Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Noticeboard

Welcome — ask about reliability of sources in context!

Before posting, check the archives and list of perennial sources for prior discussions. Context is important: supply the source, the article it is used in, and the claim it supports.

(Sections older than 5 days are archived by Lowercase sigmabot III.)

List of archives
, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9
10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19
20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29
30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39
40, 41, 42, 43, 44, 45, 46, 47, 48, 49
50, 51, 52, 53, 54, 55, 56, 57, 58, 59
60, 61, 62, 63, 64, 65, 66, 67, 68, 69
70, 71, 72, 73, 74, 75, 76, 77, 78, 79
80, 81, 82, 83, 84, 85, 86, 87, 88, 89
90, 91, 92, 93, 94, 95, 96, 97, 98, 99
100, 101, 102, 103, 104, 105, 106, 107, 108, 109
110, 111, 112, 113, 114, 115, 116, 117, 118, 119
120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 125, 126, 127, 128, 129
130, 131, 132, 133, 134, 135, 136, 137, 138, 139
140, 141, 142, 143, 144, 145, 146, 147, 148, 149
150, 151, 152, 153, 154, 155, 156, 157, 158, 159
160, 161, 162, 163, 164, 165, 166, 167, 168, 169
170, 171, 172, 173, 174, 175, 176, 177, 178, 179
180, 181, 182, 183, 184, 185, 186, 187, 188, 189
190, 191, 192, 193, 194, 195, 196, 197, 198, 199
200, 201, 202, 203, 204, 205, 206, 207, 208, 209
210, 211, 212, 213, 214, 215, 216, 217, 218, 219
220, 221, 222, 223, 224, 225, 226, 227, 228, 229
230, 231, 232, 233, 234, 235, 236, 237, 238, 239
240, 241, 242, 243, 244, 245, 246, 247, 248, 249
250, 251, 252, 253, 254, 255, 256, 257, 258, 259
260, 261, 262, 263, 264, 265, 266, 267, 268, 269
270, 271, 272, 273, 274, 275, 276, 277, 278, 279
280, 281, 282, 283, 284, 285, 286, 287, 288, 289
290, 291, 292, 293, 294, 295, 296, 297, 298, 299
300, 301, 302, 303, 304, 305, 306, 307, 308, 309
310, 311, 312, 313, 314, 315, 316, 317, 318, 319
320, 321, 322, 323, 324, 325, 326, 327, 328, 329
330, 331, 332, 333, 334, 335, 336, 337, 338, 339
340, 341, 342, 343, 344, 345, 346, 347, 348, 349
350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 355, 356, 357, 358, 359
360, 361, 362, 363, 364, 365, 366, 367, 368, 369
370, 371, 372, 373, 374, 375, 376, 377, 378, 379
380, 381, 382, 383, 384, 385, 386, 387, 388, 389
390, 391, 392, 393, 394, 395, 396, 397, 398, 399
400, 401, 402, 403, 404, 405, 406, 407, 408, 409
410, 411, 412, 413, 414, 415, 416, 417, 418, 419
420, 421, 422, 423, 424, 425, 426, 427, 428, 429
430, 431, 432, 433, 434, 435, 436, 437, 438, 439
440, 441, 442, 443, 444, 445, 446, 447, 448, 449
450, 451, 452, 453, 454, 455, 456, 457, 458, 459
460, 461, 462, 463, 464, 465, 466, 467, 468, 469
470, 471, 472, 473, 474, 475, 476, 477, 478, 479
480, 481, 482, 483, 484, 485, 486, 487, 488, 489
490, 491, 492, 493, 494, 495, 496, 497, 498, 499
500, 501, 502, 503, 504, 505, 506, 507, 508, 509
510, 511, 512, 513, 514, 515, 516, 517, 518, 519
520, 521, 522, 523, 524, 525, 526, 527, 528

Additional notes:

  • RfCs for deprecation, blacklisting, or other classification should not be opened unless the source is widely used and has been repeatedly discussed. Consensus is assessed based on the weight of policy-based arguments.
  • While the consensus of several editors can generally be relied upon, answers are not policy.
  • This page is not a forum for general discussions unrelated to the reliability of sources.
Start a new discussion


Request for comment on the BBC

The following discussion is an archived record of a request for comment. Please do not modify it. No further edits should be made to this discussion. A summary of the conclusions reached follows.
Withdraw request for comment because the community seems inclined towards a snow close and to keep the BBC as generally reliable. Sorry for any disruption this RfC may have caused. In solidarity, Brynn Who Likes Editing | talk w/ me! 07:29, 18 October 2026 (UTC)

Given that the last RSN about the outlet was nearly a year ago, I think this is an appropriate RfC opening. Does the digital editing to remove "Protect the Dolls" on Bethany Antonia's shirt have ramifications on the source's reliability? In solidarity, Brynn Who Likes Editing | talk w/ me! 20:36, 17 October 2026 (UTC)

Comment As of now, the BBC is rated as generally reliable. Also, here's what reliable sources say on the recent controversy.
  • Savage, Michael (2026-10-12). "BBC defends editing out trans rights slogan on Strictly contestant's T-shirt". The Guardian. Retrieved 2026-10-17.
  • Kanter, Jake (2026-10-12). "BBC Blurs Bethany Antonia Trans T-Shirt On 'Strictly Come Dancing'". Deadline. Retrieved 2026-10-17.
  • "BBC Censors Bethany Antonia's "Protect The Dolls" Shirt on 'Strictly Come Dancing' | Them". www.them.us. Retrieved 2026-10-17.
  • "BBC responds after censoring Strictly star's t-shirt with pro-trans slogan". The Independent. 2026-10-12. Retrieved 2026-10-17.
  • Jeffrys, Tom (2026-10-12). "Trans activists criticise BBC over Strictly 'censorship'". The Telegraph. Retrieved 2026-10-17.
  • Griffin, Louise. "BBC responds after Strictly edits out "Protect the Dolls' T-shirt | Radio Times". www.radiotimes.com. Retrieved 2026-10-17.
  • Shanfeld, Ethan (2026-10-12). "BBC Blurs Trans Rights T-Shirt on 'Strictly Come Dancing' but Says It's 'Standard Practice' to Cut 'Overt Branding or Slogans'". Variety. Retrieved 2026-10-17.
In solidarity, Brynn Who Likes Editing | talk w/ me! 20:39, 17 October 2026 (UTC)
Given that this appears to relate to an incident of censorship on Strictly Come Dancing, which is not a news show or an RS in any way, I’m not seeing why this would affect the reliability of BBC News signed, Rosguill talk 20:43, 17 October 2026 (UTC)
I still think this may have ramifications on the BBC as a parent company, which may reflect on its subsidiaries. The BBC claimed the removal was because it stringently removes any slogans or branding, but critics and activists view this as reflecting a broader bias against trans people. Also, in this video, contestants were wearing non-political slogans such as "like it's hard" and "love is the best ingredient" but that wasn't digitally edited out. If an RfC isn't appropriate, I can remove the tag. It's 11:50 pm for me and I'm tired. In solidarity, Brynn Who Likes Editing | talk w/ me! 20:50, 17 October 2026 (UTC)
I'm not sure how blurring out part of an image would ever impact reliability because whether an org is reliable is based on factual accuracy. How does blurring out a shirt impact accuracy? It could insinuate bias but enwiki accepts that sources will be biased.
However, Rosguill's point about BBC news vs entertainment is a very good one. A US example would be ABC's American Idol blurring a political slogan - is it reasonable to think that a decision on American Idol impacts the reliability and neutrality of ABC News? I wouldn't think so. PositivelyUncertain (talk) 22:08, 17 October 2026 (UTC)
Snow close generally reliable the controversy occurred on a reality tv show from my understanding, we need to see issue with news org portion of the business, not this. User:Bluethricecreamman (Talk·Contribs) 22:10, 17 October 2026 (UTC)
Snow close generally reliable (summoned by bot) How exactly is reliability affected by banning commercial or political slogans from being displayed (whether pro-trans, pro-Palestine, pro-Ukraine, pro-abortion or pro-vegetarian) on popular TV programmes? Have any facts been mis-reported?Pincrete (talk) 05:40, 18 October 2026 (UTC)
The discussion above is closed. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page. No further edits should be made to this discussion.

RfC: Reliability of Sacnilk

What is the reliability of Sacnilk as a source for Indian box-office reporting?

Tonyy Starkk (talk) 16:50, 5 November 2026 (UTC)

Previous discussions:

Survey (Sacnilk)

  • Option 1: Generally reliable in its areas of expertise (Indian box-office reporting) - I support Option 1 for Sacnilk's box-office reporting for the following reasons:
    • First there was a short discussion in 2022, in which Sacnilk was added to the list of unreliable sources because of lack of transparency. However, now the source currently has transparent details - box-office methodology, sources and estimation, editorial policy, corrections policy, glossary, team.
    • Then I want to talk about its accuracy in reporting, I have been editing box-office related content for quite some time and Sacnilk has been accurately reporting box-office figures across all major industries in India. I have compiled a large table, showing movies across industries in India and its accuracy, which I personally think is an important factor to consider.
    • Also wanted to add that the existing reliable sources in WP:ICTFSOURCES, almost all the sources in this table have referenced and used Sacnilk's report, i can give you n number of examples of reliable sources citing Sacnilk - India Today, The Hindu, Hindustan Times, News18, Outlook, Economic Times, Indian Express, NDTV, etc and many more. Here note that all these sources in WP:ICTFSOURCES are secondary sources and not box office trackers. Almost all sources have consistently referenced Sacnilk tracker for its box-office reporting.
    • Finally wanted to mention on coverage, currently Bollywood Hungama tracker is being consistently reporting Hindi language films (Bollywood industry), and in Hollywood industry we use Box Office Mojo and The Numbers trackers. But there is not a single reliable tracker which covers all languages and industries in India, which is where Sacnilk covers all industries and languages and can be used as a consistent source (like how Mojo, Numbers, Hungama are used), rather than depending on secondary reliable sources. Refer for how the current reporting looks like.

These are the reasons why I support Option 1. Tonyy Starkk (talk) 16:50, 5 November 2026 (UTC)

  • @Tonyy Starkk going through some of linked discussions, I came across WT:ICTF#Reassessment of Sacnilk.com from September. Just to confirm, you emailed Sacnik to inquire about their methodology and editorial oversight. Prior to that, their website did not have that information (archive from January). They responded and you provided them examples of what you were looking for. They updated their website to include pages about the editorial team, policies and methodologies you link to above. Is that correct? S0091 (talk) 20:13, 7 November 2026 (UTC)
    S0091, yes I did email them for transparency and they later published these details. Tonyy Starkk (talk) 02:51, 8 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Option 5 Box office returns should be seen as generally undue inclusion in most articles and under most circumstances. As such this is a bit of a moot point. Simonm223 (talk) 17:04, 5 November 2026 (UTC)
The methodology, sources and estimation and editorial pages have been added to Sacnilk with content in them. However, I really wish they are not just for show and are actually being enforced. Babin Mew (talk) 17:14, 5 November 2026 (UTC)
The methodology section is vague to the point of uselessness. Simonm223 (talk) 17:21, 5 November 2026 (UTC)
The other sources currently considered "reliable" really aren't any better. Unless someone can find out more about the actual methodology I think they either need to all be accepted or all tossed out. The problem is that trying to police the topic area is nigh impossible, so unless it's all placed under ECR there's no blocking box office insertions. Even trying to limit them to accepted sources is pretty much futile at the moment. ChompyTheGogoat [ Bleat | Munched ] 23:32, 5 November 2026 (UTC)
If you look at my !vote (and my statements in the prior RfC) I don't think we should be including box office figures on most movie pages (not limited to Indian cinema) because I think it's generally WP:TRIVIA. In the case where box office returns are actually notable (such as record-setting successes and significant commercial failures) there should be a preponderance of reliable sources that are not box office tracking websites to draw from. I am looking at this and saying it's insufficient. You say that's the state of the industry. I say we agree. Simonm223 (talk) 14:16, 6 November 2026 (UTC)
Have fun trying to keep them out. Without topic wide ECR it's hopeless. ChompyTheGogoat [ Bleat | Munched ] 23:29, 6 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Going with Option 1: Generally reliable for reasons I've given in previous discussions. 4Pas (talk) 07:32, 6 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Option 3 I see no reason to treat their figures as reliable. They often come off as truly exceptional claims. Koshuri (あ!) 15:14, 8 November 2026 (UTC)
    I dont quite understand what you mean by "exceptional claims", can you explain a bit more? Tonyy Starkk (talk) 16:19, 8 November 2026 (UTC)
    Take a look at their figures for Ramayana: Part 1. here. Do you find them accurate and how? Let me know your views, I am totally open minded to change my !vote. Koshuri (あ!) 04:26, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
    Lets compare them with Bollywood Hungama which is currently being used as a RS - Bollywood Hungama vs Sacnilk.
    Worldwide gross - 507.20cr and 515.5cr (almost close)
    India gross - 285.20cr and 299.76cr (almost close)
    India net - 238.85cr and 248.80cr (almost close)
    So all are in the same range with marginal difference and keep changing over time because its gets updating on daily/hourly basis. These are the numbers now but they keep changing as mentioned.
    Also please do check my table in large-table where i have tabulated the box office of films across industries and their accuracy. There are 15 major films which I have recorded and all of them seem to be accurate. Tonyy Starkk (talk) 05:07, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
    I support option 2 after this discussion. Koshuri (あ!) 05:20, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Option 3 They have no editorial oversight per their "editorial team". Both the profiles of Sunit Jangir and Christa Lincy described them "Senior Editors" but they also are also the Writers and Box Office Analysts. That violates segregation of duties/independence which is one of purposes of having an editor. An editor is a separate role whose responsibilities are fact-checking, setting/ensuring staff follow policies, copy editing--i.e. oversight.. Looking around the site, most of the content is written by Jangir and Lincy so mostly a two-person show who oversee themselves. I did come across Jitu Jangir, another "Senior Editor covering wrestling. It is also troubling Sacnilk did not have a stated "editorial team", policies, etc. prior to being contacted by an editor here. S0091 (talk) 16:35, 8 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Option 1 (i.e. generally reliable) As someone who regularly goes through box office of the films of Hindi cinema, my experience with Sacnilk is at par with Bollywood Hungama, the ideal source per WP: ICTFSOURCES. Honeybrowneyes (talk) 06:24, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Option 2: Per their about page. However, information attributed to Sacnilk should not be treated as definitive but as claims. Eg: "According to Sacnilk" or "Sacnilk claimed". Kailash29792 (talk) 06:39, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
    @Kailash29792 can you clarify a bit? It unclear what you mean by "per their about page". What is about their about page ;) that gets to marginally reliable rather than reliable or unreliable? Thanks! S0091 (talk) 15:04, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
    Yeah sorry about that. A site without an about us should not even be considered. But Sacnilk has, and they've been active for almost 10 years. That's why I went for option 2. Kailash29792 (talk) 15:18, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
    Thanks, that's helpful. I will also note that at least since October 2018 they have had an about page which remained the same (January this year) until recently, A little different than the one now as it does not mention Box Office numbers but they were providing them back in 2018. S0091 (talk) 15:50, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Going with Option 2 for now, given my concerns for the level of enforcements of the policies and their pages added after the email correspondence. Though I am concerned that if Sacnilk is approved as "marginally reliable", it may cause problems when cited in pages, such as The Times of India, which is considered marginally reliable (WP:ICTFSOURCES) and advised to not be included for box office figures. Babin Mew (talk) 06:55, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Option 2, with a caveat. I had commented on the original discussion. While Sacnilk's figures are generally considered reliable outside Wikipedia and often corroborate figures reported by other sources, the website itself cannot be placed in the same league as Box Office Mojo, comScore, The Numbers or even Bollywood Hungama. It does not currently have a Wikipedia article, which suggests it has yet to establish notability here. There is also a potential risk of "circular notability": someone could later create a Wikipedia article about Sacnilk, arguing that it has been deemed reliable by Wikipedia, when notability should come organically. I would therefore avoid citing Sacnilk directly and use reliable secondary sources that cite it instead. Where better sources exist, they should always be preferred.--Teegarden's Star b (talk) 10:29, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
    Additional clarification: When I said "generally considered reliable outside Wikipedia", I meant it is widely cited in the social media and sometimes mainstream media as well. Please note that it is just my personal observation and I have not critically analysed the reliability. Indian box office numbers are highly disputed and inconsistent--Teegarden's Star b (talk) 15:17, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
    @Teegarden's Star b whether a publication has an article/is notable or not has nothing to do with being a reliable source. For example, Daily Mail is a notable publication but is deprecated on Wikipedia. Keep in mind if someone says because a publication.has a Wikipedia article, it is RS. That's not a valid argument. S0091 (talk) 15:13, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
    S0091: A publication is not necessarily reliable just because it has a Wikipedia article, and if it does not even have a Wikipedia article, the situation is even worse. It simply means it has not yet demonstrated notability as per Wikipedia standards, and may not be considered reliable here. In such a case, a better source is always preferred. Indian box office numbers are highly disputed and inconsistent.--Teegarden's Star b (talk) 15:06, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
    Not having an article does not prove something is non-notable. It just means no one has written an article yet. ChompyTheGogoat [ Bleat | Munched ] 06:48, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
    @Teegarden's Star b what makes you say Bollywood Hungama with the same league of Box Office Mojo, comScore, The Numbers. If you see WP:ICTFSOURCES, I dont find its reliability consensus. Also if you look the the website , I could not find its box-office methodology, editorial team, or any relevent policies. Its a seperate discussion in itself but since you mentioned them I had to bring this question up. Tonyy Starkk (talk) 15:20, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
    Tonyy Starkk: That's WP:OTHERSTUFFEXISTS. The credibility of Sacnilk should be independently determined. It may or may not be credible, I'm not saying it is not. But it is unusual to cite a website which has not yet demonstrated notabilty at the first place. This will leads to the creation of an article using "circular notabilty".--Teegarden's Star b (talk) 15:06, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Option 1 if not at least Option 2 - since most of the reliable sources have started quoting Sacnilk Kataariveera (talk) 17:34, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
See WP:FRUIT, if even the most reliable news source cites an unreliable site as its source, then that news article is unreliable. The reliability of Sacnilk is yet to be determined. Many articles getting their source from a specific source does not make it reliable. Babin Mew (talk) 17:39, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Option 1 or 2: per this. Vestrian24Bio 02:43, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Option 2: per Tonyy Starkk argument that Sacnilk figures do not widely vary from other reliable sources related to Indian BO. Publication of methodology and editorial policy does give some confidence. There is no perfect source for Indian BO, so the more, the merrier, and I'd consider Sacnilk one source which can be considered given the track record. -- Ab207 (talk) 16:33, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Option 3: I have already given my reasoning at the Reassessment of Sacnilk.com but again briefly I will say that the fact that an editor from Wikipedia had to send them an email and give them information on how to gain reliability status on Wikipedia and then for them to go-ahead and add/create pages based on the email, it made it obvious to me that their primary goal is likely to get prestige and visibility that comes with being a Wikipedia approved benchmark by getting a reliability status that will help with strong drive for digital authority, search engine visibility, and public relations validation. And just because its figures do not widely vary from other reliable sources, does not give it a pass to be considered reliable. Its better to just use sources that are actually considered reliable. RangersRus (talk) 18:35, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
    Yes i agree that it could be one possibility but there could be another possibility as well right?? that they took my feedback into consideration and acted upon it with good faith. I totally agree that the changes came in after my email to them but i just see it that way. I felt the source was reasonably accurate, so i thought of reaching out to them. Anyway just wanted to put that possibility out there as well and leave it to the community to decide. Tonyy Starkk (talk) 19:31, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
  • I guess they have improved a lot over the years in the terms of reliability, but still disparities can be seen. I would like to support option 2. Harshit Kumar (talk) 20:32, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Option 3: Adding a few pages about their authors, ethics and methodology does not instantly make them reliable. Every unreliable source could do the same. IMO, it does not make sense (to me, at least) for a team of three to analyse and publish the box office collections of a country that produces 1500 to 2000 feature films per year, unless the entire platform is automated in some way without any oversight. Adding to the volume of auto-generated articles they publish, I do not feel comfortable deeming them anywhere close to being reliable.Jeraxmoira🐉 (talk) 05:01, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
    I guess it is obvious that it is an automated platform and I dont think any tracker would be manually feeding in numbers for 1000s of films, but the algorithm/pipeline handling them entirely.
    For oversight they have mentioned details in correction policy on how they handle errors. Tonyy Starkk (talk) 05:25, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
    You are starting to bludgeon this discussion by commenting on almost all the opposing views here. Oversight isn't what you think it is and it is certainly not only about correcting their wrongly published data. Jeraxmoira🐉 (talk) 06:15, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
    Sorry if my replies came across as excessive, i was just trying to explain my reasoning. I will step back and let the discussion continue. Tonyy Starkk (talk) 06:53, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Option 2: Information published by Sacnilk should not be treated as definitive, officially verified, or independently audited box-office figures. Such information should be presented as estimates or claims attributed to Sacnilk, using phrases such as "According to Sacnilk" or "Sacnilk reported/claimed." Additional verification and cross-referencing with other credible industry sources are necessary before drawing conclusions about a film's actual box-office performance. Needforname (talk) 06:58, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
    That should be required for the other sources that are accepted too then, because none of those criteria apply to them either. ChompyTheGogoat [ Bleat | Munched ] 07:18, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Option 2 per Teegarden's Star b. It can be used but with attribution. Segaton (talk) 23:12, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Option 2 per above. Mostly because I'm still not convinced of that editorial team. Sacnilk.com is not fully reliable and I'd still put them under WP:BLOG. But they are becoming quite mainstream now and a lot of WP:FRUIT instances are popping up. They are almost nearing the WP:PINKVILLA status now. So I'd advice a proceed with caution for now. All Sacnilk.com figures must be supported with another INDY reference/attribution. — Benison (Beni · talk) 11:40, 14 November 2026 (UTC)

Discussion (Sacnilk)

I would encourage editors participating to have a look at the previous discussions linked, to get the entire context and better understanding of the issue. Tonyy Starkk (talk) 16:50, 5 November 2026 (UTC)

The other sources still need to be re-examined too. There's no current evidence that any of them are more reliable than each other. And it all might be moot if the topic area is placed under ECR and we quit reporting them entirely, which is a better outcome. ChompyTheGogoat [ Bleat | Munched ] 23:29, 5 November 2026 (UTC)
I really think the best outcome would be the removal of box office returns from the majority of movie pages. Simonm223 (talk) 14:17, 6 November 2026 (UTC)

@Tonyy Starkk: I see you have left notifications about this RfC for some editors who participated in the WT:ICTF#Reassessment of Sacnilk.com discussion but not all of them. Be sure to invite everyone per WP:CANVASS. S0091 (talk) 14:45, 9 November 2026 (UTC)

Yeah sure will do. Tonyy Starkk (talk) 14:51, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
S0091, I have invited everyone, if you think anyone is missed please let me know. Tonyy Starkk (talk) 15:06, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
Great! Looks like you got everyone. S0091 (talk) 15:20, 9 November 2026 (UTC)

A Sharp Eye on Butterflies of Ghana

I wish to establish that a book I have helped co-author can be considered a 'Reliable source'. Users have, understandably, raided Conflict of Interest Issues. I have collaborated on a self-published book with the world's leading authority on West African butterfly species. The electronic version of the book is a free download. We were not able to find an independent publisher as the book is not-for-profit. The publication is endorsed by The Lepidopterists Society of Africa and the African Butterfly Research Institute. Thank you. Charlesjsharp (talk) 11:41, 8 November 2026 (UTC)

This discussion may help readers here to understand the motivation for this request. – Jonesey95 (talk) 13:30, 8 November 2026 (UTC)
Congrats on the book, Charles! To add some context for folks, Charles is perhaps our most prolific Wikipedian wildlife photographer, and has spent a lot of time compiling free, CC-licensed, Commons-hosted educational resources about wildlife photography. I'm glad to see that work expanding to book-length projects with scientists. Issues regarding COI/RS aside, that's a remarkable contribution and the first time I've heard of such a project.
Trying to parse this thread, it looks like the main disputed edits were these, which includes a move to a new species name. It sounds like the authority for the new binomial is Libert, but that wasn't one of the cited sources, and I think many editors hold article titles to require a higher burden of sourcing than merely updating an article. As to RS of your book, it sounds like Sáfián meets the WP:SPS line, by an established subject-matter expert, whose work in the relevant field has previously been published by reliable, independent publications. On COI, we do permit COI edits when they're properly disclosed. The thing is, they draw a lot of skepticism/cynicism, so it's done at the editor's own peril, and mistakes are going to be treated more harshly than mistakes would otherwise. I'd be especially careful when adding article text like "The 'Larsen' numbers have since been used with permission in A Sharp Eye on Butterflies of Ghana", which seems unusual. I appreciate the intent -- your book is freely accessible while other scientific sources often are not -- but it's going to raise eyebrows.
In total, my advice at this stage would just be to be careful and propose changes on the talk page first when your book is involved, then if there are no objects implement them a few days later. I'm guessing, given there are generally fewer available sources about niche African wildlife than some other parts in the world, that there are probably many updates you can implement with the book, and I'm wary of filling up the COI edit queue when most of those are likely going to be uncontroversial. — Rhododendrites talk \\ 14:14, 8 November 2026 (UTC)
Thank you for your contribution Rhododendrites. When Wikipedia could benefit from the work of THE world expert, I struggle to understand the motivation of these editors. Charlesjsharp (talk) 11:41, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
To be blunt, for starters we've had a lot of people who think they've the world experts on something who have utterly ruined articles. Or who use a source by some nutter who with crazy ideas who they're convinced is the real expert and ruin articles. Etc etc. I don't think this is you, but some dude just saying they or their colleague is an expert and we should trust them is not reassuring. In fact it raises major concerns. As I said below, anyone who genuinely wants to contribute productively should both be able politely reassure us they are indeed an expert (or their colleague or whatever). We'd also normally expect they would have no reason to behave so poorly when questioned since want to improve things here so are happy to address any all all reasonable concerns so they can contribute and improve rather than just have their own way which is what we assume when an editor behaves poorly when questioned. To be fair, you wouldn't be the first genuine expert to have had problems understanding how the norms of Wikipedia differ from what they're used to and that we're not going to accept their right just because they're an expert and that even if they seem to genuinely want to improve things, there can still be COI concerns. And personally I generally try to be very careful in how I respond to such editors understanding why it can seem offensive when you question them when they have good reason to be sure they're correct on what they're saying and especially if you suggest they are not an expert. But ultimately all editors are going to be respond in their own way & as I said below it's your responsibility to deal with any and all legitimate concerns which all so far seem to have been. Also in this case, you don't have the excuse that most have that you're new to this. You should be familiar by now with how things work here. So the fact you've behaved so poorly in response to reasonable questions and concerns over your edits raises very major red flags. Nil Einne (talk) 13:01, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
In addition, when changing a species' article to update genus assignment, it's probably best to have both to outgoing and incoming genus articles updated first. In this case, I'd suggest starting the discussion on the relevant WikiProject talk page, with pointers to the discussion from the talk pages of both genera. Once that's accepted, you can then update those pages and all of the relevant species' articles, pointing back to that accepted discussion. (So... WP Lepidoptera would be the relevant project, but you might also want a pointer from WP Insects as well.) - In solidarity, UtherSRG (talk) 15:39, 8 November 2026 (UTC)
propose changes on the talk page first when your book is involved, then if there are no objects implement them a few days later I would say this is insufficient as many insect (especially African insect) species articles have no one watching their talk pages - better to propose such changes at WP:INSECTS or the like, where editors will actually see it - but for taxon name changes, I cannot see any scenario in which this book is a sufficient source to base a page move on. No context is provided for any of the taxonomic placements. Ethmostigmus 🌿 (talk | contribs) 02:18, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
That nobody is watching an article isn't a very good reason not to try to improve it, COI or not. Perhaps Charles could post a single heads-up to the insects group, and then anyone who wants to verify his edits can check his contribs. — Rhododendrites talk \\ 13:09, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
I agree with Rhododendrites. I don't think it should be necessary to tell the WikiProject each time. If there's consensus the source is an RS then the suggestion of asking first and if there's no response just making the edit, seems fine. That said editors are always responsible for their. If no one responds but editors later notice significant problems with their edits, having asked first does not mean it's okay. And the presence of a COI is likely to mean mistakes are seen more harshly. Nil Einne (talk) 14:08, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
The reason I suggest discussion at a WikiProject rather than a low traffic talk page is both because there is an inherent conflict of interest and because these edits have already proven controversial among several editors. I haven't counted but it appears that Charles has made hundreds of near-identical edits to butterfly articles citing his own self-published work to add the following text: Torben Larsen developed a species numbering system for his 2005 publication Butterflies of West Africa. This species is #[number] The 'Larsen' numbers have since been used with permission in A Sharp Eye on Butterflies of Ghana. In some edits he added this text and removed existing references (dead but archived and fixable links - I checked), leaving paragraphs of important information like distribution without any citations: see Special:Diff/1383185817, Special:Diff/1383184181, Special:Diff/1383078790, Special:Diff/1383072549. These edits do not constitute actual improvements to any of these articles and seem to serves no purpose other than to promote Charles' book. There are so many of these edits that I cannot individually check them all, but every single one I have spot checked fits this pattern of pure self-promotion with optional ref removal - if someone else is willing to step up and help me go though them, I would appreciate it, but currently in the absence of any actually informative content in these edits I am inclined to roll them back. Ethmostigmus 🌿 (talk | contribs) 04:45, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
I'm not sure how a link to Wikispecies is meant to indicate that an individual is an "leading authority", but that aside, while self-publishing a field guide is not terribly problematic, this book is a pictoral guide. It is not an academic research publication. The entries on the species themselves provide only an image for identification purposes, the sex of the pictured animal, its binomial and common name, and a location. This is information useful for someone trying to identify a butterfly they've seen, but it is not sufficient information with which to add much of anything to a Wikipedia article - at best, one could make an argument for using the book as a source for a taxon's current name, but I find even that a bit tenuous. It is not an appropriate source for taxonomy. Ethmostigmus 🌿 (talk | contribs) 02:08, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
Now you are being silly. You state that a 'link to Wikispecies is meant to indicate that an individual is an "leading authority"'. Yes it does. If you go to that page you will see a comprehensive list of published papers. What more could you need? Just what are you trying to achieve for Wikipedia?
Furthermore, Jonesey95 is reverting my edits on species like Pentila phidia where there is no taxonomy change. Charlesjsharp (talk) 11:26, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
IMO it was reasonable for Jonesey95 to be concerned when you sourced anything to a self-published book that you were involved in. That naturally raises two concerns, while SPS can be used they need to be by experts and with care. Also there's going to be a lot of scrutiny when something is sourced to someone was involved in given COI concerns. Per Rhododendrites, this doesn't mean it can be done. But it needs to be done with great care. And if editors raise concerns it's your responsibility to answer them satisfactorily. It may be that consensus here establishes that your book can be treated as an expert SPS for some or all things which will reduce one concern although COI still needs to be dealt with. And I'll be blunt that whatever your contributions to both Wikipedia and the field, if you try to blame others for raising reasonable concerns which is that Jonesey95 and Ethmostigmus seem to have done, you will lose that argument. I'm fairly sure even Rhododendrites will agree with that. This doesn't mean that the community will ultimately agree with there concerns. But it if they are reasonable with how they handle their concerns and their concerns are in good faith, which seems to apply to both of then, then an editor making it like these editors were wrong to raise concerns when they tried to use an SPS they were involved in without being willing to deal with legitimate concerns over such things, is not going to be perceived well. Or let put it a different way, if you are right that your book is an expert SPS and you're right that what you did wasn't a problem, why aren't you willing to politely address the concerns others have raised rather than blaming them for raising them? It should be easy if you're right and there's no reason to fault others. If others really did make mistakes, then everyone else will be able to see it without you the person with a COI being the one to raise the issue. Nil Einne (talk) 12:40, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
And just to be clear, even if come the conclusion that that edit of yours or any edit of yours can be reinstated, that the book is fine to use, or that your colleague is an expert. it doesn't mean any of us are going to say either of the or any editors were wrong to raise such concerns or that you shouldn't have needed to deal with such concerns. Nil Einne (talk) 12:58, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
I'm fairly sure even Rhododendrites will agree with that. Even Rhododendrites, yes. :) I think we can get to the bottom of this and make it usable, but it's important to realize that COI + SPS = walking on eggshells even with the best of intentions. — Rhododendrites talk \\ 13:17, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
When I raised this topic, I said "Users have, understandably, raided Conflict of Interest Issues." I did not, as you say above "try to blame others for raising reasonable concerns". I have submitted unequivocal evidence that my co-author is an expert. I got frustrated with subsequent posts and unjustified reverts while this discussion was in progress. Charlesjsharp (talk) 17:59, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
Even with the qualifier that your co-author is an expert in the field, the publication of this book does not mean that the scientific consensus has shifted to accept all of the names it describes. There has to be broader evidence to justify moving page names, and even the text that has been inserted in several pages "Torben Larsen developed a species numbering system for his 2005 publication Butterflies of West Africa. This species is #[...]" is not warranted in most places - it does not impart encyclopedic information to the reader (they are unlikely to have a copy of Butterflies of West Africa, so what would they do with this numbering system?) and reads as serving to promote the books' authors rather than any useful data about the species they looked up. As someone who contributed to part of the interview questions for an upcoming Signpost article here I got a little bothered by your answers; what is a reader going to learn about WP:TOL from this? -- Reconrabbit (talk) 15:06, 12 November 2026 (UTC)

Is Jason Colavito an expert WP:SPS on pseudoscience, conspiracy theories and fringe beliefs?

Jason Colavito has repeatedly been discussed here, generally favorably, but continues to come up on article Talk pages. Is there a general orientation that we have with respect to his usability as an expert SPS?

In backgroundsummary of points raised in prior discussions and presented here for general background only and not as a recitation of reasons he is or is not an expert SPS:

Chetsford (talk) 20:58, 10 November 2026 (UTC); edited 21:23, 10 November 2026 (UTC)

Subject matter expertise is determined by independent publishing being accepted in their respective fields, not so much quotes and references. So the books on pseudoscience suggest expertise in pseudoscience. I'm not sure his column at the new republic suggests expertise. We don't do that for all columnists. --Kyohyi (talk) 21:17, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
To clarify, this is a general, bulleted, background summary of Colavito condensed from prior discussions, not a list of reasons he should or should not be considered an expert SPS. I apologize for presenting it without better clarification. Chetsford (talk) 21:20, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
And there might be more information that suggests one way or the other on the other subjects. Just from the information presented I see evidence he could be an expert for pseudoscience. --Kyohyi (talk) 21:24, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
I think yes, he could be considered an expert SPS. That being said, it depends on the context, I would be somewhat careful and cite with attribution Ar1201u1 (talk) 04:11, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
He's been published by reliable sources as an expert in the field, Cult of Alien Gods was published by Simon and Schuster and The Mound Builder Myth: Fake History and the Hunt for a “Lost White Race.” published by OUPress and received positive academic reviews. I think it's enough that editors opposed would need to explain why they think he shouldn't be considered reliable. -- LCU ActivelyDisinterested «@» °∆t° 14:25, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
Thanks, Ar1201u1, Kyohyi, ActivelyDisinterested; since this seems to crop-up repeatedly here without a clear resolution, I created an RfC below. Chetsford (talk) 04:16, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
Where has it come up? PARAKANYAA (talk) 01:32, 13 November 2026 (UTC)

RfC: Is Jason Colavito an expert WP:SPS on the subjects of pseudoscience and conspiracy theories?

Is Jason Colavito an expert WP:SPS on the subjects of pseudoscience and conspiracy theories?
(Alternative options presented since Colavito is a single person to whom the normal selection of options don't coherently apply.)

  • Option 1: Yes, and generally usable within the limits of expert SPS (i.e. not appropriate for WP:BLPs) on the topics of pseudoscience and conspiracy theories.
  • Option 2: No, not an expert SPS.
  • Option 3: Other

Chetsford (talk) 04:16, 12 November 2026 (UTC)

  • Option 1 for reasons described in the preceding discussion by other participants. Chetsford (talk) 04:16, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Option 1: following the discussion in the earlier thread, and for two specific reasons: 1. He has published several books (some by known reputable publications, others SPS), 2. other reliable sources treat him as an expert, if we consider them reliable, then we should rely on their assessment. Also, one could be self-taught and become an expert (see autodidacticism). We can cite him for pseudoscience and conspiracy theories. If there's something contentious, cite with attribution and then the readers can decide whether they want to treat him as an expert
Ar1201u1 (talk) 05:50, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Option 1 based on the books (including ones published by an academic press with reviews in journals), supported by the repeated citations in major news media. nf utvol (talk) 13:34, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Why would we need an RfC on this?
I mean, given that he's published books with reputable publishers and this is not a massively competitive field, it seems fine, so 1 if we must, but why? Every discussion I've found disputing him is on BLP articles, which we couldn't use anyway. PARAKANYAA (talk) 14:42, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
  • I lean towards option 1, but since this topic area can be contentious, I recommend always attributing Colavito's self-published statements or opinions inline. Toadspike [Talk] 10:42, 13 November 2026 (UTC)

Benjamin Hall, 1st Baron Llanover

The article for Benjamin Hall, 1st_Baron Llanover contains many references that are the subject of Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Perennial sources/all/Findmypast for which literary sources could alternatively be cited. I am unfamiliar with the current state of discussions about Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Perennial sources/all/Findmypast. Consequently, I should be grateful for feedback about the possibility that I have identified. Also, more widely, the references for the article are disproportinately non-literary, about which a tag doesn't seem to currently exist. Consequently, if my observation is relevant here, I should also be grateful for feedback about it. John Desmond (talk) 12:50, 11 November 2026 (UTC)

FindMyPast contains two different sections. The first is user generated articles and family trees that are not reliable, the other is a collection of primary sources (old newspapers, birth and death certificates, rolls, etc). The primary sources are probably reliable, it will depend on the particular source. Secondary sources are preferred, and articles shouldn't usually overly rely on primary sources, but a primary sources isn't unreliable just because it's primary. Editors also shouldn't interpret, analyse, or synthesis primary sources, as that's the role of secondary sources and risk being original research. -- LCU ActivelyDisinterested «@» °∆t° 14:35, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
Thank you very much for your response to my post, which was very helpful. John Desmond (talk) 19:38, 13 November 2026 (UTC)

Global Project Against Hate and Extremism

Just to note, I have been on the side of such "advocacy orgs" as the Southern Poverty Law Center, Anti-Defamation League, and Hope not Hate/Searchlight being generally reliable. Global Project Against Hate and Extremism (GPAHE) is another such source. However, the difference is that GPAHE is... bad. Unlike the SPLC and ADL, which have decades of history and use by others, GPAHE was quite recently established, and unlike those groups, its accuracy and fact checking is frequently dubious.

It also has quite the unfortunate habit of (unattributed!) copying from Wikipedia articles, as I have had to explain a few times (see this AfD ( where I go into more detail for a few examples); this is in part on a piece that we are citing multiple times onwiki). They have copied articles that I have personally written multiple times. And this is just what I've noticed because I look up obscure topics I've edited about to see who has copied it.

It is like the SPLC but with all of the issues and none of the actually good journalism. Anything on older materials I've seen is usually copied from the other, better anti-hate groups, or is copied from Wikipedia. Anything on new stuff is basically just regurgitated from some minor telegram channel or website with little fact checking beyond reciting what it says. In my experience their fact checking is quite poor and they do not have an obvious or decent editorial policy on their website. Also, a lot of their articles feel AI-assisted to me but I haven't dug too deep on that one.

See for example, this piece, the article is full of tons of sloppy errors and weird decisions. For example, its basis for its claims about Destiny (streamer) 15-year-old teenage son's... activities are simply recited from a twitter post made by someone else and the terrible SEO slop news site WP:SPORTSKEEDA. This article is also full of a ton of minor sloppy errors (saying Siege inspired Christchurch, a claim no reliable source has ever made, for one of several without getting too into the weeds for those unfamiliar with the topic area). Also it reads a lot like it was AI-assisted.

Most of the articles I've found from them are full of things like this... they are just generally sloppy about their matter of claimed expertise in a way the ADL and SPLC are not. Every other article they write feels like they asked Claude to summarize the contents of a 20 subscriber Telegram channel.

Given these issues and the undisclosed Wikipedia copying, am I correct in believing this is not a generally reliable source? They are cited a few dozen times onwiki. PARAKANYAA (talk) 20:57, 11 November 2026 (UTC)

Repeatedly plagiarizing from Wikipedia is enough to make a source GUNREL in my view. Thank you for your investigation. ARoseThorn (talk) 22:26, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
They have some use by others, but in a recent discussion when asked how much undisclosed copying from Wikipedia makes a sources unreliable I replied "any" (but that's wasn't universally held opinion). The issue is if the copying is undisclosed we don't know what has or hasn't been copied. Editors having to investigate each article and check it against current and past Wikipedia content is something that means a source isn't generally reliable. It might be their opinion is noteworthy if secondary sources have reported on them. -- LCU ActivelyDisinterested «@» °∆t° 13:50, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
Yeah, if secondary sources report on their opinion, no issue on reporting it. But that also goes for sources like us, like Wikipedia - our opinion is referenced on Daily Mail, after all. Their "reports" are better than their "posts", to be sure, which is what all of those works that do cite them seem to be citing.
Relative to the volume of scholarship on the far-right and the way those sources tend to be used I don't think the case is great even if judging from USEBYOTHERS; especially in this topic, the informational environment tends to be weird (e.g. there's a lot more use by others for actual neo-nazi publications in this context, versus the handful of citations to GPAHE. most of the mentions of the organization in the scholarly literature are mentioning it in reference to one of its founders rather than citing it). Or in the counterterrorism literature are there is a lot of rather uncritical use of contentious government reports and so on, which does not necessarily make those reports reliable. It depends on the ways they are used and in what context.
Their Wikipedia copying / frequent AI use is sort of a microcosm of their overall sloppiness and frequent factual inaccuracy. And I am not saying to totally ban them, if they produce a specific report that is well regarded or well cited maybe that could be used. This is why I did not say "am I correct in believing they are generally unreliable", but rather "this is not a generally reliable source". But I've seen people try to support notability with it or very contentious allegations when they seem dubious. PARAKANYAA (talk) 14:30, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
The use by others (especially in reputable published sources by individuals who have good reputations in appropriate fields of study) makes it a bit more unusual. But I lean with ActivelyDisinterested, if they are copying from Wikipedia articles in an undisclosed manner, then we can't be citing them in our articles. If there is some relevance through their citations by other sources, we can cite them instead. -- Cdjp1 (talk) 09:21, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
Speaking more broadly, even if the case for that was better (and looking at the sources that use it and how it is used, I don't think it is strong evidence; For example, the first source listed is from the creator of GPAHE, Heidi Beirich, Out of Hiding seems to mostly be citing attributed quotes from her, the NBC news source is just saying they exist and have written reports?), WP:USEBYOTHERS is only one indication of a source's reliability. We declared the ADL not generally reliable on antisemitism despite it being probably the single most cited outlet on antisemitism. Plenty of sources we declare generally unreliable have very widespread use by others. PARAKANYAA (talk) 21:19, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
That is true, to further clarify my point of If there is some relevance through their citations by other sources, this is, as you highlighted, dependent on exactly how they are used by others. If all other sources do is highlight existence, or quote specific people involved with them, and these themselves have no relevance to the articles where we may potentially cite GPAHE, then we can easily do without mentioning the opinion of material from GPAHE. -- Cdjp1 (talk) 01:14, 15 November 2026 (UTC)

Reconsidering ZDNET and CNET

Most relevant previous discussion on the noticeboard:

From limited participation, most say that CNET and ZDNET are no longer generally unreliable since their re-acquisition by Ziff Davis, as they no longer use AI authored content as policy. (The AI Policy of both CNET and ZDNET say that they don’t use AI to write content, but may use it for transcription or note-taking.) However, they have an overly promotional tone, and are incentivized to get readers to buy products through their affiliate links.

Both CNET and ZDNET have good-sounding editorial guidelines, asserting editorial independence from the subjects they cover. Reading a few of the most recent articles from both sources (CNET: 1, 2, 3, 4; ZDNET: 1, 2, 3, 4), nothing stands out as incorrect. However, the first two articles for CNET are indeed very promotional, not giving any criticism or downsides of the technology (possibly because the reporters got “exclusive” access and don’t want to jeopardize their in with the companies?)

From my brief foray into both websites, I think they are between MREL and GENREL, with ZDNET slightly better than CNET. The reviews and cover stories seem reliable, but anything under “/deals/” shouldn’t be used. I don’t know if a RFC is called for, but I’m certainly open to it. ARoseThorn (talk) 22:19, 11 November 2026 (UTC)

If there is a assessment of somewhere between MREL and GENREL, then MREL wins according to me (making this comment without examining sources and doing an assessment on merit, just what I would do) Ar1201u1 (talk) 04:27, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
I don't think it's something that needs a RFC, editors good judgement should be that anything in the deals section should be considered less than independent and so somewhat dubious. Interestingly both are still listed as unreliable on the RSP. The only RFC on them appears to have been the one about Red Ventures, rather than about them specifically. -- LCU ActivelyDisinterested «@» °∆t° 14:02, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
The reason for an RFC is that I want to change the color of CNET and ZDNET from red to yellow (or green, but probably yellow), but I don't want to do that without getting consensus. ARoseThorn (talk) 22:41, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Sorry, but BEFORERFC suggests otherwise. And I would bet 2 to 1 that the Rfc will keep the colors as they are. Yesterday, all my dreams... (talk) 05:13, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
I'm hoping this whole thread counts as Asking for input or assistance at a relevant content noticeboard per WP:RFCBEFORE. I remain unsure whether an RFC would be useful. ARoseThorn (talk) 03:33, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Generally unreliable. "Note-taking" with AI is using AI to write your content. It doesn't matter if the slop is partially written by a human. Cortador (talk) 23:33, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
I disagree; from my reading, "note-taking" is more similar to the use of AI for audio transcription than article generation. They explicitly say that all of the writing in the articles is done by a human. ARoseThorn (talk) 01:13, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
+1 Hason-LEK-SIN ● 💬 ● 🧱 ● 🧪 07:55, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
ZDNET states that they are "streamlining information" via AI and mention other vaguely defined uses. It doesn't matter if a human types in the words if the template is slop. Cortador (talk) 23:13, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
What if every other news site uses even just 1% of AI? Would you make them unreliable without taking a second look? Given the current state of AI (making fewer hallucinations than last time), many (reputable) outlets use some form of AI in the process, with guardrails in place to fact check and verify its output, and ultimately not write directly with AI. If you want 100% no AI use in the newsroom, chances are the news outlets are few to none. Keeping that "100% no AI" mindset is unworkable in the long run (regardless of how the world got here without the use of AI with respect to the "ban AI because before COVID we could all do our lives without AI" rebuttal). Hason-LEK-SIN ● 💬 ● 🧱 ● 🧪 04:47, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
Yet another case of someone straight up not reading everything else when they see "AI" and just saying "NO" like excuse me? Hason-LEK-SIN ● 💬 ● 🧱 ● 🧪 07:54, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
I actually planned to ask this question with a draft at my Sandbox talk. Anyway, after they were aquired by Ziff Davis, I don't remember seeing them make any falsehoods. CNET's One More Thing is also pretty informative. I suggest you boldly start the RFC! Hason-LEK-SIN ● 💬 ● 🧱 ● 🧪 07:52, 13 November 2026 (UTC)

Antique Trader

Hello. I am currently working on an article on the Letty Lynton dress, and I stumbled across the following online article from Antique Trader, The Letty Lynton Dress Took Country By Storm. I am unfamiliar with this publication, and I could not find anything about this in the noticeboard archives. Would this source be considered reliable for a Wikipedia article? Thank you in advance for the help! Aoba47 (talk) 17:47, 12 November 2026 (UTC)

For some reason, there is no author bio for this article (they have for other articles, and for the ones I checked, they seem to qualify as experts/professionals in the field of antiques or journalism). I am inclined to say can be treated as reliable, because other articles would be treated as reliable based on author bios. I think it would help if you could share a little more information about what you want to cite, because assessment would depend on that. If you want to cite an opinion, attribute it as per policy and it should be fine, if you want to cite facts, maybe use better source (however, sometimes there is none for these type of subjects, so we have to use what is available and accessible) Ar1201u1 (talk) 10:10, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
@Ar1201u1: Thank you for your response. Apologies for not clarifying how I would use this source. I was going to cite the author's opinion about how the Letty Lynton dress influenced designers, specifically for Valentino, Karl Lagerfeld for Chanel, and Elie Saab. I would not cite this as a fact, and I would clearly attribute in the prose that this is the author's opinion. I am going to look for further sources on this, but I just wanted to check about the reliability of this particular source if I could not find anything further. Aoba47 (talk) 16:39, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
It seems ok to use. Yesterday, all my dreams... (talk) 11:15, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Thank you for your help! Aoba47 (talk) 16:40, 13 November 2026 (UTC)

Can YesPress be treated as WP:ABOUTSELF?

I used this article for expanding Trove Brands, but once I realized it's a glorified PR agency for companies and people to publish SEO and AI friendly articles, I quickly removed any self-serving claims or analysis which only that article contains. YesPress advertises their services as follows: Your launches, wins, and expertise, written as stories and published to a newsroom of your own. Customers find them. Google indexes them. AI learns from them.

Obviously, that makes them unreliable for verification and unacceptable for establishing notability. But can they be treated as acceptable for WP:ABOUTSELF, essentially the same as e.g. WP:PRNEWSWIRE? feminist🩸 (talk) 07:52, 13 November 2026 (UTC)

I don't see why it shouldn't be treated as a press release, so usable within the limits of ABOUTSELF. -- LCU ActivelyDisinterested «@» °∆t° 15:36, 13 November 2026 (UTC)

RfC - airline booking engines

Are airline booking engines reliable sources in the context of verifying regularly-scheduled airline routes?

"Airline booking engines" in this context are, for example, navigating to ryanair.com or lufthansa.com and making use of the flight planner/booker to search for flights, and using that as a source to verify that a regularly scheduled connection between two airports exists by that airline.

Context: A previous, lengthy, discussion on this topic was held at this noticeboard recently (Archive, and no consensus was able to be reached. Danners430 tweaks made 11:45, 13 November 2026 (UTC)

Survey - booking engines

Not reliable for this specific purpose as opener - airline booking engines have a number of specific issues. First, they normally cannot be archived and the links generated are transient and unique to the reader, meaning no other editor can verify the content. Second, a booking engine will only return results for the specific date selected by the user. Some booking engines show results for a few days before and after the trip - however those systems only show that a method of travel between the two airports exists, you still have to examine each individual result to identify whether the connection recommended is a direct flight by that airline, and doesn't include a stopover or use a codeshare partner. As such, to verify that a flight is regularly scheduled, a user has to make innumerable searches to validate multiple date ranges. This is, by definition, using multiple sources and combining them to come to conclusion not explicitly stated in any of them - WP:SYNTH. Finally, there are WP:OR concerns regarding a user having to search for themselves whether a connection exists (see earlier comment about transient URLs). We don't accept "Google". google.com. as a source for this reason. Danners430 tweaks made 11:45, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Not reliable as used - Danners outlines the issues well. While booking engines do reliably show that a specific flight is scheduled for a specific day, the lack of archiving means that our readers can not verify the information seen by the editor who cited it. They do not verify that flights are regularly scheduled. Add to this the fact that booking engines are for future flights, which might be cancelled. This creates a WP:CRYSTALBALL situation. Blueboar (talk) 12:46, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Reliable as WP:ABOUTSELF Whether a source can be archived has no bearing on its reliability. WP:PUBLISHED simply requires a source to be made available to the public in some form. A searchable, publicly accessible interface meets that criterion. Additionally, audio, video, and multimedia materials that have been recorded then broadcast, distributed, or archived by a reputable party may also meet the necessary criteria to be considered reliable sources. (emphasis mine) The words "distributed" and "or" are critical here. The ability for a source to be archived is only one of three options allowing a source to be considered a "published" source for reliability; a source that is otherwise distributed to the public in some form (e.g., via an airline booking engine) meets that criteria. feminist🩸 (talk) 15:32, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
I agree with this. However, unless it is important to mention for some reason, we should leave flight routes out of articles. They change frequently Ar1201u1 (talk) 18:01, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
That's not a sourcing issue but rather a content issue, and for that matter, I disagree. For readers, the most important aspect of airports (along with other transport infrastructure, such as train stations or bus terminals) is where they can head to from there. feminist🩸 (talk) 04:09, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
  • This will depend on how they're used. Booking engines are reliable primary sources for what they directly support (WP:RSCONTEXT), and editors shouldn't analyse, interpret, it synthesise primary sources (WP:PRIMARY). If they show that a flight goes from A to B ever week, then they support that a flight is regularly scheduled from A to B. If they show that a flight goes from A to B next Tuesday, then they only support that a flight goes from A to B next Tuesday. This is policy rather a issue with a specific source.
    As with any source if they no longer support content, because they are no longer available and no archive available exist (or some other issue), then they {{failed verification}} and should be dealt with a per any other situation were a source fails verification. But that's only an issue once that happens, just because that could be an issue in the future isn't an issue in the present. -- LCU ActivelyDisinterested «@» °∆t° 15:54, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
    In a similar fashion there's WP:ACADEMICCONSENSUS, which states that to say "'x' is the scientific consensus" you need a source that directly states that 'x' is the view of all or most scientists. Simply having a source that states that 'x' is correct isn't enough, as it doesn't directly support a consensus on the matter. -- LCU ActivelyDisinterested «@» °∆t° 22:10, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Two comments -
1) @Feminist: these are airline booking sites (United, Lufthansa, Air France, etc), being used in airport articles (LAX, JFK, Heathrow, etc). Thus, I am not sure that ABOUTSELF applies in this case. The specific airport’s website would be about SELF.
2) @ActivelyDisinterested - re: “If they show that a flight goes from A to B next Tuesday, then they only support that a flight goes from A to B next Tuesday”. That, right there, is the crux of the problem. Booking sites are date specific, so while they might verify “next Tuesday” they are being (improperly) used to verify “regularly scheduled”. Blueboar (talk) 18:33, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Exactly, the schedule could change within minutes based on their algorithm, demand, weather, or a bunch of other factors (engine trouble). I am not sure why this info should be important in an encyclopedic entry. It shouldn't be added unless there is an important reason to include this info Ar1201u1 (talk) 19:03, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Perhaps ABOUTSELF is the wrong shortcut for this, but my point is that airline booking sites are reliable sources for what routes the airline operates. feminist🩸 (talk) 04:11, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
I've struck out the ABOUTSELF part of my comment above. feminist🩸 (talk) 04:12, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Not reliable for the purpose (summoned by bot) per Danners430's arguments. TarnishedPathtalk 23:55, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Not reliable for the purpose of saying that certain airport destinations are "regular" or "seasonal" since saying so is fundamentally original research. Could be ok for verifying that a specific flight has occurred. I generally agree with Danners points. InfernoHues (talk) 21:15, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Bad RfC. The prerequisite for whether a source is reliable or not is that a source actually WP:Glossary#verifies the information it is being offered to support. The question being presented asks us to determine whether or not Airline booking engines ... [are reliable] as a source to verify that a regularly scheduled connection between two airports exists by that airline. Airline booking engines do not and cannot contain the information to verify that a connection between two airports is regularly scheduled, since they do not have this sort of prose commentary.
I disagree with the contention that these sources are being offered up as a source to verify that a regularly scheduled connection between two airports exists by that airline. They are typically being used to verify that a flight was scheduled on a particular day between two airports. Given that the booking engines do not ever contain information that would WP:Directly support whether a route is regularly or seasonally scheduled, they can't possibly contain this information. I don't think this even needs an RfC - they can't support a claim they do not directly support. Before we even consider whether a source is reliable or not, it first has to be determined whether or not the source supports the claim it is being used for.
As an aside, there are many issues with the statements above - there is no requirement that a WP:RS [can] be archived or that the access to the source can't be transient and unique to the reader. The claim that a user having to search something is WP:OR fundamentally makes no sense - there is no aspect of an editor having to type something on a screen that means that the editor is producing or adding material—such as facts, allegations, and ideas—for which no reliable source has ever been published (the definition of WP:OR). A WP:RS could require an editor to physically travel to a bus stop in rural Uganda, much more onerous and difficult to verify than typing a few characters on a screen.Katzrockso (talk) 05:21, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
Having to do a search is not what makes it original research. The original research is when the user is expected to search across multiple dates, and then, as a result of those searches, intuit that the route is "regularly scheduled," even when that's never said. InfernoHues (talk) 05:25, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
That's not what the first comment on the RfC stated - Finally, there are WP:OR concerns regarding a user having to search for themselves whether a connection exists (see earlier comment about transient URLs). We don't accept "Google". google.com. as a source for this reason. Katzrockso (talk) 05:32, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
I know. The above comment is my personal rationale, I don't agree with the first comment on that point; it's not original research to cite a booking engine for the purpose of verifying that a flight was scheduled on a particular day, which I also said in my !vote. InfernoHues (talk) 05:43, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
Stating that The prerequisite for whether a source is reliable or not is that a source actually WP:Glossary#verifies the information it is being offered to support. is only part of the story - reliable sources must do this, yes, but they must also meet our reliable source requirements. If verification of content was the only requirement, we would not be deprecating sources like WP:SIMPLEFLYING… yet we are, because our policies extend beyond simply verifying the content. And in the case of booking engines, even that is in question since it cannot verify the content without falling foul of WP:SYNTH and potentially WP:OR.
You state that They are typically being used to verify that a flight was scheduled on a particular day between two airports. - that’s all well and good, but that’s not what is being asked. These sources do get used to verify whether a route is regularly scheduled - by being placed in tables in airline and airport articles to verify that a connection exists in a routine basis between two airports. That’s not a statement that the flight existed only on date X, it’s a statement that the flight exists on a regular basis. As such using a source that can only verify individual dates is WP:SYNTH. Danners430 tweaks made 09:00, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Not reliable per Danners430. Though I'd go further and say that they aren't a source at all (reliable or otherwise) for any statement other that that doing a search for a particular day produced a particular result - which doesn't even remotely belong in a Wikipedia article. Attempting to present them as anything more isn't just WP:OR, it is complete bullshit. We cite sources for things they say, not for things we would like to pretend they do. AndyTheGrump (talk) 09:24, 15 November 2026 (UTC)

Discussion - booking engines

Why are you launching this RfC now when there is literally an Arbcom case in progress? SportingFlyer T·C 11:50, 13 November 2026 (UTC)

ArbCom does not make decisions regarding content, and an open case shouldn’t prevent normal day-to-day business. The original discussion linked in the statement was opened before the AC case was even proposed, and it was always my intention to get a formal consensus on this topic regardless. Danners430 tweaks made 11:53, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
I fear this will end up being a mess (and horrendous to close), but Arbcom doesn't have a say other content. -- LCU ActivelyDisinterested «@» °∆t° 15:57, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Ultimately, we will need another RFC to determine the underlying question: are “destinations” considered encyclopedic information…
If the answer to that is “yes” then we will need a follow-up RFC to ask: where this information should be listed? (a) airport articles, (b) airline articles, (c) both or (d) neither. I have seen good arguments for and against all four options. The community will need to decide. Blueboar (talk) 18:53, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
We’ve already had that, at WP:VPP. I can’t easily get a more direct link right now, but all RfCs on this topic are listed at WP:AIRPORT-CONTENT. I may not agree with the outcome but I abide by it… hence my desire to ensure that where we have routes listed, we source them in accordance with our sourcing policies. Danners430 tweaks made 18:58, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Anything like that would be beyond the scope of this noticeboard. -- LCU ActivelyDisinterested «@» °∆t° 21:58, 13 November 2026 (UTC)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bruno_van_Pottelsberghe Consider a Notice on wall. looks like self-written with lot of self promo

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bruno_van_Pottelsberghe

Most cited sources appear to be self-authored, self-published, or drawn from publications of questionable credibility and limited academic standing. I have therefore removed some of these sources.

In particular, I have concerns about the objectivity and independence of the material published about Bruno. It appears that his profile may have been personally prepared or commissioned and subsequently disseminated through a media agency engaged by the university. Given that universities often engage external media agencies for promotional purposes, there is a possibility that such profiles are designed to enhance an individual's public image rather than provide an independently verified and balanced account of their achievements. Alternatively, the material may have been prepared internally by his subordinates in his capacity as Rector.

I believe it is important to distinguish between independently verified achievements reported by credible third-party sources and promotional content that may have been influenced by the individual or the institution concerned.

See the changes I made and explanations given in the history section of his page.

THERE WAS NO EVIDENCE/SOURCE THAT HE WORKED AT COLOMBIA UNI ETC. He added that info his own, bec Colombia is a brand....Perhaps he got rector job by adding all these inof artificially... OECD source was his own write-up about him...

He advertised that he was MBA academic director for 10 years, but the source gave no info about the years at all. Moreover, the source was a self-published source on his own college website Drfestival (talk) 12:47, 13 November 2026 (UTC)

More a BLP or AFD issue. Slatersteven (talk) 12:56, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
I agree probably best to take this to WP:BLP/N, also important to remember that primary non-independent sources are still reliable in a limited way per WP:ABOUTSELF. -- LCU ActivelyDisinterested «@» °∆t° 15:38, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Please consider this for WP: BLP/N. I don't know how to do such things because I'm relatively new. He is sourcing info from his own CV. Drfestival (talk) 16:06, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Sourcing something to a something like a CV is fine in some cases, see WP:ABOUTSELF. Basically people are reliable about themselves within certain limits (it's not promotional, or exceptional for example).
This is the noticeboard for discussing the reliability of a source, while WP:BLP/N is the noticeboard for discussing articles about living people. You're question is more about the state of the article than the reliability of any particular source.
It's never a problem to not know something, we all started that way. Asking questions is always encouraged. -- LCU ActivelyDisinterested «@» °∆t° 17:29, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
@Drfestival, the subject of the article is a professor and rector and the notability requirements are in Wikipedia:Notability (academics). What to use as sources is described there: Once the passage of one or more notability criteria has been verified through independent sources, or through the reliable sources listed explicitly for this purpose in the specific criteria notes, non-independent sources, such as official institutional and professional sources, are widely accepted as reliable sourcing for routine, uncontroversial details. StarryGrandma (talk) 16:14, 14 November 2026 (UTC)

Manual of Style for adding pronunciations in Pikachu

Moved to WT:VG#Manual of Style for adding pronunciations in Pikachu. Izno (talk) 15:38, 14 November 2026 (UTC)

The Free Press, Abdul El Sayed, and AI generated photograph

Currently, the source is used in at least 200 places in article space.

It was making the claim that Abdul El Sayed delivered his victory speech in arabic (which was community noted immediately, as about only 4 arabic words were used, or 0.27% of speech); additionally the outlet used ChatGPT to photoshop luxury goods including "Valentino shoes and a Chanel handbag" onto various staff and attendees at a party attended by El Sayed. . Actually arab news claims thefp chief of staff originally defended the choice, though CJR says the post was given a correction before being taken down?

CJR actually says that one journalist stated that Weiss saw the whole issue as a real conversation even if the photograph was AI. User:Bluethricecreamman (Talk·Contribs) 05:08, 14 November 2026 (UTC)

The post by the chief editor:

@seantfischer (November 5, 2026). "@Olivia_Reingold the odds of one being wrong when one tries to land a dig on Olivia are so astronomically high it's ridic. U r the only fashion critic we need Olivia ❤️🔥" (Tweet). Archived from the original on 5 November 2026 – via X (formerly Twitter).

I don't see anything in the CJR piece that says the photo, posted on Reingold's personal Twitter account (not the outlet), was taken down; the video was, with the following correction:

@TheFP (November 8, 2026). "We deleted an opinion video about the use of foreign languages in election night speeches. The post contained a factual error and its tone fell short of what we believe advances healthy public discourse. The rigorous editorial process that produces the work that appears on our website and in our newsletters must apply to everything we post on social media. We'll be updating how we do things to achieve just that. We regret the error" (Tweet). Archived from the original on 8 November 2026 – via X (formerly Twitter).

I also don't know what you mean by Weiss saw the whole issue as a real conversation, though. ARoseThorn (talk) 23:22, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
The specific photo editing involved, as far as I can tell, taking a real photograph and asking ChatGPT to "brighten and sharpen" it (in Reingold's words) rather than generating a completely fake image (or add fake items to a real image), so I don't think you can quite categorize it as photoshop[ping] luxury goods including "Valentino shoes and a Chanel handbag" onto various staff and attendees, though it's not something that should be passed off as authentic, for the same reason it's not allowed on Wikipedia.
All I feel comfortable concluding all from this is that there's no way The FP could be generally reliable unless they drastically change their editorial process and standards for employees. ARoseThorn (talk) 23:37, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
Free Press is already primarily opinion, so I would already say we should avoid using it when possible (WP:RSBIAS is an allowance, not a recommendation). I agree with ARoseThorn that at best, this is not a generally reliable source. It's complicated by the fact that it's owned by CBS, which does have a record of good editorial oversight; I'm curious whether Free Press still maintains its own autonomous editorial staff. Thebiguglyalien (talk) 01:32, 15 November 2026 (UTC)

A Times of India article

Specifically this article, which I want to use to rewrite Hindustan Photo Films at User:Nighfidelity/sandbox. Would it generally reliable for the info it includes? Nighfidelity (talk) 02:33, 15 November 2026 (UTC)

I think the article is technically from the Times News Network (TNN), a news agency started by The Times of India; I have no idea how that affects its reliability, however. It seems fine to me... ARoseThorn (talk) 03:18, 15 November 2026 (UTC)