by Amnesty International or The Guardian . This is a sarcasm, a joke because they have nothing to do with education or re-education. If you look at United Nations publications (e.g. ), they also say "so-called Vocational Educational and Training Centres (VETCs), or re-education camps.". "So called". This is a Chinese propaganda terminology. My very best wishes (talk) 02:50, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
    This is a user conduct discussion. We already have a move review of the move open at Wikipedia:Move review/Log/2026 November, if you want to chime in about the objections. Maayaaaaa (talk) 02:56, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
My occasional interactions with Timothy were very positive. I agree with Timothy the series of edits by Account 2 was problematic. For example, just removing any info about Ilham Tohti from the page was wrong since he is a prominent activist for the cause. But I also think that Timothy made an error of judgement by starting the ANI discussion here. The mass changes on the page did happen, but he had to discuss specific disagreements on the article talk page. I do not see it. This is a typical content dispute, I think, and it should be treated as such, i.e. without involving ANI. My very best wishes (talk) 21:20, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

Alternative

As an alternative, if a topic ban is too far:

TimothyBlue (talk · contribs) is warned for his disruptive editing and battleground conduct in the subject area of the Persecution of Uyghurs in China

Per Cullen328's suggestion. This would probably also be a WP:GS/UYGHUR action, given that it's a CT. Maayaaaaa (talk) 03:02, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

I can support either a warning or a narrower tban from opening, closing, or challenging formal consensus-making discussions (such as rfc, rm, etc.). Neutral on a broader than at the moment. (t · c) buIdhe 05:19, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

TPA

The following discussion is closed. Please do not modify it. No further edits should be made to this discussion.


User talk:Content that violates any copyrights will be deleted. Encyclopedic content must be ve (talk · contribs · deleted contribs · logs · filter log · block user · block log)

Hi please yoink this user's TPA, thanks!! -- Wesoree (talk·contribs) 06:52, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

Done. Staraction (talk · contribs) 06:55, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
The discussion above is closed. Please do not modify it. No further edits should be made to this discussion.

Bloodofox actively going against what the cited sources on the article says

User:Bloodofox has been actively edit-warring on the Champ (folklore) page, as to the usage of the term cryptid, which is supported by multiple sources cited in the body of the article, including Skeptical Inquirer. I suggest that he be barred from editing this article. The sources cited in the body of the article include the skeptical inquirer, which refers to Champ as a creature of interest to cryptozoologists. — Preceding unsigned comment added by UFTI IBN GUFTI (talk • contribs) 09:06, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

First, you might have pinged me to notify me you posted here. Second, this user has a history of adding WP:PROFRINGE material to articles, namely material promoting the pseudoscience of cryptozoology on folklore studies topics rather than the works of folklorists. The situation is akin to allowing Flat Earthers run rampant on our geology articles. Unfortunately, there are far fewer folklorists on Wikipedia than there are geologists, and so we constantly see the injection of pro-pseudoscientific material in these spaces day in and day out. Note also that this user jumps between two accounts to promote this material: UFTI IBN GUFTI (talk · contribs) and Godzillasizedemu (talk · contribs). I've attempted to communicate with this user on both accounts to little avail. :bloodofox: (talk) 09:10, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
I'm not a cryptozoologist. I just think that you're massively overzealous with how you remove the cryptid category, even when I pointed out that the skeptical inquirer refers to it with a similar term, you refused to listen to me. UFTI IBN GUFTI (talk) 09:11, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
As I said on the talk page of either one or both of your (at least) two accounts, pseudoscientific topics require strong reliable sources, and in this case we're dealing with folklore topics that require discussion from experts: folklorists. Media sources have a long history of echoing and promoting pseudoscientific claims, which we have a section on at cryptozoology. The "list of cryptids" you want at West Virginia folklore is a good example of pseudoscience creeping into what should be an objective, expert source-filled article. This is actively harming these articles and turning them into WP:PROFRINGE venues. :bloodofox: (talk) 09:15, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
You claimed that the skeptical inquirer was a "pro-fringe" source. I am saying it's not, and that as they refer to Champ as "of interest to cryptozoologists", that we should categorise it as a cryptid. UFTI IBN GUFTI (talk) 09:18, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
The word cryptid is not used by scholars to describe monsters and other beings from folklore. They don't see mothman as a "hidden animal". Skeptical Inquirer is a media entity that seeks to "debunk" this or that, not produce scholarship on folklore topics. For folklore topics, cite a folklorist—a scholar that specializes in folklore studies. :bloodofox: (talk) 09:22, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
I will concede mothman yes, even though he is popularly known as a cryptid, but Champ fits the bill of a hidden animal, that is all beside the point, skeptical inquirer is the source that is cited, and refers to Champ as a creature of interest to cryptozoologists. UFTI IBN GUFTI (talk) 09:24, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
A telltale sign of a low quality or fringe sources on American folklore topics, the word cryptid is a pseudoscientific word that means 'hidden animal'. It was invented by cryptozoologists to sound more scientific, along with all sorts of pseudo-taxonomies and other pseudoscientific stuff. Our cryptozoology article provides detailed discussion on this. Folklorists don't use cryptid because it's pseudoscientific and it promotes fringe approaches to pretty run-of-the-mill American folklore. These articles get worse every time the pseudoscience creeps in. :bloodofox: (talk) 09:31, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
I'm not citing a fringe source, I'm citing Skeptical Inquirer. For example, our Bigfoot article is in the category of cryptid, so is our yeti article, and the loch ness monster article. If the sources call it a cryptid, that's what we're calling it, and lo and behold the sources say exactly that. UFTI IBN GUFTI (talk) 09:34, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
They're in these categories because users like yourself put them there. Cryptozoology considers every monster in history to be a "cryptid" and cryptozoologists have historically sought to turn Wikipedia into a platform to promote the pseudoscience, just like every other pseudoscience subculture under the sun. Wikipedia defers to WP:RS for folklore topics, just as it does for geology topics or biology topics. :bloodofox: (talk) 09:37, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Outside of this specific situation, I'm unclear what you're arguing. Are you arguing nothing should be in the cryptid categories, then? WP:SKEPTICALINQUIRER is an RS. PARAKANYAA (talk) 15:21, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
There is no firm definition for what a "cryptid" is and utilization of the term, coined by a pseudoscientific subculture hostile to scientific approaches, really requires scare quotes, containment, and careful sourcing. It can be any claim of a monster, alien, dinosaur, demon, or even character from a fictional series that is of interest to a cryptozoologist. Because cryptozoology is a pseudoscience, there is no methodology. We need to be careful to ensure that folklore topics receive attention from folklorists and that these articles don't become cryptozoology-ified where they become a list of "sightings" followed by sections on "skeptics". We need discussion from experts. These articles need to be more closely watched. :bloodofox: (talk) 00:34, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
There is no firm definition for what a "cryptid" is there's no firm definition of a lot of terms that sources describe, and that isn't required for us to use a label, but rather its presence in reliable sources. For something more in my topic area (religious studies), what about the New Age? We describe plenty of things as New Age when the only thing scholars agree about the New Age is that no one knows what the new age is - because reliable sources describe them as such. The New Age also involves plenty of pseudoscience, but the category is frequently referred to in reliable sources. This seems like a rehash of the many discussions at list of cryptids, e.g. Talk:List of cryptids/Archive 4#Merge proposal with lists of legendary creatures. Used cautiously and contextualized, sure, but the "never use it" approach seems out of step. PARAKANYAA (talk) 14:52, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
In addition and agreement with PARAKANYAA, Folklorists have in fact proposed useful definitions: Dendle (2006) "Cryptozoology in the Medieval and Modern Worlds" in Folklore puts forward a definition based on "subjective response, rather than on characteristics of the species themselves", as "unexpected in time or place or in size or shape" or as having "at least one trait 'truly singular, unexpected, paradoxical, striking, emotionally upsetting, and thus capable of mythification'. For our purposes, however we know it when we see it begin called such in RSes. Feoffer2 (talk) 15:59, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
The word cryptid is not used by scholars to describe monsters and other beings from folklore... Folklorists don't use cryptid Without weighing in on potential behavior issues by anyone, this is factually incorrect. Professor David J. Puglia, for example, introduces Mothman as "the notorious American cryptid". Feoffer2 (talk) 15:30, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Paglia's introduction to the piece drops the word because the article that follows it features a study of cryptozoologists who apply the term to the monster. Note that the book is called North American Monsters, not the pseudoscientific North American Cryptids. Cryptid is by no means a technical term used in folklore studies when studying folklore monsters unless cryptozoologists are being studied, and so their concept of a "cryptid". The word and its origins are well studied as outright pseudoscience (see cryptozoology). :bloodofox: (talk) 00:40, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Usage in a work's title is not a standard mentioned in WP:RS, however even that standard can be met: Puglia, David J. (2023). "The (Mostly) Unseen World of Cryptids: Legendary Monsters in North America". Humanities. 13 (1). Feoffer2 (talk) 15:05, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
This edit war is especially silly because it is already categorized as a cryptid. It is in Category:Lake monsters which is a subcategory of Category:Aquatic cryptids. MrOllie (talk) 14:10, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
(Non-administrator comment) Looking at the contributions of the user and the page history, I think you meant to link to Champ (folklore) and not Champ ~2026-54957-04 (talk) 09:11, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Whoops, will fix that, thanks for noticing. UFTI IBN GUFTI (talk) 09:12, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Both parties are over 3RR here and need to immediately cease edit warring on the article. CMD (talk) 09:50, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
The editor who posted this is utilizing at least two accounts. I've opened threads on both of those accounts' talk pages. I would hardly be surprised if the user was utilizing more. :bloodofox: (talk) 11:28, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
I've got two accounts, one on my tablet and one on my computer. UFTI IBN GUFTI (talk) 22:07, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
That's irrelevant as a content disputes should be discussed on an articles talk page. Experienced editors should know that. If there's no discussion on an article talk page and an edit war over a content dispute that's very bad look for all involved. While edit warring is never justified, the fact there's an edit war an no discussion is unacceptable. And to be clear once again, we don't give a flying flip about discussions on editor talk pages. IMO in cases like this blocks should be much more readily handed out, and community bans (site or topic) actively considered if admins are not willing to do that. If editors are unwilling to discuss their disputes, they don't belong here. And to be clear, while Ufti Ibn Gufti is newer here, they've been here long enough that they should know this too so yes this is entirely on them too. The fact that they are or were using two accounts in the same dispute in the same article is even more reason why it was particularly daft of them (or anyone) to think discussions on user talk pages in any way useful for anything. Nil Einne (talk) 14:48, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

Further edit-warring against Cryptid

Sadly, may have a behavior problem here. I was uninvolved in the above dispute, finding my way here after a deletion by Bloodofox at Indrid Cold. Sadly, their pattern of edit-warring has continued even after the above discussions.

  • Above, Bloodofox argues in part "The word cryptid is not used by scholars to describe monsters and other beings from folklore...For folklore topics, cite a folklorist—a scholar that specializes in folklore studies. "
  • I replied, noting that claim is factually untrue and linking to a folklore professor introducing Mothman as "the notorious American cryptid"
  • Bloodofox dismisses the source, saying in part "Note that the book is called North American Monsters, not the pseudoscientific North American Cryptids"

Their view continues to be expressed by editwarring:

  • Meanwhile, Bloodofox initially removed "cryptid" from Indrid Cold with summary "looks like some editorializing is happening here (like injecting the pseudoscientific word "cryptid" into a 1975 source)."
  • I started a talk discussion explaining "scholars of folklore study the Cold legend as an instance of a cryptid" and restored 'cryptid', now adding explicit sourcing: one from popular media and one from a folklore studies archive (USC Digital Folklore Archives)'s page on cryptid folklore.
  • Bloodofox again removes 'cryptid', with summary reiterating their position that "Folklorists, scholars who study folklore, do not use the pseudo scientific term 'cryptid'"

Above, Admin CMD warned Bloodofox (and UFTI IBN GUFTI) they'd exceeded 3RR, so I was surprised to see Bloodofox again re-remove cryptid before forming a consensus to do so. I note this basic pattern extends across many articles, with Bloodofox making similar removals from Bigfoot, Mothman , Tuttle Bottoms Monster, Lake Van Monster , West Virginia Folklore, Minhocão (legendary creature) , Bunyip ,Vegetable man (cryptid), and of course Champ (folklore) .

To echo PARAKANYAA's concerns, Bloodofox seems to be "arguing nothing should be in the cryptid categories". The removals from Bigfoot and Mothman are particularly egregious, as these are exemplars of the term.

Bloodofox was also the subject of an ANI thread last year arguing "bloodofox has been chronically and intractably stubborn, argumentative... They have displayed a WP:OWNership attitude about... topics they're involved with." Additional sourcing or discussion on Talk is unlikely to resolve the behavior pattern, as Bloodofox has now been provided with RSes in the form of first popular media, then Skeptical Inquirer, and now folkloric scholars, only to reject all in favor of their own personal preferred verbiage. Feoffer2 (talk) 14:24, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

  • I totally understand where they're coming from, though. Labelling anything as a cryptid (especially in WikiVoice) immediately gives credence to Cryptozoology, which is a rather silly pseudoscience. Even if sources are using the word, are they using it in a credulous way (in which case I'd debate whether they're reliable) or are they reporting on the use of the word by others (in which case it shouldn't be reported in Wikivoice anyway, but attributed)? Black Kite (talk) 15:15, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
    gives credence to Cryptozoology Quite the contrary: to call an entity a "cryptid" is to alert readers that it "has never [been] proven to exist" (per MW). Explicit attribution to a non-credulous source or scare-quotes sounds good, but a total ban on using the term or Category:Cryptids seems like a mistake. Feoffer2 (talk) 16:36, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
    Indeed, but when we're talking about imaginary concepts, giving them a scientific-sounding name is only going to suggest to the gullible that they're something that exists. Black Kite (talk) 21:01, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Feoffer, I'm looking at Indrid Cold's history, and it looks more like a WP:ONUS policy issue on your part. If content is removed (especially if it didn't have clear consensus before), it's your responsibility to get consensus before reinserting it. Trying out a single new edit is one thing if you think it'll fix an issue without needing talk, but it should have been clear what you wanted did not have consensus after Bloodofox reverted it. To call that out as edit-warring at ANI is poor judgement at best and manipulative at worst.
At that article, Bloodofox made series of edits. You made a large restoration, and Bloodofox reverted one small piece of that. If someone tried to report Bloodofox for non-3RR edit warring in that instance, I'd be more prone to invoke WP:BOOMERANG. Even if you think you are right and are under 3RR, it is not an excuse to revert when you really should be getting consensus first. KoA (talk) 17:11, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

Federico Emilio Puricelli Malaplat

Federico Emilio Puricelli Malaplat (talk · contribs · deleted contribs · logs · filter log · block user · block log)

Mass-deleting information from pages, most notably Tomy just to make a draft for TakaraTomy that would instantly fail. Is there any way to figure this out, remember how Tomy, considers its pre-2006 history (トミー) before the merger with Takara to be part of its history? SBF2004 (talk) 13:36, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

OK. At the beginning, I was trying to separate the Tomy hisotry from the future Takara Tomy history. Because, the article itself is already in disorder at first look. FePM (talk) 16:30, 16 November 2026 (UTC).
But in reality, Japanese Wikipedia has different rules than this wiki, because we historically treat Tomy and TakaraTomy as the same entity then why are you doing this? SBF2004 (talk) 20:43, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Because I thought it was more confusing, then I was wrong again, and I decided to delete the new draft as it was in vain. FePM (talk) 00:21, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

Revoke TPA

The following discussion is closed. Please do not modify it. No further edits should be made to this discussion.


Mmnrefdkjcvfnik (talk · contribs · deleted contribs · logs · filter log · block user · block log)

see filter log, they've been doing this for the past hour, thanks!!! -- Wesoree (talk·contribs) 16:18, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

The discussion above is closed. Please do not modify it. No further edits should be made to this discussion.

Editor is encouraging other editors to commit suicide just as "David Carradine" did

The following discussion is closed. Please do not modify it. No further edits should be made to this discussion.


The editor wrote "If articles like this are going to continue to be posted. We need to implement mandatory drug and psychological testing before a post can be made.. There is no way in Hades that even on our founding fathers, while this revolutionary dreams, could we have come close to fighting in 99 wars since our inception. Our country is having a hard enough time producing young adults who are not dumber than a box of rocks, whereas almost 68% of school aid kids can't read on level. It gets worse when you get into the really hard stuff. So stop clapping at the minds of these morons. ,(Personal attack removed)."

He is encouraging our editors to commit suicide.

Disclaimer: Never posted on Administrators' noticeboard/Incidents before and I am not as good at code editing so I am doing my best to post appropriately.

Historyguy1138 (talk) 19:48, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

Indeffed, revision hidden. Please do not repeat awful stuff here--this is a highly visible location. We can always track down the original text if we need to. — rsjaffe 🗣️ 19:55, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Wanna cleanup their TP and disable access after how they responded to you? DMacks (talk) 19:59, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
The discussion above is closed. Please do not modify it. No further edits should be made to this discussion.

Wikijacking

The following discussion is closed. Please do not modify it. No further edits should be made to this discussion.


In 2017, I followed an online course on FRANCE UNIVERSITÉ NUMÉRIQUE (fun-mooc.fr) about contributing in Wikipedia. I contributed to History of the metre, Arc measurement of Delambre and Méchain and International Association of Geodesy among others. I created two articles: Central European Arc Measurement and Swiss Geodetic Commission in French and in English under the nickname @Charles Inigo. Despite my renewed efforts to limit duplications which I was accused of and my efforts to constructively discuss ways to ameliorate articles I contributed in, I was recently mentionned by @Johnjbarton in Talk:History_of_the_metre#c-Johnjbarton-20261030181100-Fgnievinski-20261020125000. Indeed, I may perhaps come across as overly suspicious and full of myself, but I must confess that his recent deletion of my contributions in Swiss Geodetic Commission leads me to suspect that he intends to publish my work under his own name. I believe this behavior—which I would term "Wikijacking"—is something he has been criticized for in the past, and could accordingly to another editor justify his exclusion from Wikipedia. See User:Johnjbarton#Experience_with_Wikipedia. I therefore firmly demand that he undo his recent deletion in Swiss Geodetic Commission. Please see Talk:Swiss_Geodetic_Commission. Charles Inigo (talk) 18:51, 30 October 2026 (UTC)

Sorry, are you saying that we can't port articles from other language wikis to here cause it's "your" work? — VPP (t/c) 19:24, 30 October 2026 (UTC)
This is a content dispute. My behavior, deleting off-topic content duplicated across several articles, was in response to another editors complaint, see Talk:History_of_the_metre#Duplication. Within the very long thread Talk:Swiss_Geodetic_Commission#Content_deleted_from_this_article. I asked if Charles Inigo would agree to add part of a deleted paragraph to a section in History of the metre. I was trying to find a way to reuse the off topic content. I guess that is where this "suspect that he intends to publish" comes from. I can see now that trying to help was a mistake. Johnjbarton (talk) 19:45, 30 October 2026 (UTC)
@Johnjbarton: Your last sentence there was a bit hostile. --Hammersoft (talk) 19:55, 30 October 2026 (UTC)
@Hammersoft Could you clarify "last sentence there"? Which article/talk page? Or are you referring to my post directly above? Johnjbarton (talk) 20:49, 30 October 2026 (UTC)
The last sentence in your post above; "I can see now that trying to help was a mistake." --Hammersoft (talk) 22:44, 30 October 2026 (UTC)
Hm, can you help me understand why this is hostile? I regret wasting rather a lot of my time attempting to communicate. I added this because I think the community should understand that my experience with engagement went badly. I don't see how this is hostile to anyone. Johnjbarton (talk) 23:33, 30 October 2026 (UTC)
Because stating that trying to help was a mistake can be read as an accusation that the person you are in dispute with is intractable. It's just not necessary. Your comments read just the same with out. Focus on the dispute, not the person. --Hammersoft (talk) 01:24, 1 November 2026 (UTC)
No less hostile than the wild accusation coming out of left field that deleting a section = intent to publish under one's own name. Ravenswing 22:30, 30 October 2026 (UTC)
Hostility by someone else doesn't justify hostility by another. --Hammersoft (talk) 22:44, 30 October 2026 (UTC)
No, it doesn't. Nor does it excuse the hostility in the first place. Ravenswing 00:59, 31 October 2026 (UTC)
@Charles Inigo: When you publish new content to any page on Wikipedia, you "agree to release your contribution under the CC BY-SA 4.0 License and the GFDL". That means anyone can basically do whatever they want with it so long as attribution occurs (which, for our purposes, is done with edit histories), so long as it follows those licenses. That includes another editor re-publishing it...even word for word...from their accounts. If you're not comfortable irrevocably releasing your content under those licenses, you shouldn't publish here. --Hammersoft (talk) 19:55, 30 October 2026 (UTC)
As Hammersoft says, once you post something to Wikipedia, you do not have any further control over what's done with it. - The Bushranger One ping only 22:31, 30 October 2026 (UTC)
Of course, I understand that the content I added can be reused. I am also conscious that if I port articles from other languages to English Wikipedia their content can be reused without permission. The point is that I am afraid Johnjbarton is not of good faith when he deletes content pretending it is off topic. When saying that deleting a section could be explained by the intention to publish under one's own name, I repeat an explaination that Johnjbarton hosts in is own userpage about the hostility his behaviour produced in another contributor. The advantages he could get by obtaining attribution of content which is not anymore available in the free Encyclopedia seems more important than if the content is stil under publication in Wikipedia. An alternative explaination could be that he exercises censorship or both. Charles Inigo (talk) 23:04, 30 October 2026 (UTC)
Or you could WP:Assume good faith and consider the possibility that they deleted the text as off topic because they genuinely believe it is off topic. MrOllie (talk) 23:30, 30 October 2026 (UTC)
I just want to point out that I did not publish any content authored by Charles Inigo, so the entire question of whether it is according to license or not does not apply here. The root cause of this discussion is not my additions but rather my deletions, which Charles wishes to revert and prevent. Johnjbarton (talk) 23:40, 30 October 2026 (UTC)
I would precise that I endured a lot of deletions which I tried to overcome as a means to ameliorate my contributions in other articles. Hence the duplications. However I consider my contributions in Swiss Geodetic Commission my masterpiece. I sought to illustrate Switzerland’s participation in the history of scientific collaborations during the 19th century, which led to the creation of the International Bureau of Weights and Measures, the International Association of Geodesy, and the International Statistical Institute. The drive to do this was to let know this true fact following a period in which Switzerland (not Sweden) was deprived from access to scientific collaboration with the European community. The article corresponding to Swiss Geodetic Commission in German is another example of promotional enterprise in Wikipedia. However this article is protected and cannot be modified. Charles Inigo (talk) 01:46, 31 October 2026 (UTC)
Have you, uh, considered writing a book instead? Serious question. • ꕤ Stylomecon ✎ • «talk» • 06:59, 1 November 2026 (UTC)
Another of my motivations was to show that the history of science can be explained in different ways. I could cite, for example, the sidelining of Carlos Ibáñez e Ibáñez de Ibero from the caption of a photograph depicting the founding members of the International Statistical Institute, or recent article that highlights the role of the German astronomer Wilhelm Julius Foerster, even though Carlos Ibáñez e Ibáñez de Ibero served for 16 years as the first president of the International Committee for Weights and Measures.https://www.unav.es/gep/IbanezDeIbero.html Charles Inigo (talk) 09:17, 31 October 2026 (UTC)
I must acknowledge that @Johnjbarton has done an excellent job in simplifying the "History of the Metre." The article is now much more readable. However, as far as I can judge as a French speaker, my contributions regarding the Swiss Geodetic Commission are of a higher quality than what I would expect from the simplified style adopted by Johnjbarton. As I mentionned, I would like the article "Swiss Geodetic Commission" to be translated into as many languages ​​as possible. I therefore propose that Johnjbarton translates this article for the Simple English Wikipedia and ceases his acts of vandalism on the corresponding article in the English Wikipedia. Charles Inigo (talk) 12:18, 31 October 2026 (UTC)
I'm sensing major WP:OWN problems from you. And you really should read the 3rd pillar. As the 3rd pillar implies, you should expect anything you write to be mercilessly edited. If you don't like that then a collaborative project isn't that place for you. You can consider something a masterpiece but unless other editors agree it's perfect for the article this is irrelevant. Write a blog or something if you want to write masterpieces uninterrupted. To be clear editors can and do almost singlehandedly bring an article to WP:FA status but that's because they improve them enough in ways the community agrees makes them good enough for the status. An editor's personal opinion on how his good their work is is largely irrelevant and all editors need to be willing to accept that their work will be edited and that no matter how good they consider their work was, if the community disagrees it may be edited significantly and they need to adjust to what the community wants going forward. To be clear I have not evaluated your changes. It's just your comments here which makes me think you're confused how things work. Nil Einne (talk) 13:54, 31 October 2026 (UTC) 14:21, 31 October 2026 (UTC)
BTW to be clear, I mean no sarcasm or doubt about the masterpiece thing. You may very well have written a masterpiece but it doesn't mean it's suitable for the article or any article. Things need to be suitable for and fit in with the English Wikipedia and how we do things regardless of how good they are. Nil Einne (talk) 14:25, 31 October 2026 (UTC)
I got the point. However, in Talk:Swiss_Geodetic_Commission I tried to answer objections of Johnjbarton doubting that my content was correctly sourced. I provided 16 sources and got answers showing that they were missinterpreted by him. Charles Inigo (talk) 14:33, 31 October 2026 (UTC)
As I pointed out on that talk page, the sources mostly verify the content, but they fail to mention the article's topic. Johnjbarton (talk) 16:13, 31 October 2026 (UTC)
I'm not going to look into detail but it's no point providing 16 sources if many of them are useless. Letters written by people involved are primary sources and are almost definitely useless for anything except maybe as an additional source for readers who might want to check them out when all the content is already supported by recent secondary sources. I say recent for a reason, letters are even more useless when they are from the 19th century. If you want to do independent history research, Wikipedia is the wrong place for that. Feel free to write an article somewhere that will be welcome, there are many places where that will be welcome but Wikipedia is not one of them. You said "Third, the first large section you deleted correspond to the Background of the creation of learned societies in Switzerland in particular in the canton of Geneva joining Switzerland in 1815" but the article is about something founded in 1861 so it's incredibly unlikely you'd need a "large section" "creation of learned societies" "in 1815" belongs. Sources are basically irrelevant. You never explaied what on earth "The Swiss survey is clearly mentionned" had to do with anything. This is an article on the Swiss Geodetic Commission. It's not an article on Pearce or a Swiss survey or anything else. Very limited background information might be added but generally sources will need to connect the background to the Swiss Geodetic Commission and regardless it will need to be very limited. This is much more likely to belong in the European Geodetic Association article although frankly even there is seems likely it's WP:UNDUE. If this survey or Peirce are notable then we could have an article on either of them where this might belong, But not the article on the Swiss Geodetic Commission unless you find far better sourcing establishing that this is of relevance to the Swiss Geodetic Commission which you never seemed to do. I could go on but from what I see Johnjbarton basically outlined plenty of well supported concerns and you ignored them. Johnjbarton has even gone as far as to try and help you find places to copy the content yourself (so you will get the credit) and while to your credit you have engaged in that, you are still complaining about the basic fact a lto of what you are trying to add doesn't seem to belong or at least you've failed to establish that it does with any sources. So on your part, what I see is an editor demanding to have their way even when there are very good policy and guideline based reasons why you are wrong, and ignoring an editor explaining this to them and continuing to edit war to have their way. And I suggest you think carefully about how you respond since it's looking more and more like a boomerang is going to result. Nil Einne (talk) 18:25, 31 October 2026 (UTC)
The Swiss suvey cannot refer to anything else than the pendulum work of the Swiss Geodetic Commission in the secondary source mentionned. A primary source about one's own work can also mention other's work and be also considered a secondary source on some points. I also mentionned secondary sources already sourcing the text which was reverted.
I acknoledged that the background of the creation of learned societies in Switzerland could be moved in Swiss Academy of Sciences and moved the content there.
I mentionned two secondary source mentionning Pierce, Cellerier, Hirsch and Plantamour. N° 9 and 10. Charles Inigo (talk) 18:56, 31 October 2026 (UTC)
Comment: I have a personal interest in, and some knowledge of, the history of science in Switzerland. I have looked at the material recently removed from Swiss Geodetic Commission by Johnjbarton, and scanned through the talk page thread about it. It seems to me that Johnjbarton was quite right to say that the removed content doesn't fit into the narrow topic of the history of this commission: it's overly detailed, contains long paragraphs about background matters not really related to the Swiss Geodetic Commission itself, and lacks contextualisation for the lay reader as to why this background is important. In my opinion, at ~50kb, the text should also be broken up into at least two or three subsections to make it easier to read. The material is more like an essay on the development of geodetic standards than an encyclopaedia entry, and while it is well-sourced and has value, it was not appropriate in its previous state in this article.
I agree with Johnjbarton that at least some of this material could usefully be moved to other articles, perhaps History of the metre as has been proposed (though I haven't read that article myself). Some of it could even be reworked and put back into Swiss Geodetic Commission. I don't think, however, that it should be replaced as-is.
I also don't believe that there's any reason to suspect Johnjbarton of wanting to re-publish Charles Inigo's work as their own, whether here, on other languages' Wikipedias, or elsewhere. In my opinion, there's not much point discussing that suggestion further. Suðurhafsljósæta (talk) 12:41, 31 October 2026 (UTC)
Hmm, that was too many words from me on the content-dispute side of things. Sorry. Suffice it to say that I think this is a content dispute, and Johnjbarton has not been vandalising the page, let alone with nefarious intentions. Suðurhafsljósæta (talk) 12:44, 31 October 2026 (UTC)
Refering to History of the metre, I must recall that after its simplification the article was proposed for deletion. See Talk:History_of_the_metre. This was the reason I interpret some contributors were exercising censorship. Charles Inigo (talk) 14:05, 31 October 2026 (UTC)
To save everyone else the trouble of looking, the AfD for History of the metre was opened and closed in July 2025, more than a year ago. Suðurhafsljósæta (talk) 16:21, 31 October 2026 (UTC)
Soon after the process of simplification was over. Charles Inigo (talk) 16:53, 31 October 2026 (UTC)
Someone suggested the content be merged. It got limited support with the result of this Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/History of the metre being keep. Notably no one suggested anything more than merge so most of the content was always going to be kept and anyone would find it from the same URI. So it's hard to see how there was any suggestion of censorship. Everyone would still find more or less the exact same content in the same way. The editor who suggested the merge is not the one who you're complaining about here indeed the editor here was uninvolved in the merge problem. Besides the problems I highlighted above you seem to have a major problem with not WP:AGF and are fact accusing editors of ridiculous things with basically zero evidence. Again this seems to come because you are unwilling to accept other editors may legitimately have different ideas from you about how our articles should be and that's perfectly okay. In this case it's even more silly since the community consensus was with you so there's zero reason to care. And as I said this is largely a dispute over organisation of content not whether the content will be in any article. No one was suggesting the content should be removed from Wikipedia just put somewhere else so it seems even more ridiculous. I suggest you stop with all this and just agree to do better than you have been before a WP:boomerang result. Nil Einne (talk) 17:23, 31 October 2026 (UTC)
It is difficult for me to assume Johnjbarton's good faith after he proposed to me to move the content in History of the metre#Meridional definition. Then explained in Talk:History_of_the_metre#Duplication that his attempts to cleanup articles have been reverted and all discussions return to adding the same off-topic content back, while this discussion started with a complaint about my duplications. I must confess that I asked him if the content would be suitable for Topographic Map of Switzerland which he recently proposed to rename Dufour map. See: Talk:Topographic Map of Switzerland. Charles Inigo (talk) 18:38, 31 October 2026 (UTC)
I just replied to @Johnjbarton in Talk:History_of_the_metre#Duplication. Charles Inigo (talk) 17:16, 31 October 2026 (UTC)
The suggestion I was exercising censorship is as absurd as Charles Inigo telling Johnjbarton "your recent deletion of my contributions in Swiss Geodetic Commission leads me to suspect that you intend to publish my work under your own name. ... I therefore firmly demand that you undo this action." For years, Charles has been adding detailed and longwinded content to articles about the metre and the metric system, and for years, other editors have sought to persuade Charles it's off-topic and often removed it. Charles has persisted anyway, across multiple articles. Now they claim their material must not be removed, for fear of something that has not happened, is unlikely to happen, and would not be wrong if it did happen.
Looking for example at Charles's edits to Metrication this month, with e.g. its long list of committee members and circuitous lecture on temperature effects, I despair of these important articles ever being readable as long as Charles Inigo is active in the topic area. NebY (talk) 18:39, 31 October 2026 (UTC)
Please have a look at Metrication#United_States_(1830–present). Charles Inigo (talk) 19:01, 31 October 2026 (UTC)
A fine example, wandering massively off-topic with one long paragraph about error and temperature effects, another about European assemblies, and another about geodesy, while the initial content that could be on-topic for the US is all about recognising the contribution of one Swiss geodesist. NebY (talk) 19:21, 31 October 2026 (UTC)
I added content about Samuel B. Ruggles US representative to the Committee on Weights and Measures and Coins which was established during the Exposition Universelle (1867) in Paris and called for the international adoption of the metric system. I tried to put this in context. Charles Inigo (talk) 19:43, 31 October 2026 (UTC)
You added one sentence about Ruggles, followed by a paragraph of "context", and you're not acknowledging the other problems. NebY (talk) 21:10, 31 October 2026 (UTC)
Do you consider mentionning the Metric Act of 1866 in Metrication#United_States_(1830–present) as a problem? Charles Inigo (talk) 21:23, 31 October 2026 (UTC)

Can someone explain to me what's going on? ~2026-53148-17 (talk) 18:58, 31 October 2026 (UTC)

I must admit the discussion is a bit confused. I complained about reccurent revesal of my edits, while other would like to impose me a topic ban because I proposed an alternative history of the definition and adoption of the metre than that which used to be proposed in History of the metre pretending the metre was defined by the pendulum length. This led to an editorial dispute, and some would like to lay the blame on me. Charles Inigo (talk) 19:12, 31 October 2026 (UTC)
Can you provide any evidence that "other would like to impose me a topic ban because I proposed an alternative history of the definition and adoption of the metre"? It seems no more justifiable than your initial accusation that "he intends to publish my work under his own name". NebY (talk) 21:05, 31 October 2026 (UTC)
Please give your own answer to the question. Charles Inigo (talk) 21:25, 31 October 2026 (UTC)
No. You made the accusation, now you must back it up or strike it as an aspersion. - The Bushranger One ping only 23:45, 31 October 2026 (UTC)
I must confess I was surprised by @Johnjbarton proposal to duplicate content of Swiss Geodetic Commission into History_of_the_metre#Meridional_definition while there was a discussion starting with a complaint about my duplications in Talk:History_of_the_metre#Duplication in which I felt threatened by @Fgnievinski question about a topic ban which should be reactivated against me.
This threat had been followed by Johnjbarton's suppressions of contributions I made 3 month earlier in Swiss Geodetic Commission two days after a suppression of content in Arc measurement of Delambre and Méchain. I had expanded this article in a hurry when History of the metre was simplified, a process concluded by a proposal for deletion in Summer 2025.
I had discussed with Johnjbarton the possibility to move deleted content from Swiss Geodetic Commission into Topographic Map of Switzerland from where content (90 percent written by me according to Johnjbarton) had been duplicated and ameliorated (in my opinion). I thought this would be alright for him, but he deleted the content there too. After a discussion in which I thought I convinced him that the text he had suppressed was correctly sourced, as he had proposed to add this content in History_of_the_metre#Meridional_definition, I added the text he had suppressed into Swiss Geodetic Commission leaving to him the change in History of the metre.
He then deleted the text again and mentionned me in Talk:History_of_the_metre#Duplication. Considering he was not of good faith, I checked his user page where he mentionned the "wikijacking" strategy he had been accused of and of which I thought I could also be a victim. Hence the notice aiming both at stopping the threats against me and stop this edit dispute.
Since then Johnjbarton proposed to rename Topographic Map of Switzerland. I hope my deleted contributions from Swiss Geodetic Commssion could be inserted into the new Dufour map article. Charles Inigo (talk) 05:40, 1 November 2026 (UTC)
After a discussion in which I thought I convinced him that the text he had suppressed...
...considering he was not of good faith
...I thought I could also be a victim...
Hence the notice aiming both at stopping the threats against me...
(bolding added)
I'm sorry to say this, but your mindset is not a good one to have at at a collaborative project like Wikipedia and I hope you can change your view of other editors who you disagree with.
Firstly, some of your posts indicate that you're not fully aware that the things you write here don't belong to you - they are transient and very likely to evolve over time, as others edit the same article. Your original text may not exist at all in a year or two, and you have no control over that.
You also seem to be having trouble focusing your work on the core subject of the article, and don't seem to fully comprehend/accept whenever this is fed back. Even here, you're not always properly answering the questions you've been asked, nor fully understanding why your posts can be seen as problematic. If you are, I'm afraid it's just not coming across in your responses.
Secondly, your last post is (IMO) still pretty accusatory, and I'm not seeing much introspection on your part - even reading through past discussions, you tend to gloss over concerns, even after they've been raised repeatedly, and the whole discussion at Talk:History of the metre#Duplication is rather difficult to read as a result.
You've been asked to substantiate your allegations against another editor, instead it feels like you've doubled-down (saying you could be a victim, as if there were a previous crime/malfeasance committed by that editor). Re. "Wikijacking", it seems like you were perhaps proactively looking for something negative about another editor, to validate your own negative feelings about them? That's not a pleasant place for anyone to be, if I'm right then please try to avoid doing this, for your own wellbeing as well as others.
BTW, I can't see any specific threats of reinstating a TBAN on Talk:History_of_the_metre#Duplication? There's a mention of a previous TBAN suggestion from last year, but these seem to only have been suggestions and didn't go any further (I will say that article Talk pages aren't really the best place for discussions over behaviour/TBAN's, however). I presume this is what you meant?
Overall, it feels like you're talking to other editors, but you don't seem to really be listening. In solidarity, Blue-Sonnet (I'm listening) 09:35, 1 November 2026 (UTC)
Thank you for your comment. According to you, I should not feel theatened. I rencently talked to other editors in Talk:History_of_the_metre#Duplication and wait for they answers. Charles Inigo (talk) 12:01, 1 November 2026 (UTC)
Well, no, you can feel however you wish, my exact words were I can't see any specific threats of reinstating a TBAN in response to your comment that I felt threatened by @Fgnievinski question about a topic ban which should be reactivated against me. This threat had been followed by Johnjbarton's suppressions...
I couldn't find any evidence of a threat to reactivate a TBAN (I don't think you've ever had one?), which is why I was a bit confused and wrote that I couple only presume (guess) that this is what you were referring to.
I could only find other editors discussing whether they should consider suggesting a TBAN (very reluctantly, I might add), but no specific threat from either editor that matched what you alleged.
You can feel however you wish about this, I wouldn't ever tell you otherwise.
I also don't see that they ...would like to impose me a topic ban because I proposed an alternative history of the definition and adoption of the metre - their concerns were over the amount of off-topic, tangential and excessively verbose material that was being added, as far as I understand the discussions. They didn't seem keen to take this to a TBAN discussion, considering it had first been mentioned in 2025.
It's honestly hard to tell, because you're linking entire threads and not any specific quotes or diffs; we're all left trying to guess at which comments you mean, yet none of them really match what you're alleging has happened here. We don't know whether you're bringing up valid concerns or if you've perhaps misunderstood something. In solidarity, Blue-Sonnet (I'm listening) 12:45, 1 November 2026 (UTC)
Thank you for your effort to explain the situation to me. I have contributed in History of the metre a long time and was bothered by reccurent added content mentionning that the original definition of the metre was the seconds pendulum's length. Interventions of Johnjbarton helped to summarize the link between the seconds pendulum and the Earth after many years of what I would call (using the words of Johnjbarton) a curious and obscure kind of vandalism tedious to repair. Thus, the reproach Johnjbarton leveled at me resonated within me in a particular way. I can't either be absolutely sure that I did not misunderstood something nor that I am bringing up invalid concerns. I am still waiting for an answer to my last question in Talk:History_of_the_metre#Duplication. Charles Inigo (talk) 13:53, 1 November 2026 (UTC)
I can't either be absolutely sure that I did not misunderstood something nor that I am bringing up invalid concerns.
Whenever this happens, please try to follow the assume good faith principle; unless there's very good, obvious evidence that someone is purposefully being malicious, then always presume the other person is operating in good faith; it's entirely possible that the person you're speaking to is mistaken, not in possession of all the facts or even just having a terrible day. Perhaps you're mistaken but don't realise it.
Good faith is the default position on Wikipedia and it should take a lot to tip the bar over into "bad faith" territory.
Turning to content, the desire to pass on knowledge about something you're passionately interested in is entirely natural, but it can often lead to that person inadvertently overwhelming the recipient. That's also the case on Wikipedia - if you know all this interesting stuff, of course you'll to want to pass that information on. It doesn't mean it's always a good idea, however, and that instinct often needs tempering. It's akin to information overload or a wall of text, but that's not how we want our articles to be.
Can you understand the concerns that others have raised regarding your work lacking focus? If this continues then I'm worried it has the potential to turn toxic and sour your editing career here when it really shouldn't have to go that far.
I'm certain that you don't want to waste your time writing paragraphs of information that will only be removed by someone else as off-topic, and other volunteer editors don't want to spend their own time pruning and removing your hard work - nobody wins in that scenario, everyone just comes out of the experience feeling awful.
So, I have a question for you: Would you be willing to try and focus your work on the core subject of the article, minimising tangents as much as possible?
For example, if you've begun a completely new paragraph and find that you're writing about something other than the subject of the article, take it as a giant red flag & seriously consider removing/amending it. Take it out and review the article - does it still give the reader the same amount of information about the core subject? Would it tell the reader more if it was in a different article instead? If that article doesn't exist, would it be worth drafting one?
Tangents & focus seem to be the main concern, and it's a temptation that I'm personally very familiar with.
Being very honest, my initial drafted posts are usually three or four times their eventual length (including this one, which took half an hour), as I've learned over time that I need to treat my writing like a bonsai; I prune off as much as I can, whilst leaving the core message intact. It's a skill that I don't always succeed at - this post is a little longer than I'd like it to be - but it's nowhere near as bad as it would be otherwise!
Perhaps you might find this approach helpful as well? In solidarity, Blue-Sonnet (I'm listening) 17:45, 3 November 2026 (UTC)
To be honest here, when I look at the article, I can see why the content was deleted. I'm not saying it's bad content—it's not—but quite a lot of it seemingly has very little to actually do with the Swiss Geodetic Commission. The second section that was deleted contains 4 paragraphs in a row—a total of nearly 700 words—that don't mention the commission once and it's unclear as to how this actually relates to the topic at hand. Is it just miscellaneous content about people who happened to be in the commission? If it's genuinely related, then state that in the article. And the first section is just miscellaneous history without justification as to how it relates to the Swiss Geodetic Commission. I'll admit, I don't know a ton about the topic so I'm not sure to what extent it actually is related to the Swiss Geodetic Commission but it doesn't necessarily seem like it just from a readthrough.
In terms of the reversion, I don't think you should have added that content back into the article and I think that Johnjbarton was in the right for reverting it before a consensus was reached. After removing the content, Johnjbarton (appropriately) created a talk page discussion explaining why he removed the content and suggested where you could reuse it. You two debated, and after not being able to come to a conclusion, he suggested to ask other editors for help (i.e. in an WP:RFC). However, instead of doing this, you re-added the content and accused Johnjbarton of removing the content in bad faith and "Wikijacking". For one, you could have waited for that to actually happen before taking it up at ANI. Additionally, there is no indication that Johnjbarton is trying to steal your content nor any realistic motivation for him to do so. I am more concerned about your willingness to assume bad faith and how you insult people who disagree with you, such as the multiple times you've insinuated Johnjbarton is not smart enough to understand or write complex English, that he is trying to steal your work and paste it elsewhere on WP, or that other editors are trying to censor Wikipedia.
I have read through the previous ANI that Johnjbarton was part of and it's another post accusing Johnjbarton of incompetence and trying to get him banned from WP over a content dispute (which also had nothing to do with Wikijacking, for what it's worth). The fact that you seem to think that Johnjbarton was in the wrong there, too, makes me a bit concerned about your mindset towards editing WP. I am not trying to say this to hate, and I realize that a significant proportion of editors come from academic settings and it is not always easy to collaborate with others, especially when you're used to working alone. However, to me, it seems that you feel that you WP:OWN the articles you've created or worked on substantially, and that anyone who disagrees with you is automatically wrong and/or incompetent. I have worked significantly with Johnjbarton on Black hole and never had any problems, even when we didn't always agree on content. I do think you are genuinely trying to act in good faith and improve the encyclopedia, but unfortunately, you need to change your mindset before that can happen. I support looking into WP:Assume good faith, WP:Don't call a spade a spade, and WP:Assume high intelligence. Good luck, and I hope you can hear me out. Shocksingularity (talk) 08:35, 3 November 2026 (UTC)
Thank you for your comment. I tried to calm myself translating in German. The Wikipedia article Swiss Geodetic Commssion exists now in French, Italian and German with a permanent link towards https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Swiss_Geodetic_Commission&diff=prev&oldid=1382828231. This discussion will also remain as a trace of my motivations in this enterprise. This is sufficient for me. As John F. Kennedy advised I asked not what my country could do for me, but what I could do for my country. I recalled the role Switzerland played in the 19th centuy scientific collaborations as a neutral country in central Europe and could continue to play in the future. Charles Inigo (talk) 18:35, 3 November 2026 (UTC)

Recommend we just close this as a rather initially confusing series of cultural and communications misunderstandings, so we can all go back to editing. — VPP (t/c) 17:28, 3 November 2026 (UTC)

I suspect that the problems will recur unless we get a clear statement from Charles Inigo that they have taken the comments by multiple editors above to heart and will try to follow Wikipedia's policies and guidelines in the future. Lacking that, In my opinion a three day block applied now is likely to avoid another trip to ANI in the future, with the possibility of a longer block or topic ban.
For the record, Johnjbarton is one on those names I keep seeing because I have a lot of science and technology pages on my watchlist, and my reaction is pretty much always "that was a nice improvement to that article". --Guy Macon (talk) 15:44, 5 November 2026 (UTC)
I tried to take in account the remarks and did not massive copy and paste of content from one article to another. As you already know my last copy and paste was extracts from Prime meridian (Greenwich) into Central European Arc Measurement which I then translated into de:Gradmessungskommission. As I mentionned above I concentrated in translating in German Wikipedia. When translating the "censored" version of Swiss Geodetic Commission into German I tried to summarize the text by translating a limited number of sentences. The text was also ameliorated by @Johnjbarton contributions in the English Wikipedia version of the article which was first exported in Gradmessungskommission than copied from there into Schweizerische Geodätische Kommission.
When contributing in de:Gradmessungskommission, I realized that I had wrongly linked that article with Swiss Geodetic Commission, fr:Commission géodésique suisse and it:Commissione Geodetica Svizzera. So I created a German Wikipedia article called de:Schweizerische Geodätische Kommission and also worked on Gradmessungskommission and proposed that it would be renamed into Mitteleuropäische Gradmessung and would be linked to Central European Arc Measurement and to fr:Association pour la mesure des degrés en Europe centrale.
I also translated some content (part of a note) from Arc measurement of Delambre and Méchain into Urmeter.
I belive now that some incomprehensible advices Johnjbarton gave to me probably were clues to guide me in changing the content of articles in other languages. In that hypothesis deleting content was a way to encourage translations.
In my opinion important informations are still lacking in the article Swiss Geodetic Commission and this article would need further ameliorations. Charles Inigo (talk) 23:40, 5 November 2026 (UTC)

Wikijacking continuation

I have restored this item from the archive. @Charles Inigo has not withdrawn these accusations so I would like uninvolved editors to assess them. I would like to see this Incident closed. We are essentially engaged in a slow motion edit war with occasional engagement from other editors on articles like Swiss Geodetic Commission. I don't want to continue to contribute to these articles under these conditions. Johnjbarton (talk) 20:32, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

You had accidentally replied in the middle of the upper section, burying your comment and appeal from obvious visibility. I dropped it here instead.
Courtesy cc to @User:Charles Inigo — VPP (t/c) 04:07, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Your edits were essentially deletions of content or additions of depreciating content. I tried to improve the content you suppressed synthethizing it. The actual version of Swiss Geodetic Commission is the result of this process. However, I was reproched to supress or add content without consensus, even though other contributors were doing so without any qualms. Moreover, content of other articles were also suppressed or are intended to be. Please @Johnjbarton suppress the banner you added in Central European Arc Measurement and International Association of Geodesy. Those articles do not need to be merged. Central European Arc Measurement covers the origins of the International Association of Geodesy extending from 1861 to 1919. I ackowledge Johnjbarton tried to improve the history section of International association of Geodesy without huge deletion of content and adding a First president subsection. However, Ibáñez was president of the Permanent Commission of the Central Arc Measurement from 1874 then of the Permanent Commission of the International Geodetic Commission from 1886 up to his death in 1891. He did not presided the Metre Convention but the International Committee for Weights and Measures. He advocated the adoption of Greenwich meridian as Prime meridian in 1883 before the creation of the International Geodetic Association and prior to the International Meridian Conference. Charles Inigo (talk) 07:55, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Last but not least Ibáñez attended the 1887 first session of the International Statistical Institute in Rome. Charles Inigo (talk) 08:03, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
That sounds like a lot of content dispute. That's something you work out at article talk pages. It seems to me we're here because you have accused them of things like, he was not of good faith, [he] would like to impose me a topic ban because I proposed an alternative history of the definition and adoption of the metre, and deleting a section could be explained by the intention [of Johnjbarton] to publish under one's own name. These violate WP:AGF and WP:ASPERSIONS.
The solution moving forward is to unambiguously withdraw all accusations against them. If you do that, I think this section can be closed and everyone can edit together congenially. EducatedRedneck (talk) 12:09, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
The underlying problem is that @Charles Inigo persists in adding vast amounts of extraneous material to articles, as yesterday and today at Swiss Geodetic Commission, leaving us with the same digressions in multiple articles. Editors remonstrate and revert, but Charles keeps doing it, filling articles with the nineteenth-century history of geodesy, emphasising and re-emphasising the part played by particular people, and lecturing the reader at length about temperature effects on equipment and statistical methods of minimising error. As you see above, to Charles it's all connected and as we see at Swiss Geodetic Commission, International Association of Geodesy, Central European Arc Measurement, Dufour Map, History of the metre, Arc measurement of Delambre and Méchain and more, has to be made explicit everywhere. @Johnjbarton's right that it's a slow edit war; it's also one against many, but a very persistent one, and altogether a chronic, intractable behavioral problem that can't be worked out on article talk pages - we've tried. NebY (talk) 13:12, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
From what I've seen, I agree with NebY. Suðurhafsljósæta (talk) 13:15, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
From the little I've seen when investigating with the earlier dispute, I agree as well. Charles Inigo not only keeps adding all the unwanted material but they seem unable to understand why editors don't want it even after many attempts to reason with them. Instead they sometimes end up making spurious accusations against other editors who have good reasons for not wanting this material where they are trying to put it. One such spurious accusation was what started this thread in the first place. Nil Einne (talk) 14:59, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

Call for close

In my opinion, further discussion will not change the outcome of this report. I would like to see an uninvolved administrator evaluate the discussion, take whatever action is appropriate, and close this. --Guy Macon (talk) 17:39, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

It is clear that @Charles Inigo has difficulties collaborating with others and cooperating with consensus: attributes that are required to edit successfully on Wikipedia. This is enhanced by their lack of good faith when dealing with disagreements. Because it is clear that @Charles Inigo wants to improve Wikipedia, I (and I assume other admins) have been reluctant to take action in the hope that their behavior would improve with all the feedback they've received, but it has not.
Therefore, I have blocked them from Articles, in the hope that they can collaborate through the use of article talk pages. If their use of article talk pages proves disruptive, however, then they may eventually end up with a full block from editing. @Charles Inigo, please take this opportunity to work on collaborating with others, and understand that when everyone else disagrees with you, it is time to drop the issue and move on to other areas. — rsjaffe 🗣️ 20:12, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
You decision seems neutral and fair. About the proposition to merge Central European Arc Measurement and International Association of Geodesy. Since my last post in Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Central European Arc Measurement. @Johnjbarton added content in International_Association_of_Geodesy#History, which I modified as proposed above. If necessary, we will continue this discussion in the article talk page without being stressed by reccurent deletions. Thank you for the rest you imposed. Charles Inigo (talk) 20:36, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
The discussion above is closed. Please do not modify it. No further edits should be made to this discussion.

Likely AI agent Joey2231 rapidly making edits and drafts

The following discussion is closed. Please do not modify it. No further edits should be made to this discussion.


New account Joey2231 (talk · contribs) is making extremely rapid edits to political articles using AI (see for example of WP:AIFICTREF) and is failing to communicate on the talk page. Merlin04talkcontribs 20:39, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

just simply not true. relax Joey2231 (talk) 20:48, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
In what specific ways is it not true? You certainly seem to be making extremely rapid edits to political articles. The edits appear to be done with AI. I can't see where you responded on your talk page. --Yamla (talk) 20:50, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Partial blocked from mainspace until they explain themselves. Some of those edits were seconds apart (i.e. 14 major edits in 2 minutes from 20:30:37 UTC). And now ... they're setting up a user page. Of course they are. Black Kite (talk) 20:59, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
I intended to block Joey2231 indefinitely for obvious LLM use, too fast editing, and not telling the truth on ANI ("just simply not true. relax."), but Black Kite got there first. I guess I got too relaxed. 🙁 Bishonen | tålk 21:06, 16 November 2026 (UTC).
I thought I'd give them a chance to explain (which they haven't). They've now started speed-editing Draft articles, so I've indeffed them. Black Kite (talk) 21:17, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
And I've deleted all the drafts as G15. Black Kite (talk) 21:20, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
The mass of recent drafts from this user created not long after each other bewildered me, frankly. Beta Beta Beta - talk 21:04, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
FYI the user is requesting unblock. Black Kite (talk) 22:13, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
The discussion above is closed. Please do not modify it. No further edits should be made to this discussion.

A bunch of single purpose accounts for vandalism?

Now there are a number of SPAs on the talk page that have been created years ago but have edit counts in the single digits (and one of them also vandalized the article) who are also joined by several IPs to advocate for the addition of the "Evil bunny" to the article (see Talk:Evil#Perhaps we should allow the rabbit image. and this edit which I have reverted because it used Wikipedia and Reddit as references). The accounts involved:

Is this a sock farm? In any way, none of them appear to be here to build an encyclopedia. (Also, do I have to notify them all about this AN/I report? It's a bit of a pain doing this on mobile.) Nakonana (talk) 21:45, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

I have notified the registered users. Nakonana (talk) 22:16, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
This kind of pattern can be a sign that an amusing piece of vandalism has gone viral as a screenshot (eg. North Atlantic garbage patch) or that a YouTuber has talked about it (eg. Memory conformity). When someone enjoys the video or screenshot months or years later, there's a small chance that they'll check the article to see if the vandalism is still there, and a smaller chance they'll try to add it back (or join an "add the joke back" thread on the talk page of a protected article) when they see that it's not. Belbury (talk) 22:29, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Hi @Nakonana! I think you're taking this a bit too seriously, I thought that by adding a section mentioning the evil bunny meme qua meme it wouldn't be considered vandalism. My main work is over on the wikipedia incubator and the greek wikipedia/wiktionary anyways. PastelKos (talk) 22:33, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
PastelKos, I don't know what you think it is we do over here, but what you did in the article, please don't do that again. Drmies (talk) 23:06, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Yeah, it's possible that I jumped the gun a bit. Belbury's explanation sounds logical. Nakonana (talk) 23:19, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
i assure you, I am a human. Drspaniel (talk) 03:43, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

Periodic disruptive editing, ignoring warnings on Talk page despite previous temp. block

User Sagittarius0nFire has had several incidents of disruptive editing including repetitive minor or unexplained changes (warned here), given a temporary 31-hour block, been warned multiple times about MOS:PUFFERY violations here and here, and warned about MOS:TMRULES violations. The user has not responded to any of these in their Talk page, or ever engaged in other Talk pages. They recently made a contribution, again violating MOS:TMRULES despite previous warnings. This user has not shown that they will be a meaningful contributor to Wikipedia at this point. Pinging @Garzfoth and @DMacks. Slothwizard (talk) 00:17, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

I blocked Sagittarius0nFire (talk · contribs) from editing articles until a response indicates that future problems will be avoided. Johnuniq (talk) 01:15, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
+1 to this approach. DMacks (talk) 04:13, 19 November 2026 (UTC)

Cross-wiki harassment: ~2026-60650-00


On 16 November 2026 ~2026-60650-00 (talk · contribs) removed my photos from Pentaerythritol tetranitrate with the summary "Removed copyrighted images" (Special:Diff/1386086926), although they are freely licensed on Commons. I have restored them.

At the same time another temporary account, ~2026-60535-65, added the caption "Aleksander Sobolewski's is a copyright troll who will go after you if you use this image" to around 66 of my files on Commons. This is connected to a YouTube copyright takedown I filed against a creator who used my photos without attribution. On the same day I was contacted on Commons by the account PThompson19, and I suspect the same person is behind these edits while logged out. Commons report: c:Commons:Administrators' noticeboard/Vandalism#c-Alekssobolewski-20261117012500-~2026-60535-65.

I'd ask for a block of the temporary account and, if possible, a check for connected accounts. alekss (talk) 01:42, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

While the timing is suggestive, the TA hasn't done anything on enwiki other than this single removal of images, now reverted. I am reluctant to block without further evidence of disruption. Rusalkii (talk) 00:00, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Okay, do as you see fit. Let's hope this dies down and there are no more 'disruptions'. alekss (talk) 02:51, 19 November 2026 (UTC)

Block evading TA vandals

The following discussion is closed. Please do not modify it. No further edits should be made to this discussion.


These TAs have been vadalising pages across Wikipedia, one of them has been even indeffed for it.. TAIV confirms all of these are the same users. Vestrian24Bio 01:44, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

The discussion above is closed. Please do not modify it. No further edits should be made to this discussion.

Wikipedia:Deletion review/Log/2026 November 8#RationalWiki

Wikipedia:Deletion review/Log/2026 November 8#RationalWiki (edit | talk | history | links | watch | logs)

The above two users have displayed conduct that pushes the boundaries of acceptability. Koubaki was warned for bludgeoning the afd and has bludgeoned the DR (although not as bad). OwenX has made comments that are uncivil . I believe that someone uninvolved should at least give a warning. Lavalizard101 (talk) WP:SOLIDARITY 15:18, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

Why did you only post this here after I pointed out that RW was canvassing the DRV ? Koubaki user page • talk page • contributions 15:45, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Who was canvassed to the discussion? PARAKANYAA (talk) 17:26, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
I don't think it's productive to explain it to you. Just WP:DROPTHESTICK, we've both made our point. Koubaki user page • talk page • contributions 17:45, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
You made an accusation. It is on you to explain why that accusation was made. - The Bushranger One ping only 17:50, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
You can see that the newer comments are talking about the DRV.
At least one TA claimed to be from RationalWiki in the DRV and many accounts suspiciously !voted keep the same day the thread was created, these are just some examples, many others (such as @PCHS Pirate Alumnus and @OwenX) have pointed out that there was canvassing. Koubaki user page • talk page • contributions 18:11, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
"Talking about" is not "canvassing". There is no comment in that entire discussion that suggests that users from there should vote anywhere.
The reason that many accounts voted keep the same day was because there was an ANI thread about it. All of the people who voted that day were ANI regulars. PARAKANYAA (talk) 19:04, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
"Talking about" is not "canvassing". All I'm going to say is that it can be, I'm not going to further discuss if it is canvassing. Koubaki user page • talk page • contributions 19:18, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Wait, that is the sole source for the canvassing allegations? One discussion existing somewhere, which a handful of people participated in, none of whom seem to have participated in the AFD here? Given the wildly dramatic way it was discussed and the fact that few people were confronting it, I assumed that something actually... happened. But if that's it then the fixation on canvassing was wildly out of line and OwenX citing it in their close was completely inappropriate. No, you're just flatly wrong here, simply talking about Wikipedia processes is not enough to allege canvassing, you need at least some evidence that people were either directed to the discussion or arrived because of it. I can sympathize to an extent because proving canvassing is a pain and it can feel frustrating to have consensus suddenly swing dramatically against your preferred outcome the way it did here; certainly I've sometimes squinted at discussions that suddenly swung sharply and then sighed. But you need more than that to make actual allegations, especially given that the dramatic swing postdates the posts about the discussion on ANI, meaning that it's more likely to be just... more people without established views on the topic arriving from within Wikipedia because it was raised on a high-profile centralized noticeboard. --Aquillion (talk) 20:36, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Sorry, I have to correct the record here. I argued that the post linked to by User:Koubaki wasn't blatant canvassing but pointed out anything malicious (like discussion about causing disruption) is going to be in private channels, conceding that there is no proof of blatant canvassing. That said, members of RationalWiki don't have to be actively plotting against Wikipedia to bludgeon the debate with votes, so it doesn't hurt to point out that a sheer tally of votes means absolutely nothing. Additionally, the fact that people are established Wikipedians or aren't affiliated with RationalWiki =/= they are unbiased. PCHS Pirate Alumnus (talk) 23:54, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Really confused what you're getting at here. If editors are established Wikipedians or aren't affiliated with RationalWiki there's no reason to thinki they've canvassed. And if they're biased, there's no reason to think they're biased to RationalWiki. Nil Einne (talk) 00:41, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
I posted this when I did because when OwenX made his response to my vote I was at work and waited until I was on my lunch break to check on the drv and saw his response. Anyway as was said at the ANI you opened last time the RW saloon bar thread isn't canvassing as its not attempting to sway the discussions. The votes by Randy Kryn et al. were a result of the ANI not the "canvassing". Lavalizard101 (talk) WP:SOLIDARITY 18:49, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Okay, thanks for telling me about that, even though I won't change my mind that it is canvassing. Koubaki user page • talk page • contributions 19:12, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Do sysops of other wikis not have COIs on articles about those wikis? Kowal2701 (talk, contribs) 19:44, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Not necessarily. There's a tension between WP:COI and WP:EXPERT, I am an (inactive) RW sysop. My inclination on seeing the AFD was !keep, but I didn't join in only because I lacked the energy properly to assess the evidence and arguments under enwiki standards. Narky Blert (talk) 06:35, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
I haven't looked into the whole matter, but the diffs of OwenX's comments don't look that uncivil to me. I certainly would be loath to warn someone merely for explaining their thought process somewhat hyperbolically. Accessedgrant (Epicgenius mobile alt) (talk) 17:49, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
I didn't see any incivility in these comments either. Koubaki user page • talk page • contributions 18:13, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
It seems very silly to me that they opened an ANI thread. This should be closed, all action I think is needed is for someone to slap me with a WP:TROUT as @PCHS Pirate Alumnus suggested. Koubaki user page • talk page • contributions 19:21, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
I find it borderline ridiculous that we’re at ANI for this topic again. It's almost as headache-inducing as my actual ongoing headache. OwenX has been engaging constructively with the discussion, even if we do not agree on the policy questions at hand. On the other hand, Koubaki has demonstrated an unwillingness to stop bludgeoning despite multiple warnings, and while he is certainly not alone in the bludgeoning of this discussion, I do think a formal trouting (at minimum) is in order. mdm.bla (t · c) 20:17, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Also, @Lavalizard101: you are required to notify OwenX and Koubaki on their user talk pages that you posted this discussion using {{ANI-notice}}. I won’t as I’m on mobile right now, but pinging is insufficient notice as mentioned at the top of this page. mdm.bla (t · c) 20:20, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
I even forgot to fix the curly quotes in my reply; honestly I am not a fan of mobile. mdm.bla (t · c) 20:23, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Sorry, as I said, was on a lunch break so kinda rushed for time and forgot that bit. Notified OwenX as Koubaki already has responded here. Lavalizard101 (talk) WP:SOLIDARITY 20:50, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

Propose Topic ban and temporary page block

In this comment] User:Nil Einne Suggests a topic ban for PCHS Pirate Alumnus and a limited time page block from deletion review for Koubaki until this particular deletion review is closed. I agree.

In the case of Koubaki the sheer number of comments is the problem. PCHS Pirate Alumnus has posted 10 comments so far at Wikipedia:Deletion review/Log/2026 November 8#RationalWiki and Koubaki 16. In this discussion, it's PCHS Pirate Alumnus 5 and Koubaki 7. At Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/RationalWiki (4th nomination) it was PCHS Pirate Alumnus 8 and Koubaki 39.

In the case of PCHS Pirate Alumnus the larger problem is the nature of the comments:

  • "We shouldn't be covering [RationalWiki] and giving it a search engine boost"
  • "If anyone knows how annoying the Rats [RationalWiki users] are it is me, but from experience, don't let them get to you and don't let them argue you into a WP:BLUDGEON situation. Cut off their arguments (like I've been doing) and WP:DENY/WP:DISENGAGE... The biggest challenge isn't really SPA Rats but that there are people on Wikipedia who follow the mindset of "an enemy of my enemy is my friend" and see Conservapedia as an enemy (it kind of naturally is for Wikipedia, as is Grokipedia) and therefore want to side with the Rats."
  • "[RationalWiki is] a WP:ATTACKSITE with insufficient coverage in WP:RS"
  • "[RationalWiki] is a site that was created to promote the doxing and harassment of wiki contributors, including Wikipedians (I'm not going to provide links for obvious reasons), and has expanded to doing the same to other targets, which is what landed them multiple lawsuits and almost shut the site down. Numerous people of influence on the site (some even being board members) have been banned from Wikipedia, with at least two... have been office banned for severe abuse" (Note: saying "while that in itself isn't an argument for deletion" doesn't cange the fact that it was posted as an argument for deletion)
  • "I reiterate my delete vote, per WP:WEBCRIT, WP:INHERITWEB, WP:LINKLOVE, and WP:IAR (because it interferes with building an encyclopedia, we shouldn't be pumping the search engine ranking of a site that is a haven for banned users and has encouraged harassment of Wikipedians on Wikipedia, and has in-fact brought that harassment to this very discussion, unless there is indisputable grounds for inclusion, even if there is a weak argument for inclusion)."
  • "I did not say anyone is secretly conspiring against Wikipedia (at least in relation to the AfD and subsequent review), I suggested if they are they would do so privately. We would have no way of knowing and no way of acting on it, and it's not even worth discussing other than to acknowledge the obvious in that the vote was stacked regardless of intention "
  • "The fact that people are established Wikipedians or aren't affiliated with RationalWiki =/= they are unbiased."

I would also note that User:PCHS Pirate Alumnus says "I am also member of Conservapedia (since 2009), under the username User:DMorris. Though the two wikis don't seem to get along very well, they both fascinate me. I have some administrative privileges at Conservapedia". In my opinion this constitutes a COI. (Apparently, not an opinion I am allowed to have. Also, it is the totality of the behavior that establishes the COI. Just being an admin on a wiki does not.)

  • I propose a topic ban for PCHS Pirate Alumnus from the topics of Conservapedia and RationalWiki, broadly construed, with an exception for commenting on this ANI section.
  • I propose a limited-time page block from the RationalWiki deletion review for Koubaki until it closes, with a warning that commenting 30 or 40 times in one discussion is likely to result in a block.

--Guy Macon (talk) 04:29, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

  • Support both obviously and thank you to Guy for getting in all in one place. Parabolist (talk) 04:43, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
I won't comment on my own proposed sanctions, because they are reasonable.
But to give a topic ban to only one person who has a COI with RW and not others is not in my opinion. Koubaki user page • talk page • contributions 05:40, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Please let me know who else you think has a COI. I will give them the same attention I gave PCHS Pirate Alumnus. If you don't feel comfortable publicly naming someone, send me an email. --Guy Macon (talk) 06:22, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
User:Lavalizard101 is an RW sysop. Koubaki user page • talk page • contributions 11:51, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
If it wasn't clear enough, I fully support the temporary page block sanctions against me. Koubaki user page • talk page • contributions 13:42, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Which, interestingly, is an excellent argument that the restriction will have the same effect as no restriction and that no restrictions are needed. No point in restricting someone who clearly "get it". --Guy Macon (talk) 14:21, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Support - I don’t necessarily agree that just being a Conservapedia admin creates a conflict of interest; I’m just a lurker in this matter but PCHS Pirate Alumnus has been responsible for drawing out the disagreement and relitigating decade-plus old conflicts about RationalWiki. Nivlac, 1st Viscountess Nivlac (talk) 07:37, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Agree that just being a Conservapedia (or RationalWiki) admin does not create a conflict of interest, which is why I focused on the content of PCHS Pirate Alumnus' comments. --Guy Macon (talk) 14:21, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
See my reply below. Fram (talk) 14:41, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Support calling an entire Wiki's editors "trolls" above a name the site's membership has embraced at times, unlike troll which would be an accurate but not very nice comment. sums the attitude up. This should hopefully be the last I have to say on the matter. - yes, I couldn't agree more. Black Kite (talk) 09:31, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Comment - I want this escalated to the Arbitration Committee and the trust and safety committee responsible for the office band on two RatiomalAiki admins now (before this even closes). And if they decide on a topic ban without a topic ban on at least a half dozen other editors, I’ll respect that but I don’t want the topic ban, I want my account renamed to something with no IRL connection and a full fledged (voluntary?) indef block. Because I’ve done nothing disruptive here other than transparently provide a counter to people foaming at the mouth about how “important” RatiomalWiki is; you’re free to disagree with me, that’s part of healthy discussion, but if this is the direction this community is taking, to give outright stalkers that kind of a bone because certain people don’t want to hear an alternative voice, then this is no longer a community I want to be associated with. By the way, in line with what I’ve said about barely being active on Conservapedia anymore, I’ve I’ve requested all administrative rights removed on my Conservapedia account, effectively making me exclusively a RationalWiki admin (not that I am any more active on there than Conservapedia) so please stop calling be a Conservapedia admin. Please close this discussion and take it to the ArbCom. PCHS Pirate Alumnus (talk) 11:06, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
    Just being a Conservapedia or RationalWiki admin does not establish a conflict of interest, which is why I focused on the content of your comments. I promised that I would look into any other admins from either sites, but you have to give me time; it takes a while to do a proper job of researching someone's edit history. If I see similar behavior you will see me posting about it with recommendations for sanctions if appropriate, but not in this section. Your comments above are not helping your case. This section is about your behavior. See WP:NOTTHEM. Also, if you jump right to arbcom or TaS without first filing a separate report making your case at ANI and giving the system a chance to evaluate your assertions, I absolutely guarantee that they will kick it back to ANI. --Guy Macon (talk) 14:21, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Support both - Koubaki's proposed sanction is a reasonable "shot across the bow" and should dissuade future problems. PCHS Pirate Alumnus is currently attempting to filibuster this discussion, which wasn't even about him when it was started, and accusing Lavalizard101 of sockpuppetry without evidence and calling for a BOOMERANG is only digging himself deeper. Threatening to leave the project if the RationalWiki page is restored/if ArbCom imposes a TBAN isn't productive, either. As an aside, ArbCom won't accept a case if the community (i.e. this ANI discussion) can handle the issue, and I don't see any reasons for T&S to get involved at the moment. mdm.bla (t · c) 15:11, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
I do see a COI in this topic area for Lavalizard101, and could be persuaded to support a TBAN of equal scope for him (but don't currently). mdm.bla (t · c) 15:11, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

Shouldn't we, by the same logic of COI, and the overreactions (e.g. the accusations against OwenX), also topic ban Lavalizard? They are a sysop at rationalwiki after all. Fram (talk) 11:01, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

Except my comments weren't overreactions, OwenX's comments are just in that grey area and @Black Kite: has told them to tone it down . Lavalizard101 (talk) WP:SOLIDARITY 12:00, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Yes, and OwenX agreed to tone it down a bit, which was good. The current problems I do think are limited to Koubaki (excessive bludgeoning in three discussions now) and PCHS Pirate Alumnus (I think you only really need to read the comment above for my reasoning there). Black Kite (talk) 12:17, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
And four editors or so in this thread didn't see anything ANI-worthy in them. Plus, it looks as if you hadn't even attempted to discuss the comments you opened this ANI for directly with OwenX, as required. Fram (talk) 12:18, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
I do not think that just being a Conservapedia or RationalWiki admin establishes a conflict of interest, which is why I focused on the content of PCHS Pirate Alumnus' comments. That being said, admins of other wikis should take care to avoid even an appearance of a COI when commenting about deleting that wiki's Wikipedia page. If it was me, I would express my opinion but would also add "Full disclosure: I am an admin at Wiki X" --Guy Macon (talk) 14:21, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
A COI exists because what you are, what your functions are, who you know in what capacity. The content of the comments just shows how people deal with their COI. From WP:COI: "Someone having a conflict of interest is a description of a situation, not a judgment about that person's opinions, integrity, or good faith." The stuation is "being a sysop at RationalWiki" or "being a sysop at Conservapedia", not whether they are posting in a more or less heated fashion. "A COI can exist in the absence of bias, and bias regularly exists in the absence of a COI. Beliefs and desires may lead to biased editing, but they do not constitute a COI. COI emerges from an editor's roles and relationships, and the tendency to bias that we assume exists when those roles and relationships conflict." Fram (talk) 14:39, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Fully agree. That's why I wrote "I propose a topic ban for PCHS Pirate Alumnus from the topics of Conservapedia and RationalWiki, broadly construed" and not "I propose a finding that PCHS Pirate Alumnus has a COI in the areas of Conservapedia and RationalWiki". Please don't act as if I didn't write the first 95% of my proposal and that my last "I would also note" sentence is my main argument. It isn't. --Guy Macon (talk) 15:32, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
You seem to be responding to something I didn't write. You seem to act offended because I pointed out that your position about a COI doesn't match the official guidance, but in your need to lash out pretend that I somehow opposed your proposal or disagreed with your other comments. My comments here were about Lavalizard, not about PCHS. Perhaps dial back the rhetoric somewhat? Fram (talk) 16:07, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Comment (involved) - Reporting disruptive editing at DRV to WP:ANI is seldom necessary. The regular editors there include enough admins so that an uninvolved admin will usually be able to impose a partial block or take other action if there is disruption. That dispute has been open for more than seven days and is waiting for closure., and I will wait for it to be closed or relisted. But PCHS Pirate Alumnus is in a hole and is digging. Robert McClenon (talk) 17:29, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Support badly needed, both users have been notified many times over the course of these discussions that their behavior was out of line, and it has not resulted in any change. Since they won’t restrain themselves, a non-voluntary solution is called for. --JBL (talk) 01:35, 19 November 2026 (UTC)
As I told PCHS Pirate Alumnus here, This section is about your behavior. See WP:NOTTHEM. If you jump right to arbcom without first filing a report making your case at ANI and giving the system a chance to evaluate your assertions, I absolutely guarantee that they will kick it back to ANI. --Guy Macon (talk) 03:13, 19 November 2026 (UTC)
So we can continue to discuss here and have more of the same? More of the same WP:BATTLEGROUND nonsense with 10+ vs one? That's not what these discussion boards are for and I therefore try to stay out of that. The only real reliable source pertaining to RationalWiki with serious meat to it (the LA Times article) describes the site as one that "by their own admission engages in cybervandalism," what exactly is wrong with calling that out? If one were calling Wikipedians trolls or rats, that would be WP:CIVIL. I made 8 posts to the AfD, all of which being responses to replies on my own vote, and backed off, and only replied to my own vote in the deletion review and clarified my own comments later on and stopped, how exactly is that disruptive or even WP:BLUDGEON? I have no intention of editing the deletion review further (unless somebody outright vandalizes it and I decide to revert that), so how does that even fall under the WP:Blocking policy? What policy are you even going by with this proposal, other than my opinion is the opposite of your's and you want to silence it? Although I'm not particularly important, I've made important contributions such as uncontroversially removing WP:USERGEN violations and challenging {{RationalWiki}} (which the community agreed did not need to exist) at TfD, how is stopping that from happening a net-positive for the project? I commend Fram for seeing the bigger picture but I lost confidence in this process long ago, especially considering this discussion should have been dead long ago. As I said at the ArbCom request, I don't think it's unreasonable to think, considering how contentious these discussions about RationalWiki and Conservapedia get, that barring people affiliated with those subjects is a good idea. If it would be better for the project, I would endorse that even if that means I (along with a bunch of other people), can never even mention RationalWiki or Conservapedia on Wikipedia again. But honestly, I'm at that point where one starts to lose faith in the project as a whole. I know I'm pissed off right now and it shows, I know right now it's best if I keep editing to a minimum, so please do me a favor and leave me alone. I just went to ArbCom because I've been around long enough that I know that's the next step from here and I just wanted it over with. PCHS Pirate Alumnus (talk) 03:45, 19 November 2026 (UTC)
If things are always "10+ vs one", that may be a sign that the one should step back and consider if perhaps, just maybe, the 10+ aren't the ones who are wrong. - The Bushranger One ping only 03:59, 19 November 2026 (UTC)
Well that's a logical fallacy if I ever saw one. Bandwagon effect. I'm not talking about the community as a whole (I've seen plenty of times consensus in my favor), I'm talking about people with declared connections to RationalWiki. Gee, I'm on that list, but the other 10 are usually pro-RationalWiki. PCHS Pirate Alumnus (talk) 04:02, 19 November 2026 (UTC)
Okay. But AFAICT, none of them are involved in this ANI besides you. Actually investigation further, 3 of those have not edited this year. 1 has 6 edits this year, another has 1 edit this year. Of the 5 remaining, not only did they not participate here but they didn't at the DRV, at the previous ANI, at the AFD. You're the only one to do so. There are others LavaLizard who maybe have a significant connection to but AFAICT the vast majority of people you keep arguing with and most or all of those supporting action against you do not. Even in terms of the article it self, looking at the talk page (which is where discussion over content on the article should take place), I see about 3 comments or so from those on the list going back to a significant discussion July 2023 i.e. over 3 years ago. In other words, it seems to me all these alleged problems from those with a significant connection to RW is largely in your mind or at least has been the case for over 3 years. So..... Nil Einne (talk) 05:43, 19 November 2026 (UTC)
Re "10+ vs one", PCHS Pirate Alumnus, please see WP:1AM. Seriously. I really think that page could help you if you let it. --Guy Macon (talk) 04:31, 19 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Support both proposals by Guy Macon. If Rational Wiki or the deletion review are so bad, someone else will notice and take action. The dedicated participation of these two editors increases tension and is not helping the encyclopedia. Johnuniq (talk) 04:29, 19 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Comment: I'm going to think about this, but I think I'm done over all, regardless of what happens with this discussion, rendering it moot. I'm not as active on here as I used to be because I'm too busy IRL, there's articles I've wanted to create or improve for years and never have because I've never had the time, and without any hard feelings to anyone in particular, nonsense like this is just unnecessary stress. By this time tomorrow, I'll have made my decision, and you'll know because I'll request deletion of my entire userspace. To be clear, what happens in this discussion between now and then will have no bearing in the matter. 18 years was a good run. I may stick around the Wikimedia Commons because that project is less dramatic. PCHS Pirate Alumnus (talk) 04:35, 19 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Actually, I don't want to think about this anymore and have requested Wikipedia:Courtesy vanishing. I would like to keep this separate from other WMF projects, but want this account vanished, and all of my user pages protected. I am aware that this is permanent and irreversible, and changing my mind would be sockpuppetry. Now just please leave me alone once and for all. PCHS Pirate Alumnus (talk) 05:03, 19 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Support topic-ban as proposed for PCHS. No opinion on the other bullet. PCHS, I would take the Arbitration Committee speedily-declining your hastily-written and premature argument for a case as saving you from what would at minimum be a much harder-to-appeal topic ban along the lines already proposed here and (just as likely) a possible siteban for this conspiracymongering. And before you accuse me of having an agenda here, I have not significantly edited about either Conservapedia or RationalWiki on Wikipedia. I have no opinion on the other bullet because PCHS' behaviour is the most immediately pressing here and I'm not otherwise read in on this saga enough to judge whether or not Koubaki's behaviour warrants a partblock. —Jéské Couriano v^_^v Thriller Night! 04:36, 19 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Support both however I'd also support closing this. Koubaki seems to have gotten the message & as for PCHS if they want to leave I say we just let them, even under courtesy vanishing terms. I don't think this topic ban proposal should prevent it. As for LavaLizard101, I haven't looked a great deal but perhaps opening this ANI was unnecessary. But I didn't see them anywhere as active in the combination of previous administrative thread, AFD, DRV and this ANI. And I definitely never saw LavaLizard101 keep bringing up their irrelevant disputes with any site and its contributors. (To be clear, I make no judgment about those disputes. PCHS might very well have been significantly harmed but unfortunately even if true this isn't particularly relevant to us unless you can't put that harm aside.) The fact PCHS they opened a failed ARBCOM case is IMO further proof that for whatever reason they are the primary one having problems dealing with disagreement in a productive way. Nil Einne (talk) 05:51, 19 November 2026 (UTC)
    Since it seems to matter a lot, I will say I have edited RationalWiki in the past and used to visit it a bit (I mean maybe 2-3 a month at most and not generally spending more than an hour or two probably). I believe I was even an admin or sysop or something at one stage. I say believe because I don't edit it much & one time I came back and found a message indicating I'd been made one but AFAICT I wasn't so I think it was removed. I was happy with that because at the time I still had a weak password on RW. I haven't edited it in a long time. I do agree with RW much more than Conservapedia, in fact one of the main reasons I visited RW was just to see what Conservapedia was up to which I often found funny. But that's more of a political & world view than a COI. I care much more about seeing NZ and Malaysia fairly represented here than I ever did about RationalWiki or Conservapedia, so it's a little silly to say I have a COI IMO. I make no comment on LavaLizard101 except to say IMO even if they do have a COI it's fine for them to comment within reason on the relevant threads provided their COI is declared and this is properly considered by any closer. Nil Einne (talk) 05:56, 19 November 2026 (UTC)
    I will also say I initially opened a topic ban proposal for PCHS myself in this thread. I removed this & instead added the comment above because I quickly realised I'd slightly confused Koubaki and PCHS. By slightly confused, I mean I was correct about their comments at the DRV, here etc. But I did think that this thread was about PCHS and Owen X and that some of the comments above were about PCHS for a time. But my primary concern was what I'd seen of PCHS's behaviour and not what others had said. Nil Einne (talk) 06:00, 19 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Support both proposals - PCHS Pirate Alumnus is out of control. Robert McClenon (talk) 07:51, 19 November 2026 (UTC)

The following discussion is closed. Please do not modify it. No further edits should be made to this discussion.


by Adams1985 (talk · contribs) to keep (admittedly of questionable worth) material off The Queers [] Celjski Grad (talk) 16:10, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

1 for reference. also @Celjski Grad please infrom @Adams1985 on their talk page about this report. ~2026-60846-11 (talk) 16:29, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
I have blocked them for making legal threats. This does not preclude civil discussion on the talk page over whether this info should be included, but that edit summary is a clear legal threat. – Epicgenius (talk) 16:31, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Doh, thanks. Done now. Celjski Grad (talk) 16:33, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
@Celjski Grad, given that they are already blocked for WP:NLT violations, I would say the notice is water under the bridge (they can't reply here). But giving the reported user an AN(I) notification is something to keep in mind for next time. – Epicgenius (talk) 16:37, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
The discussion above is closed. Please do not modify it. No further edits should be made to this discussion.
Hey guys, can we please keep in mind WP:DOLT before we just block and close? ​​​ Looking at the disputed text, it's sensitive BLP information cited to an op-ed written in response to a open letter, which was later (partially) walked back (though you couldn't tell from the look of our article). Similarly, the inflammatory quote was added by an IP in 2015, does not appear in the sources and I can't find am alternative source for it. User:Pyrrhic victor and User:Theeverywhereperson, who reverted this content back in under the assumption it was sourced: please read WP:BLPREMOVE and keep it in mind going forward, thanks. GreenLipstickLesbian💌🧸 02:17, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
@GreenLipstickLesbian, thanks for the heads up. My action was solely to address the fact that the editor made legal threats. The user very well may have been correct in terms of the substance of the removal. The block I applied does not prevent the removal and (if necessary) suppression of the content, which I have not looked at, and which can continue to be discussed. – Epicgenius (talk) 03:06, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
This would easily go on WP:LISTHOAXES. –LaundryPizza03 (dc̄) 01:40, 19 November 2026 (UTC)

Harassed by another user for a conflict that could easily be solved and also sweared and broke policies.

hi. i was harassed by user User:Marcus Markup for a conflict that was preventable. he also sweared at me using the f word. what had happened was that i had {{trout}} a user because i didnt understand their jokes, so another use trout slapped me back. he broke the following policies: WP:PA WP:HA and WP:DR. he also tried to silence me even when i tried to either explain or defend myself. and he specifically said this: "REMOVE IT FROM YOUR FUCKING USER PAGE". this user has to be permamently banned immediately and his ip address should be blocked immediately, its a personal attack. worse, this dispute could easily be solved. i am innocent here, he escalated it. thanks. N4tivefr0mgh4na (talk) 17:10, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

No, this is not a personal attack, nor harassment, but it's a little uncivil. This is also not appropriate for ANI. It also definitely doesn't deserve a cban, or even a block. Please warn the user. Jako96 (talk) 17:30, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Since they failed to notify the user I have done so for them. BrandNewSaint (talk) 17:33, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Reviewing User_talk:Marcus_Markup#didnt_work_so_a_second_trout_has_been_served._i_dont_want_to_go_to_war and the surrounding context, I'm more concerned with N4tivefr0mgh4na's conduct here. But overall this is still all extremely minor. Please disengage before this escalates to something beyond a minor nuisance. signed, Rosguill talk 17:32, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Agreed. Jako96 (talk) 17:38, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Also please notify the user you reported after reporting, as THIS page says. Thank you. Jako96 (talk) 17:34, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
the user said they will get me temporary banned if i posted on their talk page. so i think notifying them counts to them, as to why i didnt do it. N4tivefr0mgh4na (talk) 17:37, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
You can still inform in a discussion they're in. Jako96 (talk) 17:39, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
wait - i forgot - i said to them i will report them and get them permanetly banned. N4tivefr0mgh4na (talk) 17:46, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Also, you're the one harassing here, for your information. See WP:USERTALKSTOP. Marcus told you to "NOT POST HERE AGAIN" (their talk page), therefore you should stop posting in their talk page. Doing this could be seen as harassment, and you did that several times. Jako96 (talk) 17:36, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
i had to remind of policies. i will stop posting. thank you. N4tivefr0mgh4na (talk) 17:38, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

After being given a level 4 warning on November 12 for disruptive editing on their talk page for violating WP:OVERLINK, user @~2026-56576-82 proceeded to ignore that warning on November 16, when they violated the rule by adding unnecessary overlinks as seen on this diff on the 2026 film Ebenezer. As this happened after their final warning, I'd suggest blocking them indefinitely. NarutoSan6000 (talk) 03:56, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

I've also notified the user after reporting. NarutoSan6000 (talk) 04:07, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
This is a temporary account with only 20 edits that has never edited a talk page. Is there any evidence that they have read the warnings? The Manual of Style is a guideline, not a policy. Is there any precedent for an indefinite block for a handful of MOS violations? I am also concerned, NarutoSan6000, that you began your notification with the highly sarcastic "Congratulations!" Why did you do that? Cullen328 (talk) 06:03, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
All their edits are also tagged as "Mobile Edit" so there's a good chance that they can't hear you ~2026-54957-04 (talk) 08:09, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
I was just irritated at them because they had been warned multiple times yet persisted in their disruption. I apologize for doing so. NarutoSan6000 (talk) 08:25, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Alright, I edited it to remove the sarcasm. NarutoSan6000 (talk) 21:30, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

Talk Page block requested

The following discussion is closed. Please do not modify it. No further edits should be made to this discussion.


~2026-60993-58 (talk · contribs · deleted contribs · nuke contribs · logs · filter log · block user · block log) - blocked account is triggering and filling the filter log by spamming home page, needs Talk Page block as well. SuperFastSpellChecker (talk) 14:53, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

@SuperFastSpellChecker Admins said they will let it happen, they just want attention. Beyhive Navy (talk) 14:57, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
I understand the attention-seeking but it renders the filter log unreadable. We can't see what is happening behind the noise. SuperFastSpellChecker (talk) 15:00, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
 Done. Black Kite (talk) 14:59, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Thanks, I thought I remembered seeing a more appropriate place to make this request but I couldn't find it. SuperFastSpellChecker (talk) 15:03, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
That would be at WP:AIV. I haven't seen any there personally yet, but apparently they are accepting TPA revocation requests now. 🎮 Gommeh sign - talk 18:01, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Yes, I tried a standard report at AIV and the bot removed it because the TA was already previously blocked. I thought there was a new section where that wouldn't happen but failed to find it. SuperFastSpellChecker (talk) 18:05, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
From the header:
  • If the user is abusing their talk page access, even if already blocked, you can ask that it be revoked using {{Vandal|tpa=yes}}.
~ ONUnicorn(Talk|Contribs)problem solving 18:25, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
The discussion above is closed. Please do not modify it. No further edits should be made to this discussion.

Conduct review request: JohnWhite007 (repeatedly adding unsourced content, CIR)

JohnWhite007 came to my attention through my watchlisting of Loving v. Virginia. They have, over the last several months, repeatedly added unsourced and generally unhelpful content to the article, which has each time been reverted by me and other editors. A look at their contributions indicates a similar pattern of editing in other articles. Their talk page consists almost only of warnings for similar conduct, all but one without a reply. They generally do not engage in talk page discussion, and when they do, their three (in total) talk page edits are cryptic, ungrammatical and not reflective of an understanding of the problem.

It seems to me that they are well-intentioned, but lack the skills required to competently contribute to Wikipedia. I invite discussion as to whether any sanctions are appropriate.

I am pinging editors who have recently interacted with JohnWhite007 through reverts or talk page messages to obtain their input: @Celjski Grad, Dingolover6969, Medusahead, TonySt, Adakiko, RadioactOlive, Nentricks, Strongshorts, and Deltaspace42:. Sandstein 15:22, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

Yes, their edits to this article have been confusing, with multiple levels of vague attributions such as "cited as a decision granting protection from interracial marriage", or a citation of a decision as quoted in a book. Celjski Grad (talk) 15:45, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
I have citations including from the university of Maine. I will provide them. But the living case itself is the greatest citation. Earl warren wrote the primary holding on the bottom of the case “Under our Constitution, the freedom to marry or not marry, a person of another race resides with the individual and cannot be infringed by the State.” This is directly from the case itself along with the references to Maryland Nevada Nebraska and Indiana.
I also have some articles from the university of Maine which were recently published. Perhaps you would be so kind as to help me add citations then ? The university of Maine articles seem very good. JohnWhite007 (talk) 15:57, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
somthing somtihng WP:BURDEN says "The burden to demonstrate verifiability lies with the editor who adds or restores material". if you have a source then include it in the edit / edit summery before publishing. ~2026-60846-11 (talk) 16:02, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
User continues to add unsourced quotes and content. I was about to AIV but noticed this ANI. Their talk page is full of links to policy and reliable sources pages which do instruct how to add sources. ☾Loriendrew☽ ☏(ring-ring) 16:02, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
“As for the various statements directly concerning the Fourteenth Amendment, we have said in connection with a related problem that, although these historical sources "cast some light" they are not sufficient to resolve the problem;
"[a]t best, they are inconclusive. “
https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/388/1/ JohnWhite007 (talk) 16:23, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
intermarriage prohibited; meaning of term 'white persons.' -- It shall hereafter be unlawful for any white person in this State to marry any save a white person, or a person with no other admixture of blood than white and American Indian. For the purpose of this chapter, the term 'white person' shall apply only to such person as has no trace whatever of any blood other than Caucasian; but persons who have one-sixteenth or less of the blood of the American Indian and have no other non-Caucasic blood shall be deemed to be white persons. All laws heretofore passed and now in effect regarding the intermarriage of white and colored persons shall apply to marriages prohibited by this chapter."
Va.Code Ann. § 20-54 (1960 Repl. Vol.).
The exception for persons with less than one-sixteenth "of the blood of the American Indian" is apparently accounted for,
“Under our Constitution, the freedom to marry, or not marry, a person of another race resides with the individual, and cannot be infringed by the State.”
https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/388/1/ JohnWhite007 (talk) 16:29, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
User continued to add unsourced quotes despite this AIN, requested a short article space block at AIV while this discussion proceeds. ☾Loriendrew☽ ☏(ring-ring) 16:24, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Perhaps a p-block on that article, allowing JohnWhite007 to make edit requests on the article talk page? Schazjmd (talk) 16:32, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
I gave sources JohnWhite007 (talk) 16:32, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
The living case itself is the source. But I can also reference other cases aswell. JohnWhite007 (talk) 16:34, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
The 'living case' is a primary source. - The Bushranger One ping only 20:26, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Isn’t the loving case itself with historical background not the best citation ? JohnWhite007 (talk) 16:36, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
I agree with your assessment that he is well-intentioned and simply needs to acquire the skills to competently contribute to Wikipedia. Unfortunately, I do not believe in skill acquisition, so I feel the situation is unlikely to improve. Dingolover6969 (talk) 19:22, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

Blocked 24 hours for edit warring on Loving. --SarekOfVulcan (talk) 16:39, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

Long-term vandalism, inserting the name Dr.VonFiend

Someone has been falsely inserting the stage name Dr. VonFiend into multiple articles, going back more than a year.

In 2009 a username was registered to Dr.VonFiend. I don't have access to the deleted edits made under that name. Some IPs from Maryland were involved in mid-2025.

Can we get a block on the recent TAs? And the underlying internet pathway if it seems a good idea. Should we consider a filter for this person? Binksternet (talk) 18:46, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

AndyTheGrump again

The following discussion is closed. Please do not modify it. No further edits should be made to this discussion.


"And who the fuck are you to pontificate on 'reality'? If you want to be a patronising jerk, start a blog somewhere."

--Guy Macon (talk) 19:46, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

He redacted 2 minutes before you posted here. GiantSnowman 19:48, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Partially redacted. Took out the jerk, left in the patronizing. Which I would not have reported, so consider this withdrawn.
Sigh. If you post quick, you make mistakes. If you take time and use the show preview, you end up responding to the situation as it existed several minutes previously.   ¯\_(ツ)_/¯   --Guy Macon (talk) 19:59, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
To err is human. Or rather it was. These days, we've automated the process. Anyway, apologies for the language - it was unnecessary to get the point across. It was patronising, and did absolutely nothing to aid discussion. AndyTheGrump (talk) 20:05, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
The discussion above is closed. Please do not modify it. No further edits should be made to this discussion.

Stavru: WP:NOTHERE part 2

The following discussion is closed. Please do not modify it. No further edits should be made to this discussion.


Stavru (talk · contribs · deleted contribs · logs · filter log · block user · block log)

Previous discussion:Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/IncidentArchive1226#Stavru: Edit warring, NOTHERE, the issues were synthing and blanking in service of culture war, some key issues:

  • previous list of SYNTH by Stavru in service of preferred slant
  • Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/IncidentArchive1226#c-Stavru-20260613214900-Malgosha-20260613214100Stavru, then next day they are editwarring on the trillionaire article to elevate Elon Musk . the day after they state they were less informed and less well thought I used to be on this I'll not lie to hide my past. But now I am interested in actual improvements in articles and based on conseusus and following the Wikipedia's rules, I am willing to change. I don't have these intentions anymore, I want to be here in good faith.

User has been pushing for culture war edits non-stop. Out of a total of 51 edits in article space, 42 are reverted . Rest of 100 are talk page or ANI.

  • Since the initial report, they pushed critical race theory article in now reverted edits to discredit sourced facts about CRT
  • WP:BLUDGEONing and debating editors to get their way
  • when pressed, they revert to WP:RGW mentality here I agree under normal circumstances, but the sources presented are absolutely and clearly ideologically charged and not truly academically neutral even if they are written by scholars (because some scholars are indeed very ideologically charged).
  • WP:ASPERSION on admin when given advice your language is ideologically biased, checking your user page I see a lot of socially left, Feminist leaning
  • edit warring for talk page header. When pressed, they state It is misinformation using Feminist sources in that manner because they shouldn't be on the article the begin with
  • More RGW This is literally the whole point ! following what you deem "policy" doesnt imrpove the article (as you said),, it destroys it ! That's the whole issue and why i'm here, it herms the article, there is zero imrpovment whatsoever .

Criticism is generally treated with a feigned defference, and empty promise to do better, then continuing behavior.
Either way, they are wasting significant editor time. User:Bluethricecreamman (Talk·Contribs) 01:00, 19 November 2026 (UTC)

Proposal: WP:CBAN

As this essentially is continuation of behavior from a previous ANI thread, one where essentially all participants agreed the behavior was at fault, I will start off with some proposals. User:Bluethricecreamman (Talk·Contribs) 01:13, 19 November 2026 (UTC)

  • Weak support - I don't like this one to be honest, but a 0RR restriction only stops the edit warring, not the talk page bludgeoning and debate-foruming. If there is a way to engineer a TBAN that makes sense, I'd much prefer that. Either way, Stavru's sum contribution to the project has been editwarring, ANI threads, talk page dumpster fire starting, etc. User:Bluethricecreamman (Talk·Contribs) 01:13, 19 November 2026 (UTC)
    Am I not allowed to share my opinions ? Sorry if I insulted anyone but I'm here in good faith, I didn't spam nor vandalise, I shared my concerns on talk page and had a dialogue. I am sorry, if I did a direct violation let me know instead of silencing me. Thank you. Stavru (talk) 01:26, 19 November 2026 (UTC)
  • ? Has this user been the subject of any previous sanctions? Their block log appears to be clear. Going straight for the WP version of capital punishment w/o any intervening history of sanctions/editing restrictions seems a bit extreme. -Ad Orientem (talk) 01:25, 19 November 2026 (UTC)
    Hi, I'm Stavru, the affair is that I used the talk page to adress my concern and did dialogue with the people who responded on me.
    If I did a direct violation, tell me what I did, I apologize if I did anything to anyone, instead of punishment and I'm willing to learn, as I'm here in good faith. Stavru (talk) 01:29, 19 November 2026 (UTC)
    I don't like it either; in hindsight it is def more than a bit extreme. I thought it was only somewhat defensible as Stavru's contributions are only in culture war areas, as either talk page comments or article space synth that seems to mostly be uniformly reverted. User:Bluethricecreamman (Talk·Contribs) 01:33, 19 November 2026 (UTC)

Proposal 2: WP:0RR and stern warning to stop WP:FORUMing

Yeah, ad orientem is right, but I do believe some sanction is needed. How about this.User:Bluethricecreamman (Talk·Contribs) 01:37, 19 November 2026 (UTC)

  • Strong support - Ok, a final warning to stop with the foruming and bludgeoning, and the 0RR on top so that they cannot revert back their changes if others object. As shown above, they were doing this again wrt synth they inserted into CRT, synth during their Trillionaire edits, and wrt sourcing in the talk page header on top of Men's Right Movement. This is better as it's not punitive. I think 0RR definitely would help as it would require Stavru to learn to build consensus to be effectual, instead of relying on debating and foruming talk page and edit summaries. User:Bluethricecreamman (Talk·Contribs) 01:36, 19 November 2026 (UTC)
    Respectfully, I don't think a restriction is fair, a warning is fair, because it assumes my prespective is of less value than the rest of editors, fror the same reason an editor can revert so should I because were equal.
    As I said, most importantly I act in good faith, I want dialogue and that's why I use the talk page and I don't intend to edit articles without using talk page first. Stavru (talk) 01:41, 19 November 2026 (UTC)
    I know to build consensus, that's why I use the talk page on the MRA article, I just know what you attempt me to teach.

Also opposing debate in the talk page is just wrong, if there an issue, or something irrational in a page, we must "debate it" ill say better discuss it in good faith to resolve it and improve the article, I don't attack anyone, but I will adress my concerns peacefully when needed. Stavru (talk) 01:46, 19 November 2026 (UTC)

No, I'm entirely honest, I don't believe sanction is fair, as it isn't for the majority of editors, I've exmplained why based on who I am and my overall view. Stavru (talk) 01:45, 19 November 2026 (UTC)
@Stavru Please read WP:FORUM. Wikipedia is an encyclopedia, not an internet debate site. It is edited by hundreds of thousands of users with diverse viewpoints on many contentious topics. We cannot debate the subjects we are writing about. The project would grind to a halt and be paralyzed by acrimonious arguments. We confine ourselves to repeating what has been reported in reliable sources without putting our own slant on things. Editing hot button topics requires us to check our own prejudices at the door. Talk pages exist solely to discuss ways of improving an article consistent with WP:Policies and guidelines. Please also review related community polices/guidelines including WP:NPOV, WP:AGENDA, WP:NOT TRUTH, and WP:SYNT. I strongly advise you to avoid injecting or lobbying for your personal beliefs. You have been warned about this previously. If this continues, you are going to be subject to some form of editing restrictions or sanctions. Assuming you manage to escape sanctions this time, this comment should be understood as a Final Warning. Best regards... -Ad Orientem (talk) 02:10, 19 November 2026 (UTC)
Thank you for your decision, I'll read it and act on the best of standards and dignity. Stavru (talk) 02:13, 19 November 2026 (UTC)
Given that even now, Stavru is once again on the soapbox at Talk:Men's rights movement, something clearly needs to be done. I'm not sure how a 'stern warning to stop WP:FORUMing' would work with someone who seems unable to recognise they are engaging in it, but I suppose we could try. AndyTheGrump (talk) 02:12, 19 November 2026 (UTC)
Please, can you not make assumptions about me like you know me ? Thank you.
I've understood my mistakes, I'm not dumb, I've finally learned, if I prove myself wrong, this is my final chance anyway. Stavru (talk) 02:18, 19 November 2026 (UTC)
@Stavru You are now driving a car with no spare tires. Proceed with extreme caution. If it becomes necessary to address these issues again, my most likely course of action will be to simply topic ban you from modern American politics including all culture war subjects, until I am satisfied you understand and are willing/able to abide by the rules that the community put in place for WP:Contentious topics. -Ad Orientem (talk) 02:27, 19 November 2026 (UTC)
The discussion above is closed. Please do not modify it. No further edits should be made to this discussion.